Who has the most recently updated PS3 rosters?

[wookie48]

Quote: Originally Posted by jdrhammer

Wookie, I looked at your rosters but I didn't do anything to them since I'm waiting on the patch. One thing I did notice was Julio Jones rated a 90. Really??? That's kind of stretching it isn't it?

Dude, #1 recruit in the nation, starting as a true freshman, nick saban is the coach, and JPW is thowing him the ball. That might be valid. Naw seriously, I saw the kid play and he is gonna be good. He is in the right place and saban will get the ball to him. I had to make some edits on ala so my locker is current, I will update the sendspace a little later.

[jdrhammer]

Quote: Originally Posted by wookie48

Dude, #1 recruit in the nation, starting as a true freshman, nick saban is the coach, and JPW is thowing him the ball. That might be valid. Naw seriously, I saw the kid play and he is gonna be good. He is in the right place and saban will get the ball to him. I had to make some edits on ala so my locker is current, I will update the sendspace a little later.

I know he'll be a player but a freshman is a freshman. At 84, as originally created, he'd be draft eligible as a JR and would be in the 90's. He's like everyone else, unproven. Rolle for FSU was way overrated as well. One thing the roster guy does is overshoot on freshman. The guy that creates them overdoes it.

I know you've seen him, but I saw him get shut down by MS in the HS All-Star game. He didn't show out against lesser rated prospects.

[wookie48]

Quote: Originally Posted by jdrhammer

I know he'll be a player but a freshman is a freshman. At 84, as originally created, he'd be draft eligible as a JR and would be in the 90's. He's like everyone else, unproven. Rolle for FSU was way overrated as well. One thing the roster guy does is overshoot on freshman. The guy that creates them overdoes it. I know you've seen him, but I saw him get shut down by MS in the HS All-Star game. He didn't show out against lesser rated prospects.

Ok here you go then, is you knew what you know now about soph jeremy maclin from missouri, and we aere playing ncaa 08 how would you rate him? Or how about freshman sam bradford. See where I am going?

[wookie48]

Quote: Originally Posted by jdrhammer

I know he'll be a player but a freshman is a freshman. At 84, as originally created, he'd be draft eligible as a JR and would be in the 90's. He's like everyone else, unproven. Rolle for FSU was way overrated as well. One thing the roster guy does is overshoot on freshman. The guy that creates them overdoes it. I know you've seen him, but I saw him get shut down by MS in the HS All-Star game. He didn't show out against lesser rated prospects.

Ok I see your point but here goes a good thought process for you. If you knew then what you know now about oklahoma QB sam bradford, missouri jeremy maclin, and kansas qb todd reesing how would rate them? You see its not so much the 90 rating. Thats why I hate the way EA rates players. I loved how 2k did their rating system. The only thing I changed for jones was his AWR. Also you cant judge an athlete because of how he preformed in the high school all america game. No biggie change it if you want but I have a feeling youll change it back. Also same deal with all america myron rolle. All I changed was his AWR. You want ot know why? Check his major and what his peers say about him on ESPN. LOL

[whicho17]

Wookie are your rosters going to work now that the patch is out? If so what's your PSN? Thanks

[Kenji Saitama]

Wookie, I was about to download your home-made roster file.

But you say you're gonna make a patch file.

Should I wait a little longer or is it okay if I just play the ncaa09 with your current roster file installed?

[jdrhammer]

Quote: Originally Posted by wookie48

Ok I see your point but here goes a good thought process for you. If you knew then what you know now about oklahoma QB sam bradford, missouri jeremy maclin, and kansas qb todd reesing how would rate them? You see its not so much the 90 rating. Thats why I hate the way EA rates players. I loved how 2k did their rating system. The only thing I changed for jones was his AWR. Also you cant judge an athlete because of how he preformed in the high school all america game. No biggie change it if you want but I have a feeling youll change it back. Also same deal with all america myron rolle. All I changed was his AWR. You want ot know why? Check his major and what his peers say about him on ESPN. LOL

You really can't judge a guy from an All-Star game. You're totally right there. I'm not calling you out nor am I claiming to be an expert because I promise I'm not. I just thought a 90 was a stretch for any true FR. Also, I thought his spd was 89 before edits and I think you had him at 93 spd. No big deal. I know we can't predict the Maclin's and Reesing's but FR are normally a little over rated by EA's standards so everyone should be pretty close without inflating ratings. And there are always a few that are under rated but they're the 2* and some of the 3* guys.

No problem, I'll check out your rosters any way. Thanks for putting in the time.

[wookie48]

Quote: Originally Posted by jdrhammer

You really can't judge a guy from an All-Star game. You're totally right there. I'm not calling you out nor am I claiming to be an expert because I promise I'm not. I just thought a 90 was a stretch for any true FR. Also, I thought his spd was 89 before edits and I think you had him at 93 spd. No big deal. I know we can't predict the Maclin's and Reesing's but FR are normally a little over rated by EA's standards so everyone should be pretty close without inflating ratings. And there are always a few that are under rated but they're the 2* and some of the 3* guys. No problem, I'll check out your rosters any way. Thanks for putting in the time.

Oh no dude its cool, were just having a conversation. I know its rare on a forum to have a mature debate over sports without involving emotion its all good man. Nothin but love from north carolina!