The Official Brandon Jacobs rating petition.

[H1DR03L3KTRIC]

Brandon Jacobs = 6 Receptions, 36 yards,

I think maybe the Giants fans should give a little more credit to the Giants O-line.

3 out of 4 running backs on the Giants averaged 5 or more yards per carry, Brandon Jacobs had the lowest average out of the three.

Derrick Ward 182 carries for 1025 yards = 5.6 ypc,

'nuff said
Brandon Jacobs is a mushroom and he is overated.

[83evans]

So far from reading this post, there are 10 giants fans on this forum.

[83evans]

Wow, Giants and Karr dont even know about Jonathon stewart

[dave374]

Wait till you see Jacobs in Madden 10.
You will have nothing to complain about.
He's an absolute beast.

[Glorious Arc]

Quote: Originally Posted by dave374

Wait till you see Jacobs in Madden 10. You will have nothing to complain about. He's an absolute beast.

From the Giants bandwagon...

"But...Hes not a 99!"

Sorry couldnt resist

[Guillotine 1]

As a Cowboys fan, and a NFC East purist...I say LEAVE JACOBS AS IS.

He is a beast.

[dannydufflebags]

Quote: Originally Posted by dave374

Wait till you see Jacobs in Madden 10. You will have nothing to complain about. He's an absolute beast.

Ya, they already said they were going to tune him into oblivion though......

[dannydufflebags]

Quote: Originally Posted by Glorious Arc

From the Giants bandwagon... "But...Hes not a 99!" Sorry couldnt resist

No, I think the last guy who said that Marion barber should not be rated higher than Jacobs, because Jacobs outperformed him 2 years in a row, with a very close skill set. If I didn't see those guys ahead of Jacobs, I probably would've never created this thread.

Honestly, my next thread is a poll to drop Fitzgerald from a 99 to a 94. He is def not better than Johnson and Moss by any means.