Same here man. I get the 3 football games each year (NCAA, Madden, ESPN) and hold no loyalty to just one company. I will call a spade a spade if you know what I mean. I will give props for something that is done well, but not turn a blind eye to something that either company just "dropped" the ball on. When it comes to videogames, I have been playing since the Atari 2600, and man we have come along way. Guys don't know how good they got it today (just showed my age a little..lol).
Seems today, guys are looking for the "holy grail" of sports games. It is not going to happen. Each game is going to have its good/bad points. And what those points are, depends upon the individual. Sure, some glitches are agreed upon across the board, but you get my meaning.
Well, just my 2 cents. Cya on the boards man...