Best Madden and Why ?

[vtcrb]

Madden 12 as I can Import Draft Classes from NCAA 12.

You have to make a few edits to get Gameplay smoothed out, but I find it to be the Best all Around Madden.

[TarHeelPhenom]

I'd throw Madden 25 in there too simply because it used Infinity Engine 2.0 which led to more physics based gameplay; and it was the last game I believe that allowed you to play on a playable Broadcast Camera angle.

[PVarck31]

I just picked up 16 today. I do not remember it being this good. The player movement is great, the tackling is more organic and physics based. There’s some wonkyness their sometimes. And the WR/DB interaction is pretty much what it’s like in Madden now. I’m really surprised how good this game is.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by PVarck31

I just picked up 16 today. I do not remember it being this good. The player movement is great, the tackling is more organic and physics based. There’s some wonkyness their sometimes. And the WR/DB interaction is pretty much what it’s like in Madden now. I’m really surprised how good this game is. Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

The main complaint was that the aggressive OBJ catch was too prominent.They patched this game as late as early June that year so if a person wasn't playing it late into the year they maybe never experienced it in its final state.

[ripcandlestickpark]

Quote: Originally Posted by TarHeelPhenom

I'd throw Madden 25 in there too simply because it used Infinity Engine 2.0 which led to more physics based gameplay; and it was the last game I believe that allowed you to play on a playable Broadcast Camera angle.

I've noticed M25 still gets a lot of love on here as well. Are people usually referring to/praising the PS3/360 version or the PS4/Xbox One version?

[NoleFan]

Quote: Originally Posted by ripcandlestickpark

I've noticed M25 still gets a lot of love on here as well. Are people usually referring to/praising the PS3/360 version or the PS4/Xbox One version?

I was wondering this as well. I can get M16 for example on 360 but, having a Series S, I'm out of luck for getting the PS4/XOne version unless I buy one of those consoles.

[gr18]

I'm thinking the ps3/360 version of M25 would be the one they're alluding to.I believe Armor and Sword mentioned it as being what he felt was one of the best versions along with 16 for ps4/xbox one.

[TarHeelPhenom]

Quote: Originally Posted by ripcandlestickpark

I've noticed M25 still gets a lot of love on here as well. Are people usually referring to/praising the PS3/360 version or the PS4/Xbox One version?

Definitely referring to the 360 version. I never got around to playing the One/PS4 version.