MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheWarmWind
    MVP
    • Apr 2015
    • 2620

    #1786
    Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

    Blue Jays 2022 Draft Report

    The draft has come and gone, and it was an interesting one with several future superstars and exciting prospects joining many teams, much unlike last year.

    Hank Dietz, a big lefty starting pitcher, was the number 1 draft overall, going to the Colorado Rockies, who are easily the current worst in baseball by a long shot.

    3B Chad Darling went to the Marlins, adding to their drive to trade Frank Aguila.

    A righty starter with an interesting pitchset went to the Royals, in the form of Rickey Hackman.

    Switch-hitting SS David Yu rounded out the top 4, going to the Mariners. The Japanese import's career will be watched with great interest throughout the league.

    The Orioles made out with three quality pitchers, adding to their already great pitching depth and further committing to their defense-first strategy, and the Athletics added two interesting pieces, including a big bat that should be able to help them out right away, which only adds to the fear of the team they may be next year.

    And then we get to the Jays.

    "We just picked what we could, when we could." Said GM TheWarmWind. "We never really had an opportunity at any of the options that we scouted that we felt would shore up our weaknesses."

    "That's not to say we did poorly." He added. "Daniel Dias is a fantastic steal with our 1rst round (30th overall) pick. He's an excellent left-handed bullpen option that is ready to play MLB today, while also having a ton of upside. We just don't need more bullpen pieces at the moment, nor in the near future. The rest of our most interesting pickups are all relievers as well. It's... not ideal."

    Looking Forward

    The Blue Jays have a few things to think about, both in the short term and in the long.

    In the short term, it's obvious that the Jays juggernaut is headed to another post season. As the season winds up towards the All-Star break, the Jays need to think about what they can do to shore up their current weaknesses.

    1b has been a problem this year. Montano has flip-flopped between the brilliance he showed last year and a guy who just can't hit the ball. Julio has been on a steady decline ever since he got called up, and his bat just has zero pop in it. Steve Roman and Alfredo Moreno have both already been sent down due to their inability to hang in the bigs. Adding Valenzuela to the 40 man and calling him up is an option, but the Jays are reluctant to roll the dice on him just yet. The corner seems cursed.

    The Jays have a plethora of pitching they're eager to trade. They'd likely be looking for a rental. Brendon Belt is the obvious choice, but the Giants are contenders this year, so it's doubtful they'll be eager. The Rays' Pedro Alvarado is and option, but he is signed through 2023.

    Rizzo is also on a contender, and comes with a hefty chunk of salary to swallow, even if it is only for half a year.

    That leave the Cubs' Brian Reyes, and the Mets' Rickey Brister, a righty and a lefty. Both are hitting well right now on teams likely not to reach the post-season. Neither is superstar material, but they certainly can bring stable production to the seemingly cursed position.

    In the long term, the Jays will be looking to sweep up some of that fresh talent injected in the 2022 draft. They've got quite a few quality pieces they'll want to dangle early and often this coming off season, regardless of post-season results.

    Ron Gilmore is the obvious fruit to hang out. As much as they want to keep the left-handed fireballer, it's hard to imagine him fitting in with the Blue Jays plans. Lozano and McMullen are locked in for another 5 years. Blanco is showing he's the real deal. Fernando Chavez and Alonso Baez are showing themselves to be better then Gilmore, while at the same time costing less over the next few years. Gilmore's got a proven rotation in front of him and a log-jam of quality pitching prospects behind him. Manual Chavez, Troy Reyes, Pablo Gomez, Jorge Hernandez, Juan Brito, Nicholas Burden... the list goes on. The Jays system is bursting with pitching prospects, and something's gotta give.

    Hernandez and Burden will likely also hit the block, and I'm sure the Jays would be at least willing to listen to trades involving either Fernando Chavez or Baez.

    There will likely be another piece put up for trade in the off-season. Bryce Harper. Roberto Perez is ready to take over as the starter in LF. Floyd Moyer is on the cusp of MLB ready (he just barely got cut a few weeks ago) and Chris Manual has just exploded into the MLB scene in his debut. With Bloom and Mauzoul clearly key parts of the Blue Jays' core, having Harper on salary seems more and more superfluous.

    It's not that he's been bad. True, he had a bad April, but that's been true of every single April that he's been on the Jays bar one, and he's (as per usual) picking up consistency and power throughout May and hitting his stride now at the beginning of June. He's also a proven solid performer in the post-season. But having him off salary frees up a ton of flexibility to help deal with the younger Jays.

    Honestly, it's not likely to happen. I doubt the Jays will be satisfied with any of the offers that are tabled for him, but he'll be dangled regardless of the futility.

    Comment

    • countryboy
      Growing pains
      • Sep 2003
      • 52766

      #1787
      Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

      Cardinals are 3-2 through 5 Spring Training games

      The Cardinals are 3-2 thus far this Spring after beating the Astros 10-8 yesterday afternoon, in a game that featured 7 homeruns combined from the two teams.

      Obviously 5 games isn't enough time to make any concrete roster decisions because at-bats and innings on the mound are limited, but there are a few things that stand out early:

      Malcolm Nunez: The Cardinals have to find a way to keep this bat on the 26 man roster and are almost forced to find a way to get him in the lineup everyday. Nunez just hits. Thru 12 official at-bats the young 23 year old has 8 hits including 2 homeruns and 4 doubles. He also has 11 RBI's this Spring. Nunez is obviously stuck behind Nolan Gorman at 3rd base and Brendan McKay at 1st base, but he should be the first one off the bench to pinch hit and the first to replace either of those players when a day off is needed. This is a time where you truly wish the NL had a DH.

      Alvaro Seijas: The young 24 year old has pitched 3 1/3 innings this spring. Of the 10 outs he's recorded, he's obtained all of those out via the strikeout. He has walked 3 and has given up a gopher ball and two other hits, but his stuff has been outstanding this early. I don't know that he'll make the roster out of camp, but I don't foresee his stay in Memphis being long before he's recalled to spell either an injury or a struggling arm.

      Paul Yastremski: The 22 year old lefty was added to the 40 man this offseason after skyrocketing thru the minors. He won 17 games at Springfield in his first year and won 16 games with a sub 2 ERA at Memphis last year while leading the PCL in strikeouts with 187 on the year. Yastremski will be given strong consideration to make the club out of camp and his first start this Spring only enhances that consideration. Yastremski pitched 4 innings striking out 8 and allowing 0 hits. He did walk 2 and plunk one, but hey its Spring.

      Again, its early. But you can't help but be impressed by these three young prospects thru their early showings of the Spring.
      I can't shave with my eyes closed, meaning each day I have to look at myself in the mirror and respect who I see.

      I miss the old days of Operation Sports :(


      Louisville Cardinals/St.Louis Cardinals

      Comment

      • Tha_BlacKnight
        Rookie
        • Jul 2010
        • 240

        #1788
        Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

        Sorry if I am late to the party. I have been running a franchise since MLB The Show 16. I control my Ace in every scheduled start and I sim the days that he is not on the mound.

        I am now in the 2040 season. My question is this, is there a bug when scouting for the Amateur Draft? in the 2039 season on MLB The Show 20 I had one catcher to scout in the draft. This season it has gotten worse. There are only a couple outfielders total in the draft. That's between all three outfield positions. Not to mention one or two prospects at a couple of the other positions. During the 2039 season I just had to CPU do my scouting. Now I am at a point where I don't want to continue my franchise.

        Has this happened to anyone else? What do you suggest that I do? I don't want to start over. I have kept stats for every season of this franchise, I have a google docs section of yearly stats, career stats etc. It would be disheartening to have to start over. oddly I take a lot of pride in my record/stat keeping. Its something that keeps me sane.

        Is this common for MLB The Show once you get to a certain year?
        My greatest College Hoops 2K PG ever: Cannon Morrison

        6'8 220 Point Guard Ovr rating 62
        College: The Citadel 2009-12

        Career PPG 12.4, RPG 6.9, APG 11.2 (1521 asts)
        89 career dbl dbls, 21 career triple doubles

        4X All-Conf, 10-11 Conf POY, 08-09 Conf Frosh of the year, Frosh All Conf

        Comment

        • reyes the roof
          Hall Of Fame
          • Mar 2009
          • 11526

          #1789
          Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

          Is there any work around to get the cpu to add someone to the 40 man roster and call them up if you’re not doing 30 team control? The Nationals rotation is a train wreck, their 4th and 5th starters are rated 64 and 55 overall and they have several pitchers that are better but not on the 40 man. I’m thinking maybe manually injure one of them to see if it forced them to add someone to the 40 man and call them up. Any other ideas?

          Comment

          • Jayyoungjr
            Rookie
            • Jan 2018
            • 122

            #1790
            Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

            Jay’s Cubs Wrap Up: 2025 Season

            Spring Training Wrap Up
            With the off season over the Cubs were ready for Spring. The Cubs retained 7 starters in the field from a year ago and all of their rotation; but they were able to little more after committing over 420 million to Bryant and Tatis Jr in the off season. The moves made this year will have big ramifications as they will need Bryant to rebound from a subpar year and for Tatis to capitalize on all of his potential - some critics were leary of a club committing that much to two hitters taht hit under .260 last year.

            The big questions heading into spring training centered around how the youth on the bench would respond and in the bullpen. The big signings did not allow the Cubs to add any other proven players and Chicago will have to rely on up and comers to play key bench roles out of gate. There were a few familiar faces as the 40 man roster came together to start camp. Rafael Guerra and Richard Kell are back and looked to stick in the majors. Both players had break out starts in their first call up but fell back to earth and have not been able to produce at a consistent level. Guerra, Chris Morel and Kell are all under 24 and battled for the 2 infielder spots on the bench. All had decent springs but Guerra ended up getting the nod for his ability to play the outfield in a pinch as well as the corner infield spots. That left Kell & Morel for the final spot and the Cubs decided to go with Morel to start the year. Morel’s bat is still developing but got the nod for his sound defense. Kell will head down to Triple A Iowa but could be the first man up if injuries occur. Joining them on the bench will be new additions from the farm in first basemen Lew Cannon. Cannon was the 2023 1st round pick & came on last year as he led triple A in home runs after starting the first month of the minor league season in AA. Irving Martens and Kristian Robinson will round out the outfield bench spots. Marten has been the top prospects of the Cubs; after getting a cup of coffee last year the ‘21 1st round draft pick will start out platooning against left handers. Robinson was picked up a year ago when he didn’t break camp with the Rays a season ago. Robinson has solid tools but is still raw. The Cubs choose to roll with Robinson due to his stellar defense over Mariano Velaquez who will be optioned to Iowa.

            In the pen Andre Chacin, Kyle Ryan and Yovanny Cruz were locks to make the team as well as Emmanuel Class as the closer. Freddy Medonza, Chicago’s minor league pitcher of the year for the past 2 season impressed in the spring and will get a chance to start the year with Cubs. Duane Underwood Jr will get his first chance to start on the year on a major league roster, the 30 year old had great promise early in his career but has struggled to put it together. Underwood will get a chance to be a key middle inning guy but can also gut through multiple innings if need be. Chicago has liked to carry 6 starting pitchers due to Colas spending time in right field & this year and they will carry 7 to round out the bullpen. Michael Kopech and Adonis Medina were fighting for the last remaining spots on the 26 man roster but they both produced enough to get the nod rather than another reliever. The Cubs announced that they plan on using Oscar Colas more right field to start the year so both young pitchers may get ample starts in the season. If the club has one weak spot it might be the bullpen; while there is a lot of potential, outside of Clase and Ryan Chicago will have to rely on inexperienced arms to get through the latter half of games.

            Lineup (against Righties)
            2B Tatis Jr
            1B Rizzo
            3B Bryant
            C Contreras
            SS Baez
            RF Oscar Colas or Robinson
            LF Danny Santana
            Pitcher
            CF B. Davis

            Against Lefties
            2B Tatis Jr
            CF Davis
            3B Bryant
            LF Contreras
            SS Baez
            RF Martens
            1B Cannon
            C Amaya
            Pitcher

            Bench:
            C Amaya
            OF Robinson
            Ult R. Guerra
            Inf C. Morel

            Rotation
            DeGrom
            Marquez
            Hendricks
            Puk
            Colas OR Kopech OR Medina

            Middle relief - Underwood Jr
            Set up Chacin, Cruz, Ryan
            Closer Emmanuel Clase

            The Cubs will open up the 2025 campaign against the Brewers.

            Comment

            • millertime98
              Rookie
              • Apr 2016
              • 198

              #1791
              Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

              I am starting over....again! I have started approximately 458,421 franchises in my Show history and today I start 458,422. This one will be different because...I'm taking over two teams at the same time (insert Office Space joke here).

              This time I'm going west with the Giants and Mariners. The Giants need to rid themselves of bad, old players and Seattle needs a rebuild. Both teams are ranked in the 20's. The remaining free agents are not franchise cornerstones so I can add them as needed.

              It is hard to start a franchise in the winter. I started one in January but then all the trades and free agent signings made me start over. 2020 was a crazy weird year so I don't feel bad about starting it over.

              It is a 30 team control franchise so I will be controlling most of if not all trades so that I can have a relatively equal playing field. I got sick of computer trades being out of wack and teams like the Dodgers signing 3 free agent shortstops. I usually sign the cream of the crop free agents and let the chips fall with the rest. I also got tired of the same standings year after year: the Pirates in last and the Dodgers in first.

              I'm off to Spring Training...

              Comment

              • LowerWolf
                Hall Of Fame
                • Jun 2006
                • 12268

                #1792
                Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

                We're nearing the end of May in my Braves franchise, and we made our first roster move.

                Folty got off to a pretty strong start, but really struggled his last handful of starts. We were going to option him to AAA, but the Giants expressed interest. So we shipped him off to San Francisco for minor-league 2B Jalen Miller. We're pretty set at 2B with Albies, but the rest of the guys in our system have really struggled, so it's a pretty good move for us.

                Miller will start at AAA. We added King Felix to the 40-man and he'll take over the fifth spot in the rotation. If he falters, Sean Newcomb would be next in line.

                Comment

                • TheWarmWind
                  MVP
                  • Apr 2015
                  • 2620

                  #1793
                  Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

                  Question: is it bad that I was really tempted to get a Lozano jersey (my current ace in my 2014 carry over)?

                  I settled on a Bichette jersey instead.

                  Sent from my Pixel 3 using Operation Sports mobile app

                  Comment

                  • reyes the roof
                    Hall Of Fame
                    • Mar 2009
                    • 11526

                    #1794
                    Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

                    I just played what was probably the strangest game I’ve ever played. I’ve been struggling offensively ever since upping the hitting difficulty. My offense is pretty much home run or bust, I led a game off vs The Cubs with a Jeff McNeil HR on a ball he was out in front of and just kept it fair, it wasn’t a great piece of hitting. Then things got weird, I put up 13 more runs in the first inning, all via singles except two where they walked a run in. They threw a total of 86 pitches in the inning. I batted around twice and Jeff McNeil had three at bats in the first inning. After the 5th inning I emptied my bench so I had no pinch hitters and my relief pitcher hit a triple. Another pitcher got a hit in the 9th, I had three pitchers get hits and Joey Lucchesi got the rare 17 run lead save. I put up 23 runs and I don’t think I had more than 3-4 hard hit balls, it was all bloops and slow rollers up the middle.

                    Comment

                    • Caulfield
                      Hall Of Fame
                      • Apr 2011
                      • 10986

                      #1795
                      ? ? ? stamina vs. pitching clutch ? ? ?

                      looking for opinions & advice from the people I trust the most:

                      I have a pitching staff battle that I can't decide on how to declare a winner between 2 pitchers almost identically the same.
                      same age, same overall, same potential, same contract salary. I guess I could decide on a coin toss flip but I'd rather do it in a more logical & scientific approach. so I narrowed my focus down to stamina & pitching clutch. one pitcher has a very narrow edge in stamina and the other has a very narrow edge in clutch. what to do, what to do? I'm also willing to entertain other ways to decide. I'm all ears.

                      thanks guys
                      OSFM23 - Building Better Baseball - OSFM23

                      A Work in Progress

                      Comment

                      • Finn
                        Rookie
                        • Oct 2010
                        • 328

                        #1796
                        Re: ? ? ? stamina vs. pitching clutch ? ? ?

                        Originally posted by Caulfield
                        looking for opinions & advice from the people I trust the most:



                        I have a pitching staff battle that I can't decide on how to declare a winner between 2 pitchers almost identically the same.

                        same age, same overall, same potential, same contract salary. I guess I could decide on a coin toss flip but I'd rather do it in a more logical & scientific approach. so I narrowed my focus down to stamina & pitching clutch. one pitcher has a very narrow edge in stamina and the other has a very narrow edge in clutch. what to do, what to do? I'm also willing to entertain other ways to decide. I'm all ears.



                        thanks guys


                        Any morale issues you could use to help make the decision? One guy not like the coaching or location?

                        Comment

                        • countryboy
                          Growing pains
                          • Sep 2003
                          • 52766

                          #1797
                          Re: ? ? ? stamina vs. pitching clutch ? ? ?

                          Originally posted by Caulfield
                          looking for opinions & advice from the people I trust the most:

                          I have a pitching staff battle that I can't decide on how to declare a winner between 2 pitchers almost identically the same.
                          same age, same overall, same potential, same contract salary. I guess I could decide on a coin toss flip but I'd rather do it in a more logical & scientific approach. so I narrowed my focus down to stamina & pitching clutch. one pitcher has a very narrow edge in stamina and the other has a very narrow edge in clutch. what to do, what to do? I'm also willing to entertain other ways to decide. I'm all ears.

                          thanks guys
                          A few things:

                          * Same handedness?
                          * Option years?
                          * Stat comparison?
                          I can't shave with my eyes closed, meaning each day I have to look at myself in the mirror and respect who I see.

                          I miss the old days of Operation Sports :(


                          Louisville Cardinals/St.Louis Cardinals

                          Comment

                          • countryboy
                            Growing pains
                            • Sep 2003
                            • 52766

                            #1798
                            Re: MLB The Show 20 Franchise Discussion Thread

                            Cardinals set Opening Day roster


                            The Cardinals have set their Opening Day 26 man roster for the 2028 season as Spring Training has come to a close.

                            The roster:

                            Rotation:

                            Kyle Funkhouser
                            Jack Flaherty
                            Junior Fernandez
                            Austin Gomber
                            Carlos Martinez

                            * The Cardinals were going to have Paul Yastremski in the rotation but he suffered a broken hand on a line drive comebacker that has placed him in the 60 Day IL. Taking his place is veteran Carlos Martinez who had a solid spring in a bounce back year. It was expected that Martinez may get on the roster in the bullpen, over Trevor Rosenthal, but instead he will be the 5th starter to open the season. The Cardinals elected to send Liberatore, Hudson, and Leiter to the minors to open the season as all 3 struggled with consistency in camp

                            Bullpen:

                            Michael Wacha
                            Zack Burdi
                            Trevor Rosenthal
                            Raisel Iglesias
                            Jose Alvarado (LH)
                            Corey Littrell (LH)
                            Roberto Osuna
                            Jordan Hicks (closer)

                            * Ryan Helsley and Giovanny Gallegos were the only two that had a chance at making the roster, but with inconsistent springs and veterans in Iglesias and Rosenthal, the Cardinals elected to send both down to Memphis to start the season. Expect one or the other to return as soon as someone is injured or falters.

                            Staring Lineup:

                            CF - Harrison Bader
                            SS - Samuel Franco
                            1B - Brendan McKay
                            LF - Juan Fabregas
                            RF - J.J Bleday
                            C - Devon Snow
                            3B - Nolan Gorman
                            2B - Kolten Wong

                            * Devon Snow will get the starting job at catcher out of camp. He had a better showing than Andrew Knizner, but expect both to share the duties near equally.

                            Bench:

                            C - Andrew Knizner
                            IF - Paul DeJong
                            IF - Tommy Edman
                            OF - Eddie Ortiz
                            OF - John Torres

                            * Malcolm Nunez was expected to make the roster, but as the spring went on his production dropped. John Torres has been a organizational favorite for a while due to his strong arm and pop at the plate, so he will be the other outfielder along with Eddie Ortiz. Paul DeJong continues to make the club with consistent play and Tommy Edman is the replacement in waiting for when Kolten Wong retires.


                            So there is the 2028 Opening Day roster for the Cardinals as they look to return to the postseason.

                            Opening Day is March 26th as the Cardinals will welcome division rival Brewers to St.Louis for a 3 game series.
                            I can't shave with my eyes closed, meaning each day I have to look at myself in the mirror and respect who I see.

                            I miss the old days of Operation Sports :(


                            Louisville Cardinals/St.Louis Cardinals

                            Comment

                            • Caulfield
                              Hall Of Fame
                              • Apr 2011
                              • 10986

                              #1799
                              Re: ? ? ? stamina vs. pitching clutch ? ? ?

                              Originally posted by Finn
                              Any morale issues you could use to help make the decision? One guy not like the coaching or location?
                              nope, no morale issues, these two relievers are in Class-A and aren't on the 40-man roster so they haven't developed diva issues... yet lol

                              Originally posted by countryboy
                              A few things:

                              * Same handedness?
                              * Option years?
                              * Stat comparison?
                              they both have all their options & this is starting a new franchise and they're fake minor leaguers in Class-A with no stats yet but one will need moved to Double A because of previous roster moves

                              HOWEVER, one is a lefty and the other isn't in his right mind.
                              should I look to see how many other lefties are already in the Double A bullpen?

                              EDIT: I only have one other lefty pitcher in AA, plus the lefty does have a slim lead on the other pitcher when I add stamina points with clutch points. looks like this is an easier choice than I thought.
                              thanks cb & Finn, I think I have my answer
                              Last edited by Caulfield; 02-27-2021, 12:36 PM.
                              OSFM23 - Building Better Baseball - OSFM23

                              A Work in Progress

                              Comment

                              • reyes the roof
                                Hall Of Fame
                                • Mar 2009
                                • 11526

                                #1800
                                Re: ? ? ? stamina vs. pitching clutch ? ? ?

                                Originally posted by Caulfield
                                looking for opinions & advice from the people I trust the most:

                                I have a pitching staff battle that I can't decide on how to declare a winner between 2 pitchers almost identically the same.
                                same age, same overall, same potential, same contract salary. I guess I could decide on a coin toss flip but I'd rather do it in a more logical & scientific approach. so I narrowed my focus down to stamina & pitching clutch. one pitcher has a very narrow edge in stamina and the other has a very narrow edge in clutch. what to do, what to do? I'm also willing to entertain other ways to decide. I'm all ears.

                                thanks guys
                                Pitch selection is a big factor for me. I find that I can’t control sinkers at all so I’ll stay away from a sinker baller if everything else is equal. Especially if the sinker is their only fastball, I feel like it totally rules out pitching up in the zone for me

                                Comment

                                Working...