Raiders Make Switch to 3-4 Defense
The Raiders and defensive coordinator John Marshall have announced an official switch to the 3-4 defense today. There are compelling reasons to go back to a 3-4 defensive front seven, considering Oakland used the 3-4 set successfully from 1976 through 1989, winning 62% of the games. By contrast, since converting to a 4-3 Defensive (2 DTs, 2DEs, 2 OLBs and 1 MLB) we have won only 52% of our games. Incidentally, in all three SB Championship victories and the seasons leading up to those Super Bowls, Oakland used the 3-4 defense.
While no one will attribute the successes or failures solely to the configuration of the front 7, the use of current talent is a major factor to the results in the win/loss column. Therefore, after considering the current player strengths and weaknesses and the inherent advantages of the 3-4 Defense scheme, the benefits of reinstalling the 3-4 should be clear.
Consider the strength at DE: Matt Shaughnessy, Jay Richardson and Rich Seymour. Richardson and Seymour are prototype DEs in the 3-4 scheme, stalwart and quick.
Consider the DT weakness: the sometimes terrific Gerard Warren lacks consistency and Tommy Kelly can't be described any better. These DTs are quick but not huge and have been pushed around in the interior on too many occasions, but they might work out as DEs in a 3-4 set.
Now consider the LB strength and weakness: Thomas Howard and Trevor Scott on the outside are doing a great job; MLB Kirk Morrison is a sure but soft tackler who isn't a true MLB (can't intimidate or direct play), and may find himself left out of the mix.
The Oakland Press caught up with D.C. John Marshall at his official press conference today.
O.P: It's our understanding that you helped install the 3-4 in San Francisco, but why did you see fit to do this with our current roster?
J.M.: Truth be told, there are different forms of 3-4 defenses, fairly radically different too. There will likely be as many sub packages (non-3-4 looks) as 3-4 looks.
O.P.: Any concerns that your current roster lacks the athletes to properly implement this scheme?
J.M.: No matter what way you line up out there, good defense comes down to proper execution. Regardless, I'm not going to pigeonhole guys into situations in which they cannot successfully play in.
O.P.: As we know, the nose tackle is the most important piece of a 3-4 defense. It's very hard to find ones that aren't too tall, but are big enough to stand their ground even if they get double teamed. Do you feel we have one on this roster?
J.M.: I believe we have what it takes to make it happen.
O.P.: Who will that player be?
J.M.: There will be competition. It's too early to tell.
O.P.: In recent years, the defense has ran the same basic 4-3, man-to-man scheme. Can we expect more exotic looks? Do you plan to move Nnamdi around? Will he be used like Revis in New York?
J.M.: Well, we'll have plenty of different packages and plenty of personnel running through. Exotic? That's debatable. Revis is Revis, but I'm very excited to plug Nnamdi in. They're both great players.
O.P.: Can you guarantee improvement even with our current roster that seems to lack the players needed for success?
J.M.: Look, the 3-4 is a very specialized defense, but it's just a scheme. We aren't the only ones running it in the NFL, and it's not a best kept secret. I'm fully aware that each position requires something quite different from both a technique and physical skill-set point of view. Either way, we look forward to getting on the field and making it happen.
Time will tell if Oakland made a positive change, but at least they're attempting to change. All things considered, if we were to install the 3-4 today it would look much like this:
RDE - M. Shaughnessy
LDE - R. Seymour
NT - T.Kelly
ROLB - K. Wimbley
LOLB - T. Howard
RILB - R. Brown
LILB - R. McClain
SS - T.Branch
FS - M. Huff
RCB - N. Asomugha
LCB - C. Johnson
A 3-4 will require a stud Nose Tackle by way of the draft next year or free agency. Most likely, an upgrade at Linebacker would help as well. Either way, things are either on their way up in Oakland, or about to come crashing down.
-------
*NOTE* (I meant to post this BEFORE the season started but I forgot. I didn't make a mid-season change to the 3-4, but I started this way in preseason.)
*NOTE*