Madden 12 Top 4 Quarterbacks (Review)

[mpbaseball22]

Big Ben isnt slow at all.. no Pryor but he can pick up good yardage easily

[oneamongthefence]

What about Rosgers isn't elite?

[legenddt]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheSaints7

Yes that is my opinion. And I personally think Brees is better. Rodgers has better WR to aim for and also a better defence than the Saints. But I honestly think that if Packers played the Saints at the Superdome then New Orleans would win. I honestly think that.

Um, the packers have a much better chance of beating the saints at the superdome then the saints do of having to beat the packers at lambeau, in january.

Sent from my HTC EVO 3D X515a using Tapatalk

[quote=legenddt;2043133080]Um, the packers have a much better chance of beating the saints at the superdome then the saints do of having to beat the packers at lambeau, in january.

Not at all, If the Packers went to the Dome I reckon the Saints would win, Have not lost this season at the dome. Who have been green bays biggest challenge this year? New orleans, and we was 1 yeard off getting that TD and if possible the 2 pointer. I hope we play them at the dome in the NFC Championship and if we win I will be like, I told you so. WHO DAT!

[tarantism]

[quote=TheSaints7;2043133237]

Quote: Originally Posted by legenddt

Um, the packers have a much better chance of beating the saints at the superdome then the saints do of having to beat the packers at lambeau, in january. Not at all, If the Packers went to the Dome I reckon the Saints would win, Have not lost this season at the dome. Who have been green bays biggest challenge this year? New orleans, and we was 1 yeard off getting that TD and if possible the 2 pointer. I hope we play them at the dome in the NFC Championship and if we win I will be like, I told you so. WHO DAT!

The Saints are a one dimensional team with a piss poor defense. They may not even win the South!

[quote=tarantism;2043133312]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheSaints7

The Saints are a one dimensional team with a piss poor defense. They may not even win the South!

HAHA! Quite clearly not are they. That is why we are considered an elite team. We came the closest to winning Green Bay. YOU DIDNT. And we won Falcons so dont cry about it!!!

[TheDelta]

I'm sorry but I really don't agree with those ratings at all, and I'm pretty unbiased since I'm not a huge fan of any particular team, if anything, I sympathize with the Pats but I think it's not a huge difference whether you use Brees, Brady or Manning in the game. They all have all the throwing stats to make things happen, they are accurate and have high awareness, which is great, but since a lot of passing accuracy really depends on you, the player, the difference between them is marginal at best.

Rogers is really better than all of them by default simply because he is more mobile, which is just as huge a weapon in the game as it is IRL, if not more so. I can make all the throws with all of the elite QBs, but Brees will never scramble as fast as Rodgers, simple fact.

And you for some reason completely ignored Michael Vick. While I really don't like him IRL and I think his huge flaws have been exposed this season like I expected, it's hard to deny that he is still the best offensive weapon you can have in Madden. Yes, he's not quite as accurate as the elite, but does that really matter? He has the arm strength and if you are good at directional passing, there's not a huge difference on intermediate routes, while at the same time, he is still ridiculously fast and can outrun all Dlinemen in the game as well as almost all linebackers.

If we're talking about picking a QB for one game alone, I'd always take Vick, he's by far the best QB in the game in the sense of "the QB that gives me the best chance to win". Of course, I wouldn't want him in a franchise, simply because he's too old by now and will begin to lose his elite physical talent in a season or two.

[StreetCarp]

Sanchez > Rodgers > Brady > Brees >>>>> Roethlisberger