What's the difference between EA's player ratings and your own player ratings?

[MarylandScout2]

Of Note: These are my preliminary ratings and they are subjected to be changed as I move along and start editing more teams before the game drops.


Top 10 Quarterbacks

Name - OVR - THP - THA - AWR

Ryan Mallett - 90 - 99 - 88 - 83
Jake Locker - 90 - 91 - 86 - 72
Kellen Moore - 89 - 86 - 93 - 89
Case Keenum - 89 - 87 - 95 - 85
Christian Ponder- 88 - 86 - 90 - 80
Blaine Gabbert- 88 - 93 - 86 - 79
Jerrod Johnson - 87 - 94 - 86 -67
Andy Dalton - 86 - 85 - 92 - 76
Andrew Luck - 84 - 92 - 87 - 68
John Brantley - 84 - 92 - 88 -66

Top 10 by Awareness
1. Kellen Moore
2. Case Keenum
3. Nathan Enderele
4. Ryan Mallett
5. Kyle Pardon
6. Chrisitan Ponder
7. Andy Dalton
8. Russell Wilso
9. Andrew Luck
10. Ryan Colburn

Top 10 Throw Power
1. Ryan Mallett- 99
2. Ryan Katz -95
3. Jerrod Johnson
4. Blaine Gabbert
5. B.J. Daniels
6. John Brantley
7. Tom Savage
8. Cameron Newton
9. Andrew Luck
10. Nathan Enderle


Top 10 by Throw Accuracy
1. Case Keenum
2. Christian Ponder
3. Kellen Moore
4. Scott Tolzien
5. Chandler Harnish
6. Andy Dalton
7. Taylor Potts
8. Kyle Pardon
9. Nathan Enderele
10. Terrance Cain

Top 10 by Speed
1. Denard Robinson
2. A.J. Highsmith
3. Terrelle Pryor
4. Skylar Jones
5. Robert Griffin
6. Tyrod Taylor
7. Jeremy Johnson
8. Jake Locker
9. Joshua Nesbitt
10. Sherrod Harris

[ctindal21]

Quote: Originally Posted by MarylandScout2

Of Note: These are my preliminary ratings and they are subjected to be changed as I move along and start editing more teams before the game drops. Top 10 Quarterbacks Name - OVR - THP - THA - AWR Ryan Mallett - 90 - 99 - 88 - 83 Jake Locker - 90 - 91 - 86 - 72 Kellen Moore - 89 - 86 - 93 - 89 Case Keenum - 89 - 87 - 95 - 85 Christian Ponder- 88 - 86 - 90 - 80 Blaine Gabbert- 88 - 93 - 86 - 79 Jerrod Johnson - 87 - 94 - 86 -67 Andy Dalton - 86 - 85 - 92 - 76 Andrew Luck - 84 - 92 - 87 - 68 John Brantley - 84 - 92 - 88 -66 Top 10 by Awareness 1. Kellen Moore 2. Case Keenum 3. Nathan Enderele 4. Ryan Mallett 5. Kyle Pardon 6. Chrisitan Ponder 7. Andy Dalton 8. Russell Wilso 9. Andrew Luck 10. Ryan Colburn Top 10 Throw Power 1. Ryan Mallett- 99 2. Ryan Katz -95 3. Jerrod Johnson 4. Blaine Gabbert 5. B.J. Daniels 6. John Brantley 7. Tom Savage 8. Cameron Newton 9. Andrew Luck 10. Nathan Enderle Top 10 by Throw Accuracy 1. Case Keenum 2. Christian Ponder 3. Kellen Moore 4. Scott Tolzien 5. Chandler Harnish 6. Andy Dalton 7. Taylor Potts 8. Kyle Pardon 9. Nathan Enderele 10. Terrance Cain Top 10 by Speed 1. Denard Robinson 2. A.J. Highsmith 3. Terrelle Pryor 4. Skylar Jones 5. Robert Griffin 6. Tyrod Taylor 7. Jeremy Johnson 8. Jake Locker 9. Joshua Nesbitt 10. Sherrod Harris

where's jacory harris???

[MarylandScout2]

Quote: Originally Posted by [email protected]

where's jacory harris???

he is an 84

[MarylandScout2]

Top 5 by Position Of Note: I'm gonna keep my rating to myself on the other players as I don't want other roster makers to try to take my ideas and use them as their own until I have the file out.

Running Back
1. Mark Ingram
2. Ryan Williams
3. Jaquizz Rodgers
4. John Clay
5. Kendall Hunter

Wide Receiver
1. A.J. Green
2. Jonathan Baldwin
3. Michael Floyd
4. Ryan Broyles
5. Terrance Toliver

Tight End
1. Kyle Rudolph
2. D.J. Williams
3. Weslye Saunders
4. Charlie Gnatt
5. Luke Stocker

Defensive End
1. Adrian Clyborne
2. Cameron Heyward
3. Robert Quinn
4. Greg Romeus
5. Marcell Darues

Defensive Tackle
1. Stephan Pea
2. Jared Crick
3. Marvin Austin
4. Jerrell Powe
5. Marcus Fortson

Outside Linebacker
1. Bruce Carter
2. Von Miller
3. Travis Lewis
4. Akeem Ayers
5. Nick Bellore

Middle Linebacker
1. Quinn Sturdivant
2. Vontaze Burfuct
3. Greg Jones
4. Luke Kuechly
5. Alex Wujciak

Cornerback
1. Patrick Peterson
2. Prince Amukamara
3. Brandon Harris
4. Aaron Williams
5. Ras-I Dowling

Free Safety
1. Rahim Moore
2. Deunta Williams
3. Jaiquwan Jarrett
4. Robert Sands
5. Will Hill

Strong Safety
1. DeAndre McDaniel
2. Ahmad Black
3. Davonte Shannon
4. Mark Barron
5. Jeron Johnson

[l3ulvl]

Maryland, great credit for doing this, I love the toned down ratings. I guess my only fear is that the recruited players eventually becoming 95+ and outshining the initial rosters. I suppose there's nothing u/we could do about that, though.

One thing that has always bugged me about the dynasty rosters down the road is a team can stockpile QBs, and have their third string guy rated over 90. Same thing with RBs and other positions. I know EA has toned them down but I really wish they'd reserve the 95+ OVR guys for truly elite players, instead of having at least 10 guys at each position every year in a future dynasty.

I'd love to enter 2018 and see only 1 or 2 guys at each position rated 94 or higher, but I'm skeptical.

I'm DYING for performance based ratings.

[Playmakers]

Quote: Originally Posted by MarylandScout2

Of Note: These are my preliminary ratings and they are subjected to be changed as I move along and start editing more teams before the game drops. Top 10 Quarterbacks Name - OVR - THP - THA - AWR Ryan Mallett - 90 - 99 - 88 - 83 Jake Locker - 90 - 91 - 86 - 72 Kellen Moore - 89 - 86 - 93 - 89 Case Keenum - 89 - 87 - 95 - 85 Christian Ponder- 88 - 86 - 90 - 80 Blaine Gabbert- 88 - 93 - 86 - 79 Jerrod Johnson - 87 - 94 - 86 -67 Andy Dalton - 86 - 85 - 92 - 76 Andrew Luck - 84 - 92 - 87 - 68 John Brantley - 84 - 92 - 88 -66

Maryland you have to try to find away to get those guys into 70's for awareness

The reason being is because they are going to turn the ball over a lot in most offline dynasty games.....

You can do this by tweaking their break tackle ratings if you haven't already....kinda like reduce break tackle and increase awareness to keep their overall down.

But those guys with awareness under 70 are going to spazzz out in the game and start throwing picks unless of course your willing to do like I do every year and drop the catch ratings of the defenders down significantly accross the boards.

That will make the defenders use the knockdown animation more often as opposed to actually trying to catch the ball in return reducing the INT's you see per game with default settings.

The only problem is that's a helluva lot of defenders but it does work great and balances out the passing game very good. More deflections by defenders instead of INT's because they have hands of glue at default.

Other than the 3 guys with low awareness you posted everything looks else great

[Playmakers]

Quote: Originally Posted by MarylandScout2

Of Note: These are my preliminary ratings and they are subjected to be changed as I move along and start editing more teams before the game drops. Top 10 Quarterbacks Top 10 by Speed 1. Denard Robinson 2. A.J. Highsmith 3. Terrelle Pryor 4. Skylar Jones 5. Robert Griffin 6. Tyrod Taylor 7. Jeremy Johnson 8. Jake Locker 9. Joshua Nesbitt 10. Sherrod Harris

Also on this group here focus on these ratings

Ball Carrier Vision, Elusiveness, Agility, Awareness and Juke Move those are the hidden ratings that force the Mobile QB's to attempt to make more plays with their feet in the game.

You can jack up the elusiveness rating and juke move rating really high if you want it won't effect their overall ratings they are just complimentary ratings that EA never utilizes correctly to make the atheletic QB's take off and run more if they sense pressure.

OK that's it......pretty soon I'll have no more secrets left for my own set of rosters............

[MarylandScout2]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

Maryland you have to try to find away to get those guys into 70's for awareness The reason being is because they are going to turn the ball over a lot in most offline dynasty games..... You can do this by tweaking their break tackle ratings if you haven't already....kinda like reduce break tackle and increase awareness to keep their overall down. But those guys with awareness under 70 are going to spazzz out in the game and start throwing picks unless of course your willing to do like I do every year and drop the catch ratings of the defenders down significantly accross the boards. t

Those are just the ratings I have given the players without focusing on their other attributes, once I do that I will see some increases in those attributes which will mainly be the Awareness

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

Also on this group here focus on these ratings Ball Carrier Vision, Elusiveness, Agility, Awareness and Juke Move those are the hidden ratings that force the Mobile QB's to attempt to make more plays with their feet in the game. You can jack up the elusiveness rating and juke move rating really high if you want it won't effect their overall ratings they are just complimentary ratings that EA never utilizes correctly to make the atheletic QB's take off and run more if they sense pressure. OK that's it......pretty soon I'll have no more secrets left for my own set of rosters............

They are not secrets if I already know them.