I dont think it would be Vick since they have a 97 and 99. A SS Kam chancellor would be most beneficial to our teams probably, he had a great nfl season and was a beast at VT. I could see a brandon flowers or deangelo hall (cbs), darryl tapp who was a monster at VT, they could very well gives us a Darren Evans/David Wilson/Ryan Williams which were all beast HBs. The most underrated player by far on here from VT is Tyrod Taylor (QB) He led us to 3 ACC championships, ACC POY, lost of records broken and he is a bronze like 68 or something.
Of course the home run for this would be a 99 Bruce Smith (end) or 99 Jake Grove (center) but I dont think either will make it in the game for whatever reason EA doesn't have license for or what not.