Bigger game killer?

[fossen]

Your whole thread is predicated on a false statement.

If you are trying to make some comparision to ESPN, you are not asking the right question. ESPN is quite obviously not inferior in the gameplay department .... they have different strengths and weaknesses, but you're just trolling by setting up a comparision that doesn't exist.

[MachoMyers]

whoa...you can't enter names?

Hope this doesn't happen w/ football next year

[fossen]

Quote: Originally Posted by DreBly

whoa...you can't enter names? Hope this doesn't happen w/ football next year

You can enter names .... the limit is 324, however.

[TheBandit]

Isn't it nice how we have two great games for everything now?

[ELDoro]

only being able to edit 324 players is a bigger killer for myself.....

[jmike500]

hey.can u guys help me out?

[sputin]

Quote: Originally Posted by fossen

Your whole thread is predicated on a false statement. If you are trying to make some comparision to ESPN, you are not asking the right question. ESPN is quite obviously not inferior in the gameplay department .... they have different strengths and weaknesses, but you're just trolling by setting up a comparision that doesn't exist.

his thread is predicated on an opinion albeit an unpopular one.

i have both games and taking their different strengths and weaknesses into consideration i still think that espn is inferior on the court.

inferior has a negative connotation but it's not meant as a slight to choops. when compared to mm, ch is inferior on the court. mm has inferior graphics.

ultimately it's up to the individual to decide which "inferiorities" he/she can live with.

i'll cede mm's much better on the court play, commentary, and atmosphere. but the dated graphics, camera angles, roster limit, online problems, etc make it difficult for me to choose mm over ch2k5.

so to answer the question...

if i were only interested in playing exhibitions games vs. the cpu - which i am not, without a doubt the bigger game killer would be so-so gameplay.

[Alliball]

My thread is predicated on a "what if". There is no EA and there is no ESPN. There is just game A and game B. Game A has very good game play but you can't edit all the names, while game B has just so-so game play but you can edit every player to your heart's content. So I asked which is more important or on the other hand a game killer.

I don't have either game so I can't form an opinion on them.