Player rating changes

[packersfan4eva]

That would be perfect. You would actually have to play with each of the guys you have and build a starting lineup instead of just going off overall.

[CcAaRrSsOoNn3]

Looks like EA forgot to put in Maryland's Kenny Tate. SMH

[FightinSnydersKSU]

Yeah I'm with you. I hate how everyone just goes off of what a player's OVR is

[tarheel_24]

I did some simulating in dynasty on 12 with a rating set like the first qb ratings and the second and I discovered while set one was a bit high the second set was too low. With the second set freshman qbs would come in too high and be rated over the existing qbs, so you would have to edit all incoming recruits and player progression just got all screwed up. So without further ado I give you an in between set.


1. Matt Barkley- 97
2. Tyler Wilson- 95
3. Landry Jones- 95
4. Arron Murray- 95
5. Denard Robinson- 94
6. Geno Smith- 94
7. Logan Thomas- 92
8. Tyler Bray- 92
9. Tahj Boyd- 92
10. Keith Price- 92
11. Casey Pachall- 91
12. EJ Manuel- 91
13. AJ McCarron- 90
14. Mike Gleenon- 90
15. Collin Klein- 90
16. Bryn Renner- 90
17. James Franklin- 90
18. Ryan Aplin- 89
19. Riley Nelson- 88
20. Alex Carder- 87
21. Derek Carr- 87
22. Tyler Tettleton- 87
24. Jordan Wynn- 85
25. BJ Daniels- 85
26. Braxton Miller- 84
27. James Vanderburg- 84
28. Taylor Martinez- 83
29- Connor Shaw- 83
30. Nathan Scheelhaase- 83
31. Munchie Legaux- 83
32. Teddy Bridgewater- 82
33. Tevin Washington- 82
34. Kain Colter- 82
35. Seth Doege- 82
36. Jordan Rodgers- 81
37. Brett Smith- 80
38. Blaine Gautier- 80
39. Andrew Maxwell- 80
40- Zac Maynard- 79
41. Dayne Christ- 79
42. Tino Sunseri- 79
43. Tanner Price- 79
44. Jared Barnett- 79
45. Colby Cameron- 79
46. Matt Schilz- 78
47. Terrance Owens- 78
48. Rakeem Caito- 78
49. Blake Bell- 77
50. Chuckie Keeton- 77

[tarheel_24]

New rb ratings

1. Marcus Lattimore- 97
2. Montee Ball- 96
3. Knile- Davis- 95
4. Ray Graham- 95
5. John White- 95
6. Joseph Randle- 94
7. Stephan Taylor- 94
8. Kenjon Barner- 93
9. LeVeon Bell- 93
10. Giovani Bernard- 92
11. Rex Burkhead- 92
12. Andre Ellington- 92
13. Christine Michael- 91
14. DeAnthony Thomas- 90
15. Curtis McNeal- 90
16. Silas Redd- 90
17. Cierre Wood- 89
18. Robbie Rouse- 88
19. Henry Josey- 88
20. Isiah Crowell- 88
20. Eddie Lacey- 88
21. Montel Harris- 88
22. Ontario McCalebb- 88
23. Zach Line- 87
24. Zach Stacey- 87
25. James White- 87
26. Dominique Whaley- 86
27. Cameron Marshall- 85
28. Lyle McCombs- 85
29. Charles Sims- 85
30. Ed Wesley- 85
31. Spencer Ware- 85
32. Orwin Smith- 84
33. Fitzgerald Toussaint- 84
34. Eric Stephens- 84
35. Chris Nwoke- 83
36. Isi Sofele- 83
37. Jonathan Franklin- 83
38. Perry Jones- 83
39. John Hubert- 83
40. Jawan Jamison- 82
41. Orleans Darkwa- 82
42. James White- 82
43. Branden Oliver- 82
44. Michael Ford- 82
45. Dustin Garrsion- 80
46. DJ Harper- 80
47. Malcolm Brown- 80
48. Matt Brown- 79
49. JeTerian Douglas- 79
50. Kenny Hilliard- 78

[tarheel_24]

WRs

1. Robert Woods- 96
2. Marquess Wilson- 95
3. Sammy Watkins- 95
4. Keenan Allen- 94
5. Tavon Austin- 94
6. Kenny Stills- 93
7. Tavarres King- 93
8. Darick Rodgers- 93
9. Cobi Hamilton- 93
10. Marqise Lee- 92
11. Emory Blake- 92
12. Terrance Williams- 91
13. Josh Boyce- 91
14. Markus Wheaton- 90
15. Stedman Bailey- 90
16. Ryan Swope- 89
17. Mike Davis- 89
18. Odell Beckham- 89
19. Conner Vernon- 88
20. Malcolm Mitchell- 88
21. Roy Roundtree- 88
22. Devin Street- 87
23. Eric Highsmith- 87
24. Keenan Davis- 87
25. Nick Harwell- 87
26. Justin Hunter- 86
27. DeAndre Hopkins- 86
28. Theo Reddick- 85
29. Quinton Patton- 85
30. DeVante Parker- 85
31. Russell Shepard- 85
32. Tracy Lampley- 84
33. TJ Moe- 84
34. Dorial Green-Beckham- 84
35. Kasen Williams- 83
36. Jared Abbrederis- 82
37. Josh Gordon- 82
38. Andre Debose- 82
39. Jaxon Shipley- 81
40. Brandon Carter- 81
41. Matt Miller- 81
42. Jordan Mathews- 80
43. Cody Hoffman- 80
44. Jaz Reynolds- 79
45. Kenny Bell- 79
46. Rashad Greene- 79
47. Jeremy Gallon- 79
48. Tracy Moore- 78
49. Jheranie Boyd- 78
50. Marcus Davis- 78

[StayPlation82]

Quote: Originally Posted by DerkontheOS

They need to do away with overall all together. Sorry off topic.

the overall isn't the problem it's how do you give a rating to something that can't be measured like trucking, elusivness and even accuracy to a degree.

Also i don't think a college rating should matter in terms of pro success.

sidenote. where is Michael Dyer? i know he transferred but he should be on the list, no?

[cparrish]

I've always been confused how you can just say a player is a 93 overall? Do you just higher and lower ratings till John Doe is a 93 overall as opposed to rating a player to his specific abilities and rolling with whatever the overall rating ends up being?