MLB 14 The Show OSFM Hybrid Roster - V1 Release

[buczneverlose]

MCCUTCHEN MVP RATED 81?!

[KayOtic723]

I love the OS community but guys he said don't worry about overall that also mean the ratings period! play about 20 games first i am playing game one and to me IMO its night and day difference in a good way

[Madden's Jowels]

Quote: Originally Posted by KayOtic723

I love the OS community but guys he said don't worry about overall that also mean the ratings period! play about 20 games first i am playing game one and to me IMO its night and day difference in a good way

Don't look at the overall ratings, sure, I can buy that. I know these were tuned to play a great game and not to have pretty overall ratings for the stars. I'm 100% down with that.


But how do you justify Ryan Braun's arm strength being like 25 points higher than Puig's? Those most certainly couldn't be based off ZiPs projections so somebody made a judgement call on that one and definitely goofed it up. That's just a physical trait, no skill involved. Puig has a cannon. I'm guessing it was probably a data entry error, somebody reading the wrong cell off a spreadsheet.

[JohnDoe8865]

Has anyone with a copy of OOTP 14/15 considered seeing how the defensive ratings in that game might translate to MLB 14? Just a thought, trying to offer another possible solution.

[LanteriX]

Rosters look great on first glance.

The fielding ratings being a problem seems quite overstated. There's a few outliers here and there, but I really wouldn't think that any kind of overhaul is really necessary at all. Rather, just clean up some of the mistakes here and there.

[COMMISSIONERHBK9]

is the beard situation that bad for the ps4 if i use these rosters. i am using the knight roster and i havent really seen an issues on the ps4. i need to know if i should restart and use this. once again willard good job. i had your roster last year

[URBYJT]

Quote: Originally Posted by Madden's Jowels

Don't look at the overall ratings, sure, I can buy that. I know these were tuned to play a great game and not to have pretty overall ratings for the stars. I'm 100% down with that. But how do you justify Ryan Braun's arm strength being like 25 points higher than Puig's? Those most certainly couldn't be based off ZiPs projections so somebody made a judgement call on that one and definitely goofed it up. That's just a physical trait, no skill involved. Puig has a cannon. I'm guessing it was probably a data entry error, somebody reading the wrong cell off a spreadsheet.

Probably has to do with the limited data on Puig. They said they'd fix it.

Quote: Originally Posted by JohnDoe8865

Has anyone with a copy of OOTP 14/15 considered seeing how the defensive ratings in that game might translate to MLB 14? Just a thought, trying to offer another possible solution.

That's a good idea. Though it seems like OOTP goes more indepth that it might be hard to make it translate, I dunno.

[Madden's Jowels]

^^^ I like the idea of using the Fangraphs fan scouting or whatever


Although, it's tempting to just stick the ratings into the game as is since they're base-100 and base-99, I'm guessing we'd get better results by coming up with some sort of algorithm haha.