NCAA 07:
I don't remember the name for these two recruits but I was simulating seasons while coaching Florida.
The first was like a 3* ATH who was about 6' 215 or somewhere in that range. A true athlete, he could have played at QB, HB, LB, CB, FS, and DE. I ended up plugging him in at SS (he had 82 or so speed). He redshirted for a year, and since he was still behind a highly rated SS I let him play in the nickel. Freshman All-American, and All Conference awards. He went on to become a two time 1st team all-american, and won the Jim Thorpe award.
The second was a QB while at Florida. I had the sim set to running a flexbone option offense, and in comes this QB who probably a 4* QB at one point but had just never played. Come his senior season he stepped in and went to town throwing for 3500+ yards, running for another 1000+, winning a heisman, and a national championship.
NCAA 09:
I was in an OD (Pro Style) playing as Cincinnati. Within my first or second year I had to replace almost all of my defensive starters so my MLB position was handed over to a 3* recruit out of Ohio named Chris Herron. At 6'3 240 he had all the size, but maybe not the athleticism you wanted (78 speed). He progressed really well throughout his career. He left after his junior season (damn that glitch) and he had reach 86 or 88 overall. He was a two time all-american, and I even managed to break 100 tackles with him during his junior season.
NCAA 11:
I played 9 seasons in an online dynasty with the Legends League, and I took home 3 national championships. Needless to say I had some great players during my time.
The first in the infamous Marcus Guidry who garnered a lot of hate from my rival at FSU. I had left Miss. St. after one season to join Miami. I was going to have Jacory Harris for one season, and I was certainly worried about the barren QB situation. During the season I pulled in a 4* QB and a 4* JUCO QB who was in the ESPN150.
Despite this success, and a surrounding amazing recruiting class (this class would go on to anchor the team for four years), I still wasn't to thrilled about what would happen to my QB situation the next season. Off-season recruiting came up, and a new 5* QB appeared by the name of Marcus Guidry.
I entered a fierce recruiting battle for him with the Georgia and FSU users (though I started at no. 1 and felt confident that he was never going anywhere else.) I entered into an illicit back room deal with the FSU user that resulted in him backing off, and allowed me to close out on Guidry.
The rest is history. Guidry went on to win a national championship his freshman year (a team starting a mess load of freshmen all over the place), and another one his junior year. He re-wrote the Miami record book, finished over 15,000 yards passing, and even broke the NCAA record for career TD passes (which the dynasty TTU user had previously broken). His senior year he came up short of another national championship appearence (damn FSU), but he still took home a Heisman trophy and all the other offensive hardware he was eligible for.
After Guidry finished his playings days, I did what Urban Meyer should have done when Tebow graduated, and took my services elsewhere. I wandered down to LSU. I had a few stud defensive players that I didn't personally recruit, but they were there for my three year stint.
MLB Tony Galloway - 6'1 250lb MLB with 91 speed. This man was the anchor of my defense. He was all over the place making tackles, interceptions, and crushing ball carriers (ask AuburnAlumni). He came out with a vengeance in his senior season and won LB of the year on the way to a national championship.
FS Matt Hawk - 6'4 224lb with a lot of speed, and strength. Unfortunately he was behind a FS who had the same amount of eligibility as him. I took a page out of the Packers playbook and used the nickel 2-4-5 as a base defense and moved Hawk down into the nickel (despite less then ideal coverage ability). I even played Hawk at MLB in the 3-4 in a few instances. He flourished, and it resulted in two All-American nominations as well as being one of the team's leading tacklers.
CB - Brian Crews- 6'2 194. Just a tall, and rangy guy. I didn't think much of him during his sophomore year since the CB opposite of him was a stud recruit who played up to hype. Starting in his junior season Crews went on a tear of shutting down receivers and making QBs pay for looking in his direction. He finished with LSU records for interceptions in a single season, career, and even broke the NCAA single season record. He was a force to be reckoned with.