2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Wikoff is a mid-C.

yeah but a BETTER mid-C...i have no choice but to turn on my PS3 *sigh*

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

i guess he's worth a shot....nothing more then a mid-C tho

So to sum things up:

Milk Carton for Carlos Pena (LOL couldn't resist, I wish that was possible...but there's no way I could do that without feeling bad for Cinci.)

Being serious now:

Pena= Mid C?

CarGo= 3 Bs? Did we agree on that or was there still some argument about it?

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

yeah but a BETTER mid-C...i have no choice but to turn on my PS3 *sigh*

Yeah, life sucks.... Mine isn't even working : Trying to fix it...

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

So to sum things up:

Milk Carton for Carlos Pena (LOL couldn't resist, I wish that was possible...but there's no way I could do that without feeling bad for Cinci.)

Being serious now:

Pena= Mid C?

CarGo= 3 Bs? Did we agree on that or was there still some argument about it?

Yeah, that's about right. What package of B's for CarGo?

Also, you better give Cargo a REAL nice introduction to your dynasty, lol.

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Yeah, that's about right. What package of B's for CarGo?

Also, you better give Cargo a REAL nice introduction to your dynasty, lol.

I think Trop and Houser have to leave in that deal for me to feel like I didn't house them. So those two plus one of Dominguez/Villar/DeShields is reasonable (IMO, if you disagree please speak up haha.)

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think Trop and Houser have to leave in that deal for me to feel like I didn't house them. So those two plus one of Dominguez/Villar/DeShields is reasonable (IMO, if you disagree please speak up haha.)

2 high-B's for CarGo...and dont click trade yet....i still got some chit to figure out.....WAITTTTTT FOR MEEEEEE

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think Trop and Houser have to leave in that deal for me to feel like I didn't house them. So those two plus one of Dominguez/Villar/DeShields is reasonable (IMO, if you disagree please speak up haha.)

Actually, don't give them Dominiguez or Villar, with Arenado/Tulo... Give them DeShields, as they don't have a better 2B prospect.

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

So to sum things up:

Milk Carton for Carlos Pena (LOL couldn't resist, I wish that was possible...but there's no way I could do that without feeling bad for Cinci.)

Being serious now:

Pena= Mid C?

CarGo= 3 Bs? Did we agree on that or was there still some argument about it?

Here's my only argument with the Cargo thing the Rockies wouldn't accept a trade for Cargo unless Singleton, DeShields or McCullers was in it. Think about it Singelton went to Hou for Pence. Cargo is way better than Pence and is locked up longer, there would have to be a good A involved or there would be no deal

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think Trop and Houser have to leave in that deal for me to feel like I didn't house them. So those two plus one of Dominguez/Villar/DeShields is reasonable (IMO, if you disagree please speak up haha.)

Dominguez shouldn't even be involved in these talks he can't hit to save his life, he's a backup at best

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Here's my only argument with the Cargo thing the Rockies wouldn't accept a trade for Cargo unless Singleton, DeShields or McCullers was in it. Think about it Singelton went to Hou for Pence. Cargo is way better than Pence and is locked up longer, there would have to be a good A involved or there would be no deal

But CarGo is playing like chit, locked up to a VERY long and potentially dangerous deal, and Pence was playing out of his mind when he was dealt.

Also, I asked for DeShields to be involved.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Here's my only argument with the Cargo thing the Rockies wouldn't accept a trade for Cargo unless Singleton, DeShields or McCullers was in it. Think about it Singelton went to Hou for Pence. Cargo is way better than Pence and is locked up longer, there would have to be a good A involved or there would be no deal

i'd be ok with DeShields...no chance on either Singleton or McCullers

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

But CarGo is playing like chit, locked up to a VERY long and potentially dangerous deal, and Pence was playing out of his mind when he was dealt.

Cargo numbers werent that bad, Uptons are way worse this year IRL and he was still gonna take an A or two to get

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

i'd be ok with DeShields...no chance on either Singleton or McCullers

Then in my mind your ripping them off

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Cargo numbers werent that bad, Uptons are way worse this year IRL and he was still gonna take an A or two to get

That's cause Upton is two years younger, not as dangerous a deal, and not Coors benefited (Jk, I don't want to start THAT again)

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Cargo numbers werent that bad, Uptons are way worse this year IRL and he was still gonna take an A or two to get

True, but that's why I had a slash there lol. I would include any of the 3 of those prospects (DeShields/Villar/Dominguez) whichever makes the deal the best for Colorado. I want both teams to win in any trade, just how I am.

Also: CarGo is hitting .287 at home, .256 on the road. Just throwing it out there