The top QBs 10 thread

[feeq14]

For the sake of discussion in the ides of April i figure what better than a list to get people arguing and keep discussions lively in boring NFL offseason.

Here is my list of my top 10 modern era QBs (60s-now) based in order of importance on,

Overall ability as a QB,
Stats,
Championsips,
Winning legacy,
Lasting impact on game,
Intangibles.


Elway
Young
Bradshaw
Montana
Brady
Manning
Marino
Aikman
Favre
Moon

I know a few are gonna contest moons position on the list, but I really think that moons legacy as a true pocket QB, not to mention that he was highly talented and has ridiculous stats, (especially if you include Canada) you have to put him in there. You give moon a Championship and he is possibly top 5.

But this is my opinion please post your own lists and try to keep debates on top as I know this will quickly become charged.

[snepp]

Young?

No Unitas?

[ProfessaPackMan]

1.Montana
2.Unitas
3.Starr
4.Elway
5.Favre
6.Marino
7.Bradshaw
8.Moon
9.Aikman
10.Young

[totalownership]

I don't even know if I really want to put Bradshaw up there. He used to throw up alot of junk and his receivers were bailing him out left and right.

[SPTO]

I'd love to say Jim Kelly is #1 on my list but sadly he isn't. I can only do a top 4 as anything after that is interchangeable.

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Marino
4. Unitas

[ProfessaPackMan]

I still can't see how people can put Brady in the Top 5 unless people are doing strictly super bowl wins

[Brandon13]

Quote: Originally Posted by ProfessaPackMan

I still can't see how people can put Brady in the Top 5 unless people are doing strictly super bowl wins

Well, you could probably say the same thing about Montana.

[Saber]

Quote: Originally Posted by Brandon13

Well, you could probably say the same thing about Montana.

or Aikman.