DLC to allow button punching

[DarthRambo]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

this is still an argument ??? the game is flawed in some areas not the controls

if u suck at this game then u suck, end of story, if u like a specific control scheme then u should be able to use it.

Again, another poor, not thought out AT ALL reply by a person that uses TPC. no suprise, none at all. I have ceberal palsey btw, which doesn't allow me to use TPC, so before u go on stating things like that, think first!

[TheGawd]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

Again, another poor, not thought out AT ALL reply by a person that uses TPC. no suprise, none at all. I have ceberal palsey btw, which doesn't allow me to use TPC, so before u go on stating things like that, think first!

i think he was agreeing with you....

[DarthRambo]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

i think he was agreeing with you....

I read it over again... kinda hard to tell, but nonetheless i spoke my mind. Sorry if i misinterpreted.

[parker002]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

What part of "I have officially (agreed to disagree)" could you not understand? Man, just when I try to get out smooth.. they reel me back in. Look, I give a rats ***. If you don't like the thread maybe this thread isn't for you. All me and a group of others want to do is enjoy a decent game. That's it. Bringing back the buttons does not effect a stick users game. It really isn't too much to ask.

Rebuttal in.. T minus 3,2,1..

Obviously there's no need for a rebuttal since you said you "officially" agreed to disagreed, and immediately followed the above post with ANOTHER response. You're obviously not willing to let it go, now are you?

[Millennium]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

i think he was agreeing with you....

if by He, you mean you, as MyBeatsAreBetter is the same person as you.

And all three names are banned.

[vision]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

Obviously there's no need for a rebuttal since you said you "officially" agreed to disagreed, and immediately followed the above post with ANOTHER response. You're obviously not willing to let it go, now are you?

I never said let it go, I said agree to disagree. Would leave me alone now please? The points have been made. This is petty.

[parker002]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

I never said let it go, I said agree to disagree. Would leave me alone now please? The points have been made. This is petty.

I absolutely agree it's petty.

Hence why I asked if we could let the thread die.

Unfortunately, the fighting about buttons is overshadowing things that NEED to be in the first DLC - stamina slider, legacy bug fixes, etc.

It's good though. I wasn't aiming to attack you specifically, your post just happended to be the last one in the thread at the time I responded.

[Rawdeal28]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

If it was up to a lot of you we would all still be playing on 2 button control pads using a digital pad. I remember when analog sticks were introduced everyone hated them and until just a couple of years ago had friends who insisted on playing Madden and other games using the digital pad.

The bottom line is games and how they are played are going to change. You may or may not like some aspects of that change, for instance I really miss the big space PC games like Wing Commander, but that's just how the industry works. You can rail against it and make all the good points you like, and some of you do make excellent points, but you will have to adapt or simply cease to game.

As for this specific argument, I have seen several people say that pushing the stick around requires no skill in argument of buttons to counter the "button mashing requires no skill". The truth is that is a very poor argument IMO simply because to use the stick you can't just move the stick around and do worth a damn 95% of the time whereas you can with just pushing at the buttons.

Also, I can see a lot of folks point that they could have left the buttons in for offline play but I think you're missing the point. The point is that the game is not meant to be played in such a way and by continuing to give people the option there are still going to be people playing it in an unintended manner. The only way to really get folks on board to a new control scheme is often to dump the old one. Yes some folks will simply cease to be on board period but if the new scheme is good that will be outweighed by those who previously did not like the old scheme but enjoy the new one. I'm sure EA has a ton of marketing research to validate that is the case or they wouldn't be going in this direction.

And lest anyone think I can't sympathize with the button issue, I can because I am an old school video gamer who hates the golf swing with the analog controls in the new games. They still offer (well Tiger 09 did) the old way and I use it often, while still trying to get used to the analog scheme. It's just the way it is..

co-sign.

Can we PLEASE let this thread die?

please

if by He, you mean you, as MyBeatsAreBetter is the same person as you.

And all three names are banned.

lol

[Swingking77]

Re: DLC to allow button punching

Your argument seems to be more against the stamina system and/or the accuracy of the punches moreso than the buttons themselves.

Yes... It may. But it's like complaining about your house being on fire... If someone shows up with a can of gasoline, do you want them to add it onto the already blazzing fire? That's what button pushing is... Fule to a fire that threatens, every time, to ruin a decent game...

It's a past issue now, since they will be adding them anyhow... But marl my words "if the stamina isn't fixed" the button mashers will once again win, just like the cheesers in Madden ruin the game online every year...