Honest Assessment of NCAA 10

[2krules]

An honest assessment of NCAA 10 cannot be made by anyone who has not played it.

[deaduck]

Quote: Originally Posted by boxtrev

From what I have seen and read.

That's like deciding which tastes better, Post's 100% Bran or Kellogg's All Bran, by looking at and reading the box.

[jfsolo]

LOL, whenever some starts off a post/thread with "Honest Assessment", its a 100% mortal lock that they're going to bash the hell out of a game.

Its as if people who love a game can recognize that how they feel about a game is just their opinion, but those who hate a game are convinced that what they feel is the undeniable truth.

"No, no I'm not bashing, its just an 'Honest Assessment', really"

[ProjectSRT]

Quote: Originally Posted by deaduck

That's like deciding which tastes better, Post's 100% Bran or Kellogg's All Bran, by looking at and reading the box.

Yea, if you are talking about gameplay and gameplay alone. These games need more than just gameplay adjustments. Elements like that you CAN see before you play the game, and its those elements we havent seen in NCAA 2010 that we are seeing in Madden 2010.

[LucianoJJ]

We won't be able to make a final judgment on both NCAA and Madden 10 until September. By then, both games will be patched, the first series of bugs will be dealt with, and people will have found all the exploits and glitches.

[deaduck]

Quote: Originally Posted by ProjectSRT

Elements like that you CAN see before you play the game, and its those elements we havent seen in NCAA 2010 that we are seeing in Madden 2010.

What ? Like handwarmers?

[doctorhay53]

Quote: Originally Posted by jfsolo

LOL, whenever some starts off a post/thread with "Honest Assessment", its a 100% mortal lock that they're going to bash the hell out of a game. Its as if people who love a game can recognize that how they feel about a game is just their opinion, but those who hate a game are convinced that what they feel is the undeniable truth. "No, no I'm not bashing, its just an 'Honest Assessment', really"

A very good point. 'TBH' is a disclaimer for 'I'm about to say something bad about something.'

[ProjectSRT]

Quote: Originally Posted by deaduck

What ? Like handwarmers?

Thats a start. Presentation upgrades. Details. Details can give a game longevity. Why do you think NFL 2K5 is still brought up? They did things with their presentation/atmosphere that causes the game to still be played today, its why Ian is taking a page from their book and adding alot of their presentation features to Madden 2010.