NBA Elite 11 Demo Available, Post Impressions Here (PS3, 360)

[tha_show256]

Quote: Originally Posted by erob1962

Just tried to play this game again...couldnt stomach it. NBA Elite almost reminds me of the days when you were just satisfied that your player had the mapped on faces of your basketball heroes. Could play those games all day long. But gaming has moved past 2003 ...gone? I think I'm not alone when I say I expect so much more from todays Gen sports game. I want signature walks,moves,shots and dunks. I want signature team plays and offensive and defensive schemes. I'm sure if I spent more time on the controls this would be a lackluster 1 on 5 arcady experience of a game. But like I wrote at the beginning of this post ... I've played those games earlier in the decade. I need and expect so much more for my 60 bucks. Maybe they can bundle it with the Sports Illustrated package...again to move it off the shelves. Umm ... is this game targetting the Wii Generation?

That's what I think it really is, this game is for the Wii generation, that want to control every aspect of the game no matter how it looks or plays to its real life counterparts! I think, if your the type of gamer that loves the Wii and what it does and represents to gamers this game is for you. If you want style,signature,NBA authencity, you like the other game! Myself, well, lets just say I won't give my answer in this the Elite thread.

[pdawg17]

Wow...now people complain about having TOO MUCH control...I am LOVING that part of the game personally...in other games (including Live 10) I got sick of driving to the basket only to be "forced" into a crazy, windmill flip shot...in Elite if I'm driving to the basket and someone steps in front of me, I love being able to adjust to a left or right-handed layup - whatever I choose...in the other games I am constantly "surprised" by how my player finishes a shot which to me shouldn't happen - even if that "finish" looks really cool or realistic...if I didn't choose to do that move then it's not satisfying...

[Super Glock]

Quote: Originally Posted by pdawg17

Wow...now people complain about having TOO MUCH control...I am LOVING that part of the game personally...in other games (including Live 10) I got sick of driving to the basket only to be "forced" into a crazy, windmill flip shot...in Elite if I'm driving to the basket and someone steps in front of me, I love being able to adjust to a left or right-handed layup - whatever I choose...in the other games I am constantly "surprised" by how my player finishes a shot which to me shouldn't happen - even if that "finish" looks really cool or realistic...if I didn't choose to do that move then it's not satisfying...

I agree, I'm really digging the control I have like you mentioned. It makes it better than Live 10 for that reason alone. I absolutely hated the 2 player canned animation in Live 10 when I was driving to the basket.

[ryan36]

No comparisons guys. I'm gonna post it every time I see one until it stops. People are getting banned for this

[fatleg3]

Quote: Originally Posted by JWiLL02

Shooting is arguably the easiest aspect of the new control system...you push up on the shot stick, that's all. Once you get the timing down, it's entirely possible to hit every shot with Kobe, especially from mid range. Having to constantly make sure the ball is in the proper hand while moving around the court is the hardest part IMO. Not that it's difficult, it's just extremely awkward.

isnt every basketball game like that with shooting and timing. the thing with elite is you have to have it straight.

I seen a couple post where people say they have been going 10/10, 9/10 and so on. If thats true then you are very talented at this and i dont see why you would not like that. it means you are doing something right. I just dont understand. If a player shoots 40% from the field irl do you want the game to make 40% of his shoots go in the make the rest go out, our have that reflected in how big the sweet spot is at different spots on the court which is what dna is for.

I hardly make shots that im being contested on from mid range on out. The cpu on the other hand is just like live 10. when they are down it seems like every player shoots like kobe

And i like that about having to have the ball in the correct hand. Everytime i have to ball in the wrong hand guess what happens. The cpu knocks it out. it punishes me for making that mistake.

[tha_show256]

Quote: Originally Posted by pdawg17

Wow...now people complain about having TOO MUCH control...I am LOVING that part of the game personally...in other games (including Live 10) I got sick of driving to the basket only to be "forced" into a crazy, windmill flip shot...in Elite if I'm driving to the basket and someone steps in front of me, I love being able to adjust to a left or right-handed layup - whatever I choose...in the other games I am constantly "surprised" by how my player finishes a shot which to me shouldn't happen - even if that "finish" looks really cool or realistic...if I didn't choose to do that move then it's not satisfying...

To me, its not about having to much control...I love the fact that I have that much control. I've stated that before in this thread...Its satisying to know that I just did what I did and I know why and how it did what it did. If that makes sense to you?? On the other hand, there's only some many times I can watch the way this game moves and how bad it looks doing it! I'm sorry this game is just and eye sore, really so much so if you look at games like NCAA and Mad The Show for instance. With all the style and flair of real NBA players I want my Kobe Bryant to have Kobe Bryant signature style and flair! Something this game lacks, very much so. To me, its just a matter of opinions and taste. But I think, the general conseus on this title is overwhemly to one end of this specturum....

[pdawg17]

Quote: Originally Posted by fatleg3

isnt every basketball game like that with shooting and timing. the thing with elite is you have to have it straight. I seen a couple post where people say they have been going 10/10, 9/10 and so on. If thats true then you are very talented at this and i dont see why you would not like that. it means you are doing something right. I just dont understand. If a player shoots 40% from the field irl do you want the game to make 40% of his shoots go in the make the rest go out, our have that reflected in how big the sweet spot is at different spots on the court which is what dna is for. I hardly make shots that im being contested on from mid range on out. The cpu on the other hand is just like live 10. when they are down it seems like every player shoots like kobe And i like that about having to have the ball in the correct hand. Everytime i have to ball in the wrong hand guess what happens. The cpu knocks it out. it punishes me for making that mistake.

I love the challenge with the dribbling...when I try to go right with the ball in my left hand, I should be slower and should get my pocket picked for that...it's one more thing to pay attention to which to me is great...

[CutthroatGold]

I admire Elite for the innovation of total control in this installment of EA's B-Ball game. I for one, like that you have control in game....but what happened to the graphics and AI!?!? Playing the "other" demo, I was blown away with presentation and all the little trimmings.

Don't get me wrong, I really like the boldness of EA in taking the line in another direction and trying something new, but if this is where they are taking the retail version...I'm sorry I'm not giving them my money.

Overall I give it 6 out of 10