In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Yeah...THAT Guy
    Once in a Lifetime Memory
    • Dec 2006
    • 17294

    #61
    Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

    Not sure if you've made up your mind yet, but I'll give you my two cents. Also, you can take into consideration the fact that my girlfriend and I are only 22 years old, so I'm not as experience as some others around here. Anyways, here goes:

    It sounds like you and the current girl are somewhat similar to me and my girlfriend. I'd say we have more differences than things in common. She's visited pretty much every country in the world. The furthest west I've traveled is Chicago, and the only time I've left the country was to drive an hour north to Canada. She likes to eat every type of cuisine ever made except for seafood. I'm extremely picky, but the one kind of cuisine that I really love is seafood. The only sports she follows are hockey and Australian Rules Football (she's from Melbourne). I like pretty much every sport except for those two (though I've also never seen an ARF match lol).

    Anyways, the reason I say this is because of the fact that you said "My point in bringing all that up is that I think initially our differences brought us together. But I'm not sure if a future together would make us both happy. And after about month 6 or 7 of being together, I have not felt like I am getting any closer to her."

    I think this is sort of key, and it reminds me of something I went through this past summer. I was working in Boston for the summer, and my girlfriend and I were going through a rough patch, and at the same time, I met a girl that shared a ton of the same interests I had, and also shared a lot of the lifestyle choices I prefer (wants to settle down and have a family in the Boston area). Anyways, my girlfriend and I ended up taking a break from talking for a few weeks so that we could figure out what we really wanted. She never really wanted to have a family at any point and wanted to always be traveling, whereas I wanted to eventually settle down and have a family.

    We ended up deciding that we could compromise, and that we'd both like to travel for a bit, but eventually settle down, and likely have a family somewhere.

    The thing that made that whole process worth it is the fact that even though we're very different people, it keeps things exciting, and at the same time, we have enough things in common that we feel compatible. She gets me to try new foods. I get her to try new sports. We get each other to see different areas in the country. But we both enjoy Breaking Bad, Criminal Minds, movies, and the Food Network together. We enjoy cooking together. And our personalities (sense of humor, maturity level, etc.) are very in tune with each other. I believe that having a lot of differences is important, but more important is that you have personalities that mesh and that you're willing to compromise to make things work.

    To me, it sounds like you have those exciting differences with your current girl, but that you may not have enough similarities to make things work, but that's really something that you have to figure out on your own.

    For me, my girlfriend is now moving to Malaysia for 9 months after we graduate, but we're determined to make things work, and I'm looking into moving somewhere new so that I can do a little bit of traveling of my own while she's gone, and then we'll hopefully settle down somewhere when she comes home.

    Good luck dude. I'm sure that you'll figure things out sooner or later. You'll make the right decision.
    NFL: Bills
    NBA: Bucks
    MLB: Cubs
    NCAA: Syracuse
    Soccer: USMNT/DC United

    PSN: ButMyT-GunDont

    Comment

    • Yeah...THAT Guy
      Once in a Lifetime Memory
      • Dec 2006
      • 17294

      #62
      Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

      Well damn, finally got caught up and saw that I basically typed all that out after you figured it out for yourself lol.

      As far as breaking up goes, there's literally no good way to do it. The last time I broke up with a girl, it was with someone that really thought we were going to get married. I couldn't bring myself to actually break up, and I talked to one of my good friends, and he just convinced me that it wasn't working because of the distance (which really wasn't true, but he was able to convince me that it was), and I just went with that. The thing that sucks is that I tend to get pretty worked up over breaking up, but when I finally settle on the idea of it, it's like a weight has been lifted, so when I actually break up with the girl, I'm extremely calm about it and they just don't understand how I could sound so emotionless about it.

      Just know that there's no way to break up with someone in the "right" way unless it's mutual. Otherwise, you just gotta say your part, stick to your guns, try to remain calm, and get it done.

      And I DEFINITELY would not mention anything about the ex. Abso****inglutely not.
      NFL: Bills
      NBA: Bucks
      MLB: Cubs
      NCAA: Syracuse
      Soccer: USMNT/DC United

      PSN: ButMyT-GunDont

      Comment

      • GAMEC0CK2002
        Stayin Alive
        • Aug 2002
        • 10384

        #63
        Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

        Having been on both sides of a breakup, its one of the hardest things to deal with. There is no easy way to do it--there are no words you can say to ease the pain of a broken heart. Only time.

        The only bright side is that is almost always is the right choice.

        Comment

        • Koolie G
          MVP
          • Mar 2005
          • 1812

          #64
          Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

          I wouldn't mention the ex. You just need to give here the ol' "it's not you, it's me" line. Tell her you just don't see this working out long term and you need time to figure out what you want. Which is all true. She won't like it but no one ever does. You can try to explain how you are doing this for her own good and that she is young and needs to experience more, blah blah blah, but she won't see that and will just be mad.

          Set up a meeting with the ex. See what your feelings are. If you don't have the same feelings and you find that you are missing your now new ex girl, maybe you've figured out who you really want to be with. You may decide a relationship with any girl is not what you want right now. Or you may decide you and DookieMowf should try to hook up because you have similar interests. The world is your oyster, you can do what you want.
          PSN: Koolie_G
          XBL: KoolieG
          Twitch: KoolieG

          Comment

          • TMagic
            G.O.A.T.
            • Apr 2007
            • 7550

            #65
            Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

            What happens if I tell her nothing about my ex, then a few months down the road she finds out about us hanging?

            I feel like she'd think I was lying to her. Like I slapped her in the face.
            PSN: TMagic_01

            Twitter: @ThoseFools

            YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEC...cd41cJK2238sIA

            Comment

            • dsallupinyaarea
              Rookie
              • Jan 2009
              • 2764

              #66
              Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

              Originally posted by TMagic
              What happens if I tell her nothing about my ex, then a few months down the road she finds out about us hanging?

              I feel like she'd think I was lying to her. Like I slapped her in the face.
              Those be the breaks. Everyone can't win in this situation.
              NFL - Vikings

              twitter - @dsallupinyaarea
              psn - dsallupinyaarea8
              xbox - dsallupinyoarea

              Comment

              • wwharton
                *ll St*r
                • Aug 2002
                • 26949

                #67
                Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                Originally posted by TMagic
                What happens if I tell her nothing about my ex, then a few months down the road she finds out about us hanging?

                I feel like she'd think I was lying to her. Like I slapped her in the face.
                No matter what happens she's going to feel like you slapped her in the face.

                Bottom line is the pursuit of happiness. If, down the road, you feel like being with your ex is what will ultimately make you happy in life... and it was a serious, conscious decision, that's all you should worry about. Really, at this point, all that matters is making a serious and conscious decision that you don't think being with this current GF will ultimately make you happy. Honesty and thoughtfulness is what matters. She doesn't have to like it or like you, but she'd have to choose not to respect honestly doing what you think is best for you. Especially since we're talking about relationships, and if that's honestly how you feel then getting out of it is what's best for her too.

                Comment

                • Jr.
                  Playgirl Coverboy
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 19171

                  #68
                  Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                  Originally posted by TMagic
                  What happens if I tell her nothing about my ex, then a few months down the road she finds out about us hanging?

                  I feel like she'd think I was lying to her. Like I slapped her in the face.
                  I don't see any reason to not tell her. I think those that are saying not to bring it up are trying to make it easier on the both of you and keep it as non-confrontational as possible (don't mean to put words in people's mouths, so if I'm wrong let me know).

                  It's already going to be hard on her, so I don't think there's any reason to keep information from her. Be as honest as possible and leave knowing that you were as straight forward as possible and she has all of the information so she can move on.
                  My favorite teams are better than your favorite teams

                  Watch me play video games

                  Comment

                  • GAMEC0CK2002
                    Stayin Alive
                    • Aug 2002
                    • 10384

                    #69
                    Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                    Originally posted by TMagic
                    What happens if I tell her nothing about my ex, then a few months down the road she finds out about us hanging?

                    I feel like she'd think I was lying to her. Like I slapped her in the face.
                    She's going to be hurt regardless. Just be honest with her and tell her you still aren't over your ex. It was nothing she did or did not do. And because you do care about her, it wouldn't be fair to say I'm committed to you and still have lingering feelings for someone else.

                    Comment

                    • KingV2k3
                      Senior Circuit
                      • May 2003
                      • 5881

                      #70
                      Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                      Bachelorette Number One is the clear winner here, and there's no need for all this discussion now that the pix been posted...

                      Comment

                      • DIESEL
                        MVP
                        • Feb 2003
                        • 1426

                        #71
                        Re: In Need Of Some Seriou s Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                        I skimmed the thread , so I apologize if I'm a little off but this is what I gather on the ex.

                        1. It appears, at the very least, she started having feelings for another guy while she was dating you. Possibly cheated on you?

                        2. While she's in the relationship with the new guy she's busy dreaming about you.

                        3. While knowing you are currently in a relationship, the ex starts contacting you and is openly discussing rekindling the relationship.

                        I'm with Phobia.

                        The ex sounds like a drama queen. In her e-mail she talks about destiny bringing you together if it's meant to happen. I don't consider sending texts and e-mails to people in a relationship destiny. I agree you should break up with the current girl ASAP.

                        But be careful bro.
                        Good job! Good effort!

                        Comment

                        • ex carrabba fan
                          I'll thank him for you
                          • Oct 2004
                          • 32744

                          #72
                          Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                          Damn man, actually came through with pics?

                          Just a guess, but your girl probably sensed you being different lately and that's why she texted you that. Not saying you were shunning her, but I'm sure she noticed even the tiniest difference in how you interact with her due to your thoughts about your ex.

                          It's really easy to sense when something is off with your partner, especially this early into your relationship with your current.

                          Comment

                          • Heroesandvillains
                            MVP
                            • May 2009
                            • 5974

                            #73
                            Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                            Honestly, and I mean no ill will here...

                            I had to stop reading after the first 3 pages. It's starting to infuriate me.

                            You communicate on FB with your ex. You request an email. You communicate with your ex's mother, etc.

                            I don't know how else to put it. Leave your current GF, man. She deserves better.

                            Comment

                            • kaletore11
                              #44
                              • Sep 2013
                              • 2549

                              #74
                              Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                              Originally posted by Heroesandvillains
                              I don't know how else to put it. Leave your current GF, man. She deserves better.
                              After reading every post in this thread, this is my conclusion as well.

                              You're obviously lost at the moment and I don't blame you for it because I had a very similar situation and handled it terribly. But you should really leave your current gf, she doesn't need to go through all this s**t.

                              Honestly, I don't think what OSers say will have a big impact on your decisions regarding this situation. It's obvious you want to see your ex and see if there's still something there, and my guess is you will see her. Chances are, you'll end up disappointed because getting together with an ex is most often not the best idea. But hey, it's better to see her and go home empty handed than ask yourself "what could have been" for the next few years.

                              Just to provide some personal experience, I was in a situation where I had an ex with whom I had the strongest connection and most passionate relationship ever. She broke up with me for reasons unknown to this date, but never treated me poorly. I found another girl and was quite happy where that relationship was going when the ex jumped back into the picture. I foolishly started seeing her and literally my entire life went downhill at that point. My gf realised something was going on and dumped me, even though I thought I was behaving normally. Turned out that the ex is a headcase and enjoys the drama more than being in a happy relationship and after some time she disappeared from my life as well. In the meantime I got back together with another ex who turned out to be the best thing that ever happened to me and I've been happier than ever the last few years. ****, that just killed the point I was trying to make..... Hmm.....

                              Yeah, just leave your gf because you're not fair to her and see what's up with the ex because you obviously want to. Use your brain for the first decision and your gut for the second one.


                              Man, I suck at giving advice.
                              Khalabeeb - Tony Henderson
                              Stiopic - Brock

                              Originally posted by areobee401
                              Positive HIV test results > fans talking class in sports

                              Comment

                              • slickdtc
                                Grayscale
                                • Aug 2004
                                • 17125

                                #75
                                Re: In Need Of Some Serious Advice (Yes. Relationship Issues)

                                Originally posted by Heroesandvillains
                                Honestly, and I mean no ill will here...

                                I had to stop reading after the first 3 pages. It's starting to infuriate me.

                                You communicate on FB with your ex. You request an email. You communicate with your ex's mother, etc.

                                I don't know how else to put it. Leave your current GF, man. She deserves better.
                                I hear you, but I think TMagic is still figuring it out himself. Is it just a passing feeling? Can the current girl last with him?

                                He's just indecisive, not maliciously dragging his current girl through the mud. She is, quite unfortunately, likely to be collateral damage in this scenario.

                                Before he can tell anyone, he has to figure out what he truly wants, too. I think OS confused him with the "stay single" angle too. Diabolical place this is, let me tell ya! lol
                                NHL - Philadelphia Flyers
                                NFL - Buffalo Bills
                                MLB - Cincinnati Reds


                                Originally posted by Money99
                                And how does one levy a check that will result in only a slight concussion? Do they set their shoulder-pads to 'stun'?

                                Comment

                                Working...