Thoughts for MLB 16 the Show (offline)

[lilrosati56]

I'm not one to really put much thought into the uniforms or equipment, it doesn't really bug me either. My wishlist is as follows:

1) Improved stats. I'm a Fangraphs and Baseball Reference junky, so looking at that stuff all day and then going to the Show's stats is a huge step down. So more stat categories and more view-able seasons is a MUST.

2) Improved manager AI logic. Too many times a Pedro Alvarez type hitter is left in to face a LOOGY, and vice versa. This detracts from a lot of the strategy of of lineup and bench construction.

3) I like Quick Counts and it's completely changed how I play, but if there were some way to make it so I could make a pitching or batting change before the count generates, that'd be great.

4) Improved satamina. Some players in MLB play 155+ games/year. That's pretty much impossible in this game.

5) Smarter regression.

All in all, this is a great game. The camera customizations along with working sliders allow you get get the pitcher-batter battle pretty much perfect. In fact, I'd say the on field play is borderline great! I'd just like more depth in the franchise, stat-wise. I want to be able to pick out a potential ground ball specialist to pick up for my bullpen.

[Jason27]

1. Fix player regression. Older players are regressing too quickly. An idea may be to copy what is done in season mode and have the attribute change take place at the end of the season.

2. Edit contacts in Franchise mode

3. Ability to edit coaches just as we are able to edit players.

4. In depth batter/pitcher statistics. If a batter dominates a particular pitcher or vice versa it would be nice if it was acknowledged in the game.

5. Continue to improve "suggested trades". To dive in deeper with trades not limiting the trade to 3 players on each side would be nice.

6. I love Quick Counts! If a more hitter friendly counts could be generated that would be nice.

7. I don't really care for assigning training assignments in franchise mode.

8. Keep adding equipment brands! One of my favorite things in MLB 15 the Show.

[saintloue28]

After playing NBA 2k16, I think relocation/rebrand would be amazing! I know the heads at MLB and the owners are probably a bit less modern. But I'm sure Sony can do some convincing. Lol.

Sent from my SM-N910T using Tapatalk

[OneTonneBaby]

Big one for me would be stats. Most of them are outdated.

even most mainstream baseball sites carry things like WAR, BABIP, FIP etc... which are all just formulas of stats which should be easy to implement id guess.

outfielders need a look as they miss the ball far too many times.

fielding bunts by the AI and user is bad as well.

[Clarityman]

Quote: Originally Posted by biggio7

Also, FA prices should be fixed. CC Sabathia shouldn't be a declining player and dropped to a 68 overall asking for 22 million a season... then a team (Phillies) sign him to it for 2 years? There are way too many budget issues then regarding trades because of things like this. Thought of another, I'd like more diversity with 2nd positions. Guys should be eligible at other positions after playing so much at one too. But, I should be able to select utility or something instead of just given one option.

Idk I could see the Phillies making that move

[adamj2281]

Yeah, here are my quick thoughts on Franchise/Gameplay (although MLB 15 fixed a lot of my complaints with regard to Franchise - trade logic is passable, editable contracts, rookie/MILB contracts, etc.)

-FA Logic: For the most part the signings have made more sense, but we still get situations where teams will sign someone just because they have money (I saw the Giants beat me out for M. Wieters,, he had 100 AB's the following season)

-Allow trades of team-controlled players early in the offseason, as it stands now you have to either coax the player into resigning early on, or wait until February and renew everyone then make trades.

-Progression/Regression: Not as worried about older players declining, I'm figuring the dice roll on this works out. However, I'd like performance count a bit more in both directions, to punish the team if you bring players up too soon and the falter.

Maybe keep the expected MLB date with the player's info and have it update each offseason based on potential, performance, etc. and explain the cost ramifications or bringing players up early (maybe a info window that explains the years of team control, etc.)

Gameplay:

-Zone plus Analog: Have a way to set the directional hitting prior to the pitch, kinda of like guess pitch. I still love zone plus analog hitting, and like the new system far as not having to time your step.

- Fielding, it would be cool to add certain animations that are only available if you have certain fielding/reaction #'s, pretty sure this already exists, just add more.

Stadiums:

-My own Braves bias - please add Suncoast Park to be available in the 2nd year of Franchise, I think it would be a cool addition and add to your "little things" litany of additions.

That's all I have, commentary is what it is, if they want to overhaul it, great, if not, it's not going to ruin the game by any stretch.

-

[dran1984]

Quote: Originally Posted by adamj2281

Yeah, here are my quick thoughts on Franchise/Gameplay (although MLB 15 fixed a lot of my complaints with regard to Franchise - trade logic is passable, editable contracts, rookie/MILB contracts, etc.) -FA Logic: For the most part the signings have made more sense, but we still get situations where teams will sign someone just because they have money (I saw the Giants beat me out for M. Wieters,, he had 100 AB's the following season) -Allow trades of team-controlled players early in the offseason, as it stands now you have to either coax the player into resigning early on, or wait until February and renew everyone then make trades. -Progression/Regression: Not as worried about older players declining, I'm figuring the dice roll on this works out. However, I'd like performance count a bit more in both directions, to punish the team if you bring players up too soon and the falter. Maybe keep the expected MLB date with the player's info and have it update each offseason based on potential, performance, etc. and explain the cost ramifications or bringing players up early (maybe a info window that explains the years of team control, etc.) Gameplay: -Zone plus Analog: Have a way to set the directional hitting prior to the pitch, kinda of like guess pitch. I still love zone plus analog hitting, and like the new system far as not having to time your step. - Fielding, it would be cool to add certain animations that are only available if you have certain fielding/reaction #'s, pretty sure this already exists, just add more. Stadiums: -My own Braves bias - please add Suncoast Park to be available in the 2nd year of Franchise, I think it would be a cool addition and add to your "little things" litany of additions. That's all I have, commentary is what it is, if they want to overhaul it, great, if not, it's not going to ruin the game by any stretch. -

Won't/Can't happen for multiple reasons

[The Left Shark]

Didn't really feel like reading or skimming through all the pages but a couple thoughts from myself:


1. Bring back the swing stick. This year just didn't do it for me and I found the new way very unenjoyable and I could not get into the game. The swing stick from the past few years made hitting feel more authentic.


2. A pet peeve of mine is seeing everyone start sprinting out of the box on drop third strikes. Maybe program it so only guys with a certain (maybe 90 minimum?) speed, aggressiveness, or baserunning ability run to first. It is cringe worthy watching David Ortiz spring hard out of the box to first seeing as though he does no more than a jog when he actually hits it.


3. Just so it easier to make real roster moves, maybe let rosters go up to 100 with a minimum of 90 so its easier to keep it updated. For example: its the point in the season when OSFM rosters are released but then your favorite team signs a guy who was just released or claims him. Then you have to drop a guy on the roster who may still be there and don't really want to drop prospects as they are more than just (unknown players).


Just a couple thoughts here.