Certain things about this game that dont make sense...

[LAfan1624]

Quote: Originally Posted by FADED

Replay challenges are in this years game. only thing is you kan't decide when to use them but they are in tha game. hopefully next year they leave it up to you when you wanna use your challenges.

They are? Ive only seen them on home run reviews on fair/foul balls.

[HustlinOwl]

Replays only on plays at 1B


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Bobhead]

lol didn't we just find out about the new home run derby rules like... a week ago?

I'm actually laughing at how ridiculous this topic is

[LAfan1624]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bobhead

lol didn't we just find out about the new home run derby rules like... a week ago? I'm actually laughing at how ridiculous this topic is

Aside from the home run derby these are all legitimate points.

[Jr.]

Quote: Originally Posted by LAfan1624

Aside from the home run derby these are all legitimate points.

The All-Star Game jerseys not being in has been explained numerous times, and isn't a legitimate gripe, in my opinion.

The awards point is pretty nit-picky, but it is incorrect in the game. If that's important to you, then I can see why you would want it changed.

Replay reviews are in, but extremely limited. I would expect that to be expanded next year.

[dougdfc]

My biggest gripe is that this game touts itself on being a simulator, yet the 2015 NL playoffs consisted of the Phillies, Padres, Cardinals, Mets and Nationals.

[cusefan74]

Quote: Originally Posted by dougdfc

My biggest gripe is that this game touts itself on being a simulator, yet the 2015 NL playoffs consisted of the Phillies, Padres, Cardinals, Mets and Nationals.

So it's not a sim because why? The only team that really does not have a chance of being in the playoffs this year is the Phillies.

[Speedy]

Some of y'awl are just very arrogant...

@ the OP:

1) SCEA has stated it's a memory issue they are working on; hopefully next year!

1a) The HR derby format was decided very recently, well after the game was shipped; this likely will be updated in 2016.*

2) I agree to this also...I believe they will focus heavily on franchise and statistics (sabermetrics especially) in 2016.*

3) Remember replay is just 2 years old; give SCEA some time to get the code right and how to work replays within a video game. Currently, it's coded to give the correct call each time which I'm okay with now.

*I am in no way a developer but I would think some of these things are fairly small (HR derby) while others the community has really pushed for (exhaustive franchise/statistics detail) and I feel they will work on for next year.