S38s you were onto something with the bump. Lately I've been bumping, shading to the outside, and using inside zones to muck things up.
I really think that man press is the counter to a spread offense. I just played a guy who liked to go 4-5 wide the whole game. My strength lied at linebacker, DL, and SS. I had 1 bronze CB, that's it.
I ran man bump probably 75% of the time and came back from down 20-7 ton win 21-20 because he wouldn't run the ball. He had something like 26 passes and 6 runs. I have no sympathy for me sitting in 3-2 dime press when this guy won't line it up and run the ball. Why should I change?
Well I didn't and it paid off. I made multiple stops in the 2nd half and won the game. Lesson learned: Kill spread defenses with man press, especially effective with pass rushing talent. If I had Deacon Jones or Randy White he would've been wanting to quit.
It's too easy to break a zone defense in a spread formation. The guy could run slants/posts/outs on me all day no matter what zone was called. I get into bump and he can't get anything off and ends up throwing away over 5 passes.
This game I was controlling my gold SS to manually take away inside routes, but with some guts you could control a pass rusher and improve in that area too. In fact, I've been labbing manual rushing with my gold OLB and I am definitely learning how to apply talent properly against a spread offense. Simple: make him hold the ball. This turns it into "your" game which is the pass rush. Simple pitch and catch is not "your" game when you don't have talent at DB to work it.
Okay rant over. Simply said, Outside shading in bump should be seen as the standard approach... take away easy fade points and things get tougher. It covers inside routes better than you'd think.
Edit: Wait a second there fellow APF'er. I know what you're thinking - "Oh gosh oh golly gee willickers that sounds kinda unfair!"
Here's the counter: RUN THE FREAKING BALL! Line it up, and pound it down the throat of your opponent. You'll break big ones all day. Scramble with your QB... run with him if things aren't working.