MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

[brandonholmes]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Since the Nationals bullpen is in shambles, would this be a viable deal?

doolittle & montas
for
joe ross

Don't know why WSH would deal off their major league roster when they have plenty of prospects they could swing a trade with. Robles/Soto/Fedde could headline a deal for an elite reliever with control.

I could see the Nats taking a chance on Doolittle first, but you're looking at a lottery ticket.

[BZito75]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Thank you for the response dude


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[TheLad510]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Kind of package you guys think the A's can get from the Brewers for Sonny Gray?

[rjackson]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Kind of package you guys think the A's can get from the Brewers for Sonny Gray?

I take it you are the A's, then? Midseason? How is Gray doing for you?


I think that IRL the A's will want Corey Ray (or possibly Brinson), Hader, and a lottery ticket. I'm not sure the Brewers agree to that but I don't know them or what they are planning to do right now. I'm firm on that demand if I am the A's and I think that they can get better offers from other teams.

[TheLad510]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

I'm at the trade deadline but 4gb a Wild Card spot so I might not trade him I just wanted to see what I can get from the Brewers since they're interested in real life.

[epikOH]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

At the All Star break in my 30 team control. These are the trades that I've completed so far and want to make sure they're fair and realistic. Stats can be included later on cause I don't have them on hand.
Reds get:
SP Nick Neidert
SP Rob Whalen
CF Brayan Hernandez
Mariners get:
C Decin Mesoraco (off the top he's like .278/~.320/~.400s/17 HR

Mariners are down to 2 catchers in their entire roster due to injury.

White Sox get:
SP Marcus Molina
SP Anthony Kay

Mets get:
3B Todd Frazier (~.260s/~.300s/~.400/18 HR)

Mets are tied with 2 other teams for NLWC, Wright is down for what looks to be the season.

White Sox get:
SP Joshua Sborz

Dodgers get:
C Geovany Soto

Dodgers are at like ~60 wins and Yasmani has no HRs, 12 RBIs, hitting under .200. Soto is hitting +.260 with 12 HRs.

White Sox get:
2B Ian Happ
1B Jeimer Candelario
SP Oscar De La Cruz
CF DJ Wilson

Cubs get:
SP Jose Quintana
3B Gerson Montilla

Looking to get about 40 trades this July.

Any word on these?

[disk]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Any word on these?

They look ok but the Quintana return is a little light. Replace Happ with Jimenez and you are pretty close in my opinion. White Sox probably don't deal with the Cubs in real life either haha.

[rjackson]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Mesoraco is tough because his value fluctuates a lot but averaging the last 4 years of WAR, he's actually negative value in 2018 IRL. If he's playing and doing well I'd say go for it.


Todd Frazier doing that well feels like he should get more but I think Molina is a B in the game, right? With that kind of a season, I'd shoot for Andres Gimenez IRL.


Soto performing like that has put up about 1.5WAR. That actually gets him Mitch White or DJ Peters.


That last trade has been stamped and approved by this thread so go for it if you want...but I don't think that the Cubs are giving up Happ especially midseason and I don't think CWS agree to it either. Keep in mind that I also think that trade is not that great to begin with because I question the realism...I think that StL, NYY, and ATL are better trade partners for Q (and Gray). The Pale Hose will want more hitters than pitchers - they are looking good on pitching at this rate and still believe that Fulmer is a starter for some reason or at least seasoning him that way for more experience.

That's my 2 cents.

[BigOscar]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

I think I might have asked this a while ago but don't remember the reply, if it got one, but what do you reckon it takes to get Byung Ho Park to the Rays. He's in the minors and paid some money, not a lot, but I really need a power righty handed bat as Rickie Weeks is an embarrassment to DHing.

I presume very little, but what are we talking? Mid C prospect? More/less?

[epikOH]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

They look ok but the Quintana return is a little light. Replace Happ with Jimenez and you are pretty close in my opinion. White Sox probably don't deal with the Cubs in real life either haha.

I'll probably roll this one back then.

Mesoraco is tough because his value fluctuates a lot but averaging the last 4 years of WAR, he's actually negative value in 2018 IRL. If he's playing and doing well I'd say go for it.


Todd Frazier doing that well feels like he should get more but I think Molina is a B in the game, right? With that kind of a season, I'd shoot for Andres Gimenez IRL.


Soto performing like that has put up about 1.5WAR. That actually gets him Mitch White or DJ Peters.


That last trade has been stamped and approved by this thread so go for it if you want...but I don't think that the Cubs are giving up Happ especially midseason and I don't think CWS agree to it either. Keep in mind that I also think that trade is not that great to begin with because I question the realism...I think that StL, NYY, and ATL are better trade partners for Q (and Gray). The Pale Hose will want more hitters than pitchers - they are looking good on pitching at this rate and still believe that Fulmer is a starter for some reason or at least seasoning him that way for more experience.

That's my 2 cents.

ATL in my game have the Phillies irl record so that's a no go. Mitch White will likely replace Sborz. Yes Molina is a B so add Gimenez or replace? I'll look towards StL and other contenders when I get the chance

[Worldserieswinner28]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

What would it take to get Julio Teheran to the yankees. he is pitching like he is in real life. Would like a few peoples opinions

[rjackson]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

I'll probably roll this one back then.



ATL in my game have the Phillies irl record so that's a no go. Mitch White will likely replace Sborz. Yes Molina is a B so add Gimenez or replace? I'll look towards StL and other contenders when I get the chance

with Molina being a B, I think it is fine. If Gimenez is a B, I think it gives more realism to go with him. Still add Kay.

[rjackson]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

What would it take to get Julio Teheran to the yankees. he is pitching like he is in real life. Would like a few peoples opinions

Coppy wouldn't do it without getting a good prospect close to the majors. Probably Mateo?

[CKW11]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Coppy wouldn't do it without getting a good prospect close to the majors. Probably Mateo?

No real need for Mateo with Swanson/Albies holding down the MI for a while.

I'm not sure the Yanks and Braves match up too well here. Coppy would ask for Frazier and would be rightfully denied. Rutherford is too far from the majors to be the headliner and Kapriellian just had TJ.

I read the other day the Braves would have been willing to move him if they would have been able to work a deal for Q/Archer/Gray in the offseason. So the Braves would need to acquire a top of the line starter before they move him.

Plus if Julio is pitching how he is IRL then there's no need to sell low on him.

[Worldserieswinner28]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Coppy wouldn't do it without getting a good prospect close to the majors. Probably Mateo?

okay I just read an article saying the yankees could go after him since he has never really developed to his true potential and could get him for cheap right now but they did not name specific prospects on what cheap meant