MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[jmontanez90]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sandoval to the Yankees for Slade Heathcott and Manny Banuelos

Sandoval to the Dodgers for Zach Lee

Sandoval to the D'backs for Chase Anderson and Stryker Trahan

Even with Chris Johnson extended, I believe a contending Braves team would be interested in Sandoval and they could offer up one of their young starters in return. Get JR Graham and Joey Terdoslavich in return. Or settle for C prospect Christian Betancourt and a lower end pitcher

Belt can get you a little more in return.

Thanks for the suggestions. As far as Belt goes, what do you think I can fetch for him?

And now that the Marlins are in town tonight I might as well ask, what do you think it would cost to get Stanton?

[Hender3]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Jordy Mercer
Asdrubal Cabrera
Everth Cabrera
Stephen Drew
Sean Rodriguez
Jonathan Villar
Jimmy Rollins
Ruben Tejada
JJ Hardy

...any specific type of player you'd like? All round? Power bat? Strictly glove?

Doesn't matter, all around preferred.. I had Cozart batting 8th. Line up as follows

1.BHam
2.Votto
3.@DatDudeBp
4.BRUUUUUCE
5.Ludwick
6.Frazier
7.Meso
8.Cozart
9.Pitcher

[PhilliesFan13]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Still considering giving it a little more time, but I am getting ZERO production from my Rays catchers Ryan Hanigan and Jose Molina. It's horrendous. Them and Yunel Escobar are pretty much the only regulars who aren't playing well at all. The defense is there, but the offense from those 3 is non-existent.

Any catcher suggestions?

[Totte]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Still considering giving it a little more time, but I am getting ZERO production from my Rays catchers Ryan Hanigan and Jose Molina. It's horrendous. Them and Yunel Escobar are pretty much the only regulars who aren't playing well at all. The defense is there, but the offense from those 3 is non-existent.



Any catcher suggestions?

Ryan Lavarnway, BOS
Hector Sanchez, SF
Brayan Pena, CIN
Victor Martinez, DET

[Totte]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Doesn't matter, all around preferred.. I had Cozart batting 8th. Line up as follows



1.BHam

2.Votto

3.@DatDudeBp

4.BRUUUUUCE

5.Ludwick

6.Frazier

7.Meso

8.Cozart

9.Pitcher

I'd target JJ Hardy. Good glove, some speed and nice pop

Give Cozart and Guillon in return?

[Coper3000]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Still considering giving it a little more time, but I am getting ZERO production from my Rays catchers Ryan Hanigan and Jose Molina. It's horrendous. Them and Yunel Escobar are pretty much the only regulars who aren't playing well at all. The defense is there, but the offense from those 3 is non-existent.

Any catcher suggestions?

I think Jason Castro could be a nice fit for the Rays.

[Totte]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think Jason Castro could be a nice fit for the Rays.

Yes! Great call right there. He'd slot in nicely in that Joe Maddon lineup

[Coper3000]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Yes! Great call right there. He'd slot in nicely in that Joe Maddon lineup

Shipping him there in my Astros Franchise is something I've thrown around. Max Stassi is waiting in the wings, and is pretty good defensively too.

Spreadsheet calls for a Mid B + Mid C for Castro. Could you picture a trade centered around Hak-Ju?

[PhilliesFan13]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think Jason Castro could be a nice fit for the Rays.

Yes! Great call right there. He'd slot in nicely in that Joe Maddon lineup

Interesting. I will definitely look into Castro. I would consider leaving one of Hanigan or Molina as the backup and dropping the other one. Would like to have a lefty and righty catcher.

[Pesan915]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sup guy,

Franchise with Marlins I would like to get either Bryant or Baez from Cubs what would I need to give in return not having to be Stanton, Fernandez maybe Yelich.

Thanks

[guayo10]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sup guy,

Franchise with Marlins I would like to get either Bryant or Baez from Cubs what would I need to give in return not having to be Stanton, Fernandez maybe Yelich.

Thanks

Mission Impossible. Realistically the Cubs aren't looking to move either. Fairness wise, one of Stanton or Fernandez would have to be included.

[guayo10]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Thanks for the suggestions. As far as Belt goes, what do you think I can fetch for him?

And now that the Marlins are in town tonight I might as well ask, what do you think it would cost to get Stanton?

From the Giants? Maybe Crick, Escobar, and Bum? Not sure if that is enough.

Realistically the Giants don't have the prospects to get Stanton, so adding Bum may not be realistic, but for fairness parting ways with their top two guys and Bum would make some sense. Maybe throwing Gary Brown back the other way as well. Getting another small piece from Miami.

[Pesan915]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Mission Impossible. Realistically the Cubs aren't looking to move either. Fairness wise, one of Stanton or Fernandez would have to be included.

Baez nor Bryant are worth Stanton or Fernandez value. How about Olt? Don't see him being there since Bryant will be taking over 3B role and Baez I'm guessing 2B.

[guayo10]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Baez nor Bryant are worth Stanton or Fernandez value. How about Olt? Don't see him being there since Bryant will be taking over 3B role and Baez I'm guessing 2B.

What do you mean? Of course not for a one for one but a package with Baez and Bryant would net you Stanton. Again not sure if you're going for realism or fairness.

Realism: No dice as the Cubs are huge on both. Not sure Theo would trade both to get Stanton. Also if the Marlins stay in the race they have no incentive to sell right now.

Fairness: Stanton would get you Baez, Bryant, Almora, Edwards, Alcantara/Villanueva (too much or too little?). Going off of the spreadsheet.

But back to answer your question, maybe Yelich, Marisnick, JT Realmuto for Baez? For Bryant see the package above ^^^

For Olt? Sheet says 2 low B's.

Again not sure if you're going for realism, if so won't happen. If you want to be fair Stanton could net you both, while Baez would be the only one you might be able to get without Stanton/Fernandez.

[BA2929]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Realistically, getting Stanton or Fernandez would take a pile of top tier talent.

The Royals would probably have to give up Ventura/Zimmer/Mondesi and possibly a few other guys to entice the Marlins to even listen to them.

That's 3 of the top 35 prospects in baseball and I doubt it'd be enough.


Face it guys. If you want to be realistic about getting Stanton or Fernandez, it's going to take a lot or be downright impossible to make it true to life. Without those two guys, the Marlins won't have any fans showing up.