MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[KnickNation17]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Cargo would take Wheeler/Syndergaard + Nimmo + Plawecki. Dunno about Tulo.

That's probably fine for Cargo but still a lot I can only imagine what a Stanton package would look like.

Would adding a proven starter like Niese to that deal get Tulo?

[AC]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

That's probably fine for Cargo but still a lot I can only imagine what a Stanton package would look like.

Would adding a proven starter like Niese to that deal get Tulo?

Probably not.

[KnickNation17]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Probably not.

Damn he may be out of my range then. Would they want a Montero or a Degrom?

[AC]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Damn he may be out of my range then. Would they want a Montero or a Degrom?

I feel like the Cards would still beat that package.

[PistoleFoley]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I feel like the Cards would still beat that package.

Just to speculate, what do you think a deal between Colorado and St. Louis would look like? I'm thinking at this point (in real life) the conversation probably starts with either Shelby or Martinez, and then I would think either Piscotty, Grichuk or maybe even Taveras, and probably at least another piece.

[AC]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Just to speculate, what do you think a deal between Colorado and St. Louis would look like? I'm thinking at this point (in real life) the conversation probably starts with either Shelby or Martinez, and then I would think either Piscotty, Grichuk or maybe even Taveras, and probably at least another piece.

Take your pick, lol. Friggin Cards. Martinez + Wong + Adams was the price last year but now Martinez + Piscotty + Wong + Gonzalez/Cooney/Reyes + Ramsey may be closer to the asking price after Tulo boosted his stock so much.

[PistoleFoley]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Take your pick, lol. Friggin Cards. Martinez + Wong + Adams was the price last year but now Martinez + Piscotty + Wong + Gonzalez/Cooney/Reyes + Ramsey may be closer to the asking price after Tulo boosted his stock so much.

Yeah, the Cardinals have so much depth and not enough places for these players to go, especially in the outfield. I can't see John Mozeliak parting with quite that much, but like you said, Tulo's season probably pushes it close to that. Do you think Craig would hold any value at this point to the Rockies in a trade?

[AC]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Yeah, the Cardinals have so much depth and not enough places for these players to go, especially in the outfield. I can't see John Mozeliak parting with quite that much, but like you said, Tulo's season probably pushes it close to that. Do you think Craig would hold any value at this point to the Rockies in a trade?

Probably not imo.

[Deuce2223]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

That's probably fine for Cargo but still a lot I can only imagine what a Stanton package would look like.

Would adding a proven starter like Niese to that deal get Tulo?

Just based off of spreadsheet value you are looking at a (1) High A (2) Mid A, (1) Low A, (2) High B's, (1) Mid B and (1) Low B.

So that's pretty much your best 8 prospects.

Wheeler,Synderguard,Montero,D. Smith,Nimmo,Cecchini, plus someone like Matz/Tapia and Rosario/Puello.

For Kemp, maybe Daniel Muphy and Plaweki, (Dodgers don't really have much depth at Catcher).

[AC]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Just based off of spreadsheet value you are looking at a (1) High A (2) Mid A, (1) Low A, (2) High B's, (1) Mid B and (1) Low B.

So that's pretty much your best 8 prospects.

Wheeler,Synderguard,Montero,D. Smith,Nimmo,Cecchini, plus someone like Matz/Tapia and Rosario/Puello.

For Kemp, maybe Daniel Muphy and Plaweki, (Dodgers don't really have much depth at Catcher).

Smith can't be traded and kind of sucks. Cecch sucks too. Same with Puello.

Wheeler + Synder + Montero + Nimmo + Matz + Plawecki should definitely raise some eyebrows but I doubt OP would even want to do that.

The Dodgers don't need even more MIF depth (Gordon, Guerrero, Hanley, Arrubenera, etc). Plawecki + Matz works just fine.

[KnickNation17]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Just based off of spreadsheet value you are looking at a (1) High A (2) Mid A, (1) Low A, (2) High B's, (1) Mid B and (1) Low B.

So that's pretty much your best 8 prospects.

Wheeler,Synderguard,Montero,D. Smith,Nimmo,Cecchini, plus someone like Matz/Tapia and Rosario/Puello.

For Kemp, maybe Daniel Muphy and Plaweki, (Dodgers don't really have much depth at Catcher).

8 best prospects for who? Stanton? I can't see anyone current player would demand 8 prospects. That's a lot.

& I like Kemp trade but I would want Tulo over Kemp and I assume Plaweki would have to be in a Tulo trade

[AC]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

8 best prospects for who? Stanton? I can't see anyone current player would demand 8 prospects. That's a lot.

& I like Kemp trade but I would want Tulo over Kemp and I assume Plaweki would have to be in a Tulo trade

I think he meant for Tulo + Cargo.

[KnickNation17]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Smith can't be traded and kind of sucks. Cecch sucks too. Same with Puello.

Wheeler + Synder + Montero + Nimmo + Matz + Plawecki should definitely raise some eyebrows but I doubt OP would even want to do that.

The Dodgers don't need even more MIF depth (Gordon, Guerrero, Hanley, Arrubenera, etc). Plawecki + Matz works just fine.

When I was I asking about adding Niese to the Tulo trade I was saying would that get me Tulo in the game. I know in real life the cardinals could send out a better offer than the Mets

So the package would be Synder+ Nimmo +Plawecki + Niese/Degrom/Montero
For Tulo

[KnickNation17]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think he meant for Tulo + Cargo.

Oh ok gotcha. Yeah even for those 2 I wouldn't want to give up that. TBH id rather stick with Tulo

[DJeterFan2]

Re: MLB 14 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Trade Proposal for the first place Rangers in my franchise.

Rangers get:

CP Jonathan Papelbon: B Potential, 84 Overall

Phillies Get:

1B/OF Mitch Moreland: B Potential, 78 Overall
RF Nomar Mazara: B Potential, 65 Overall

The Phillies are way out of it in the NL east with a 26-47 record and 17 games behind the Braves. They are in full rebuilding mode. Meanwhile the Rangers have Fielder at first and Andre Ethier in right. So there's no spot for Moreland. And K-rod has been miserable out of the closer spot. By posting a 4.50 ERA, 7 Blown Saves, and an 0-2 record.