It really depends on how often you will download the PS Extra Game Catalog games. That's the main incentive. It does come in handy when they occasionally drop a big game on Game Catalog only. Like I can see them dropping a game like GOW Ragnarok on there late this year or a game like Spider-Man 2 by this time next year. I think it's best for those who either don't buy games frequently or trade in games.and want to replay them.
I do PS Extra for the first couple years. But, most of the times I didn't even like the games available for a long while. I think one year I went from January to about August before I was interested. Most of the time, I would download a game just because without the intent on playing. I downloaded a couple games my daughter will eventually like in a couple years. But, this time around I dropped down to PS Essential with the intent on upgrading when there is a game I truly want. So far since November, there hasn't been a game I really. If I wanted to upgrade to PS Extra it would only cost me now $28 instead of $42 because of that sale. But, I would want to see what February's Game Catalog games are before I would decide to upgrade. The longer I wait the cheaper the subscription is for the rest of the duration
For me, PS Premium isn't worth it. I don't have interest in Game Trials, Game Streaming, or Classic Games. For me, if they would attach Crunchroll to PS Premium, I would jump on that just for Crunchyroll since Sony is associated with them. Plus for me, I have Gamefly. So, I could rent whatever game I want.
Comment