What is so bad about this game?

[ucas005]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattyEdgeworth

Its a good base for the next games in the series at least.

That's what they say every year. I'm tired of good bases for next year. Why can't it ever just be a great NCAA game. An MLB 10 The Show, NBA2K11, or College Hoops 2k8 type classic that you can keep playing for years? Is it too hard to ask for a classic this generation console college football game?!

[Aranor]

Unfortunately there hasnt been a "good" base for this generation. First they have to actually make a good game to improve on instead of making dumb statements like "Its too difficult to fix so wait till 2013 for the fixes." This is because they know people will flock to the games year after year. Why fix what they can sell?

[KuruptOwnz]

Quote: Originally Posted by Aranor

Unfortunately there hasnt been a "good" base for this generation. First they have to actually make a good game to improve on instead of making dumb statements like "Its too difficult to fix so wait till 2013 for the fixes." This is because they know people will flock to the games year after year. Why fix what they can sell?

As much hate as you have for this game (see every topic you post in about NCAA12), you sure do a lot of talking about a game in which you despise.

[BadAssHskr]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattyEdgeworth

My question to you guys is what is so bad about this game?

Really the only thing wrong with the game is about .05% of EA's customer base.

Sadly, this day in age people feel entitled. You know the false old adage, the customer is always right. It gets take to a new level by that .05% I was telling you about.

[dcal]

That is quite a list of glitches and bugs. The reason it probably does not seem as bad to me is that I did not buy 10' or 11'(or really play them). The last one I played was 09' and I thought it was awful.

From a perspective of playing the game every year, which most of OS members have , I can appreciate why there is some frustration with the game.

[Aranor]

Quote: Originally Posted by KuruptOwnz

As much hate as you have for this game (see every topic you post in about NCAA12), you sure do a lot of talking about a game in which you despise.

There is a difference in continuing to do something for a little time for football. Its a whole lot different entirely to continue to buy the same broken game year after year. The last one I bought was in 09. Only reason I got 12 was because of coaching carousel. I have no other football game anymore other than 12. Im not going to waste anymore money for another EA product than I already have.

[BadAssHskr]

Quote: Originally Posted by Aranor

There is a difference in continuing to do something for a little time for football. Its a whole lot different entirely to continue to buy the same broken game year after year. The last one I bought was in 09. Only reason I got 12 was because of coaching carousel. I have no other football game anymore other than 12. Im not going to waste anymore money for another EA product than I already have.

his point is still valid.

[MattyEdgeworth]

Quote: Originally Posted by BlackBetty15

Man...Thats always the silver lining logic with EA sports titles and fans of football are tired of it man. Its good for some but for folks who want to really play football, EA's claim to this being the best thing besides real saturdays is a lie and a travesty. A game that doesnt even have penalties or the animations to correspond to them is downright sad and its been that way since NCAA first came out on 360....so....5 years now and the fundamentals of football are still broken? Crowd still looks bad, stadiums are still wrong for many fans, players still look cartoonish and less liek they should...I mean just take the pads and legs for instance. It doesnt look right. I mena is it fun? Sure...but is dynasty worth your time...I would rather receive an unlubbed catheter. (hope that doesnt go against any rules) I dont know...so many issues but hey...it is better than last years I suppose.

I can understand that. I only started watching football 3 years ago and have only been playing football games since Madden 10. I've only been watching college football for a year.

By the way, This was a genuine question. I haven't played the full game and I just wanted to know what was wrong with it.