Why do you think because I'm a Cards fan that I think Cueto shouldve been dropped? Obviously I'm the only one. He didnt get dropped. You guys act as if what I say goes. It obviously doesn't. I was just going off of his record and ERA since I can't watch the Reds game in and game out. Admittedly, I do not look into sabermetrics too much so I'll admit I was mislead by his record.
As for us Cards fans holding a grudge against him, we don't like any Reds player (except Votto. Who can hate the guy?) so the fact he ended one of our players careers, albeit Jason Larue, he still ended his career. Like I said, I respect him but I don't like him. I respect Phillips' glove but I don't like the guy. Thats what rivalries are all about. Mutual respect as well as a mutual hate. I'm sure many people didn't like Pujols when he was still with us. It wasn't because he was overrated or a dirty player, he was just so good and burnt so many teams over the years it was hard to like him.