Yep, you would be the only one, considering the ball physics suck and there is nowhere near an infinite amount of animations. The ball is never effected by wind for one and it certainly doesn't bounce around accurately. Ever seen the ball warp into the hands of a DB in the NFL?
Play one whole season and you will see the same animations multiple times over. Same tackles, same post play animations, same throwing motions and jukes, etc.
I'm really not sure what game you are playing if you don't notice these things.
The AI sucks and continues to stink. CPU still doesn't run the ball well at all and can't throw for crap. LBs still intercept and swat down balls that they never would in real life.
I could go on and on.....