2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Brandon League for one B
Matt Capps or Brett Myers for 2-3 C's depending on his stats
Brandon Lyon for one C

Woah way too much League a C or two and the same for Myers, Capps a C. And Lyon basically for a bag of balls

[pootytang]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I understand that Heyward and Stanton aren't going to get traded but what value do they have? Assume Braves and Marlins are out of it.

2 As and a B?

Also, For Mauer and Morneau what can I expect? I was thinking 2 A's and a B for Mauer and an A and B or C for Morneau, but I'm not really sure. Obviously they would be traded to contending teams that need a push at their respective positions.

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I understand that Heyward and Stanton aren't going to get traded but what value do they have? Assume Braves and Marlins are out of it.

2 As and a B?

Also, For Mauer and Morneau what can I expect? I was thinking 2 A's and a B for Mauer and an A and B or C for Morneau, but I'm not really sure. Obviously they would be traded to contending teams that need a push at their respective positions.

Hayward = Mid A and high B
Stanton = Three high A's
Mauer = Mid A, Mid B, C
Mourneau = Two B's, C

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I understand that Heyward and Stanton aren't going to get traded but what value do they have? Assume Braves and Marlins are out of it.

2 As and a B?

Also, For Mauer and Morneau what can I expect? I was thinking 2 A's and a B for Mauer and an A and B or C for Morneau, but I'm not really sure. Obviously they would be traded to contending teams that need a push at their respective positions.

Stanton 2 A's or 3 Heyward A and 2 B's Mauer 3 High B's Mourneu 2 low B's

[Trevor314]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What do you guys think is realistically fair for a Felix Hernandez deal? The Mariners aren't going to win with him anytime soon, and they could really stock up on big time prospects by dealing him now.

[Totte]

What do you guys think is realistically fair for a Felix Hernandez deal? The Mariners aren't going to win with him anytime soon, and they could really stock up on big time prospects by dealing him now.

This was discussed a while back in this thread if you wanna do a search and get a more in depth response. I think we said something like 2 A's and 3 B's or something. Remember IRL how the Mariners asked the Yankees for Betances, Banuelos, Hughes, Noesi and Montero a year ago or so

[brett the jet favre]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

This was discussed a while back in this thread if you wanna do a search and get a more in depth response. I think we said something like 2 A's and 3 B's or something. Remember IRL how the Mariners asked the Yankees for Betances, Banuelos, Hughes, Noesi and Montero a year ago or so

Last i checked, we didnt ask, the Yankees offered their top 8 prospects and the Mariners said no, and on top of that he has a option not to be traded if its to the Yankees, and another big team, i forget.

[AC]

Last i checked, we didnt ask, the Yankees offered their top 8 prospects and the Mariners said no, and on top of that he has a option not to be traded if its to the Yankees, and another big team, i forget.

No, I think the Yankees were just hesitant to include Gardiner.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

No, I think the Yankees were just hesitant to include Gardiner.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

I seem to remember it that way as well, of all the guys to have reservations about trading lol...they chose Gardiner.

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I seem to remember it that way as well, of all the guys to have reservations about trading lol...they chose Gardiner.

Hey, he's pretty good. But yeah, they wouldn't trade him.

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Hey, he's pretty good. But yeah, they wouldn't trade him.

Don't get me wrong, Gardiner is a hell of a player and I actually like the way he plays the game. But of all the players in that deal, he had arguably the lowest ceiling...which is why I was surprised they would have reservations about him. Regardless, if you had a choice of him and some prospects or Felix Hernandez...you'd be lying or delusional if you'd choose Gardiner and prospects over one of the more dominant pitchers in baseball.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Don't get me wrong, Gardiner is a hell of a player and I actually like the way he plays the game. But of all the players in that deal, he had arguably the lowest ceiling...which is why I was surprised they would have reservations about him. Regardless, if you had a choice of him and some prospects or Felix Hernandez...you'd be lying or delusional if you'd choose Gardiner and prospects over one of the more dominant pitchers in baseball.

bingo...no way he'd be hold-up in a trade for any marquee player

[fran33s]

What's coco crisp worth? Batting .260 with 21 SB

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What's coco crisp worth? Batting .260 with 21 SB

Two C's at most.

[fran33s]

Eh. Okay. Just wondering..