|
Quote: |
|
|
|
|
Originally Posted by Yari |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I had previously bought the '15, '16, and '17 versions of the game but after seeing the direction that MLB The Show went this year I felt that I'm better off holding on to my $60. I say this because while I'm a fan of franchise mode, I have a more complete product in OOTP which I can still play just as effectively after a long day and not have to tune down the difficulty to compensate for reduced reaction time.
Additionally, the changes to RTTS were a major factor in my not buying '18 due to the forced nerfs even for transfers. If I wanted to play "be an average shortstop" I can already impose my own attribute caps and don't need the game to do that for me. While I do like the idea of the various templates, I do not like that they are forced upon you without a choice. I have spent a lot of effort getting my RTTS player to all 99's through three versions of the game and I'd prefer not to have that work eroded away by an artificial cap (though I could live with aging eroding it).
Finally, while some of the Diamond Dynasty changes are neat, the fact that this mode still requires an internet connection even for offline play is extremely disappointing to me. I'd like to be able to complete the mode but I would not be able to do so before the servers get shut down entirely and all of my progress is lost. It is my opinion that any card collecting mode must be available offline and Diamond Dynasty does not meet that criteria. Additionally, the additions to this year's mode with having to get nonfunctional collectables is another turn off. If this were like the Skybox/Crib from the now defunct 2K sports series, I could live with it because at least I'd have a neat place to store my stuff in that I can view offline. However, I don't particularly care to look at nonfunctional jersey or bobblehead cards.
In summary, MLB the Show '18 is a good attempt, but it's not for me. Now if RTTS gets rid of the forced caps, franchise mode gets some major love, and DD is available truly offline with a little skybox to decorate and personalize, then I'll be interested in returning to the series again.
|
|
|
|
|
|
I think people read too much into the cap system and don't give it a chance. I have a "defensive cannon" that is an absolute beast. I steal 40 bases, hit 40-50 HR, bat around .350, etc. Same for the fielding.... plenty of range, diving catches, robbing HR's, gunning down runners, etc. The equipment that you can equip to your player carries you into the 90's on most attributes other than ones you will never use.
As for the game.... it's the most fun I've had with the game and RTTS in a long time. When I settle in for the evenings I've played everyday since it dropped. There are more "little things" that I'm seeing in games that give it an awesome touch. I love the variety of hits.... line drive missile HR's, towering shots, bloop singles, etc. Also love the added emotion for strikeouts, poor AB's, etc. I have held off buying some of the titles I've been looking forward to (Far Cry 5, God of War) because right now I have no desire to play anything else.