I've enjoyed reading about all of your CM's, so I'll try to share mine again and hopefully OS won't log me out and erase my post before it goes up like last time.
Club: Leyton Orient
Difficulty: World Class - 7 minute half - Lenient Budget
I'm currently in October of my fourth season and my overall record looks like this so far..
Played - 195, Won - 124, Draw - 40, Loss - 31
Goals For - 313, Goals Against - 157
Biggest Win - 5-1 vs. Brentford, April 2014
Biggest Loss - 3-0 vs. Wolves, November 2013
Domestic Cups Won - 4
Continental Cups Won - 0
2013-14 Season
W42, D13, L8 - G108, A51
4-4-2 Formation
My career got off to a solid start with a second place finish in League One, which meant automatic promotion to the Championship. I made it to the semi finals of the Capital One Cup, and Round 3 of the FA Cup.
I sold my leading goal scorer, Mooney, in the January transfer window for $3M, which was 3x his listed value. I brought in a youngish Argentinian striker named Juan Duma for $1M as a replacement. I also redeemed a Scout a Future Star from the EASFC catalogue, which gave me a 15 year old RM to begin developing in my youth squad.
2014-15 Season
W43, D10, L7 - G98, A38
4-2-3-1 Formation
Going into this season I was already tired of trying to get by on a paltry budget of around $300K, so I decided to use a financial takeover and received a healthy $42M. I splashed the cash and brought in several young players that would serve as the backbone of my club for years to come. Adryan is the only one I can remember the amount I paid for ($9.3M), but I also snatched up Jack Butland to play in goal, Kurt Zouma as my anchor CB, Rodrigo Caio at CDM, and Maximilian Meyer as a utility midfielder. I didn't sell anyone during this season. I also redeemed another Scout a Future Star this season and received a 16 year old LW to add to the RM from the first season.
This was probably my most successful season so far because I again gained automatic promotion to the Premier League by finishing in second place, although it was tight as I finished only 1 point ahead of QPR. Bolton won the league running away. However, I did manage to win both the Capital One Cup and FA Cup, which meant I would be playing European league football the next season! I also won manager of the month for the first and only time so far in my career during this season.
2015-16 Season
W31, D13, L15 - G82, A57
4-2-3-1 Formation
Back to a more modest transfer budget of a few million, this season started off with very few squad changes despite nearly every club trying to pry Butland and Adryan away from me. I stood firm with my value of $20M for Butland and $25M for Adryan, and no one was willing to over spend to that amount for either player. I did bring in an additional striker after Zivkovic, who I brought in the previous season for less than $1M, went out with an ACL injury during the Community Shield match vs. Chelsea. The striker is a Brazilian youth player/regen named Barbosa da Silva who I got for $2M. He's quite pacy, but has below average WF and skill move abilities. I also sold one of my more dependable central midfielders, Romain Vincelot for a healthy $2.7M. Vincelot played well for my club, but he was 29 when I sold him and already starting to decline, so I jumped on getting back solid value for him. I also bought my first youth scout, 3*/2* I believe, and started adding more youth to the two players already in development.
The season started off surprisingly well for having a below average squad by Premier League standards. I stayed somewhere between 5th-10th place for most of the season, and finished somewhere around 8th. I was bounced from the Capital One Cup in the quarter finals, but managed to win the FA Cup again. I also made it to the round of 16 in the Europa League where I was absolutely steam rolled by Athletico Madrid.
2016-17 Season
W8, D4, L1
4-2-3-1 Formation
I saw a nice bump in my transfer budget to around $14M at the start this season. I decided to put most of that into securing another solid CB to replace the aging players at that position. I was finally able to land John Anthony Brooks, the young American CB who I had been after for a couple of season for a bargain of $12M. He instantly became the highest rated player on my squad at 80 OVR. I also brought in another LB youth player/regen from Bayern Munich for a little over $1M. I let Zivkovic go to QPR for a small $950K fee, but I was tired of his terrible stamina and I had moved on to more reliable players at the striker position.
This season got off to a rocky start as I began league play with 4 straight draws despite leading by a goal at some point in each match. Things were starting to look really bleak when I received a letter from the club board expressing their concern after a 2-1 loss at Sunderland. I managed to right the ship for the time being shortly after with a tough win vs. Liverpool early in the Capital One Cup and a dramatic, come from behind 3-2 win vs. Olympique Lyon in the Europa League group stage. I followed up those wins with a couple of victories in the league and a 4-0 smashing of Genk, and things seem to be coming together quite well for my squad this season.
My complete squad currently looks like this:
GK - Butland, age 23, 76 OVR, $4M value
GK - Maenpaa, age 31, 64 OVR, $200K value (never plays)
GK - Larkins, age 22, 56 OVR, $60K value (on loan at S****horpe)
RB - Rankovic, age 23, 66 OVR, $725K value (recently bought from Bayern for $500K)
RB - Trapp, age 18, 65 OVR, $425K value (youth player/regen, progressing nicely)
CB - Brooks, age 23, 80 OVR, $11.5M value (recently bought from Hertha for $12M)
CB - Zouma, age 21, 74 OVR, $3.3M value (has not improved in any single stat so far
)
CB - Gunter, age 22, 70 OVR, $1.5M value (bought from Dortmund in season 3 after playing for my squad on loan in season 2)
CB - Bradbury, age 28, 69 OVR, $675K value (original club member)
CB - Barraza, age 19, 66 OVR, $600K value (youth player/regen currently in on loan with option to buy from Barcelona)
LB - Alar, age 20, 71 OVR, $1.5M value (youth player/regen bought from Bayern in season 3)
LB - Omozusi, age 27, 68 OVR, $675K (original club member)
LB - Sawyer, age 31, 63 OVR, $160K (original club member)
CDM - Rodrigo Caio, age 23, 71 OVR, $1.6M value (just starting to see stat improvement this season)
CDM - Ozuntali, age 20, 70 OVR, $1.4M value
CM - Pierre-Emile Hobjerg, age 21, 75 OVR, $3.9M value (recently bought for $5M + James from Bayern)
RM - Snedker, age 18, 68 OVR, $950K value (my scout a future star youth player)
RM - Odubajo, age 23, 65 OVR, $625K value (original club member who's been incredibly clutch in the past 3+ seasons)
RW - Boateng, age 22, 67 OVR, $875K value (currently in on loan with an option to buy from AC Milan)
LM - Cox, age 29, 72 OVR, $2M value (original club member & been very dependable)
LW - Pelagotti, age 18, 70 OVR, $1.5M value (my scout a future star youth player)
CAM - Adryan, age 22, 76 OVR, $6.5M value (progressing slowly)
CAM - Meyer, age 21, 72 OVR, $3.2M value (progressing VERY slowly)
CAM - Sherratt, age 23, 56 OVR, $130M value (original club member but never plays)
ST - Duma, age 22, 75 OVR, $4.4M value (very happy with his progression)
ST - Barbosa da Silva, age 20, 68 OVR, $1.2M value (recently purchased after playing for my squad on loan in season 3)
ST - Capellini, age 18, 62 OVR, $375K value (currently in on loan with an option to buy from Chievo Verona)
------------------------------------------------------------------
Tips for those who want to start a CM with low level clubs:
Bring in players on loan! I can't state how much this has helped my squad depth and overall success. I almost never brought in players on loan in my FIFA 13 CM, but I've been really successful with it this year.
Also, starting in about the third season, search top flight clubs for their young players and try to bring them in on season loans with an option to purchase. I've found that this helps identify players who don't progress as they should more easily.