MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

[MiracleMet718]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Just because you are too lazy to discover this stuff doesn't mean it's inside information.

What information I posted isn't publicly available to someone with a brain?

Oh, so you are one of those. I’ve tried really hard to have actual conversation on here with you and I tried to give you benefit of the doubt, but it took until now to realize you are actually completely delusional.

Good luck on continuing your journey to crack the code of a video game and being the controller of what is and is not good video game etiquette. I have better things to do like being “lazy” and not having a brain.

[IndianSummer]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

I took the time to do a deep dive. Wasn't difficult.

You sound guilty LOL. If you edit players, rob the cpu in trades, etc that's cheating.

Oh I get it. You’re one of those.
It’s cheating if anyone makes a slider adjustment and it’s a deep dive on the farm in Missouri. Haha.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

When did they say the deadline for the survey is, end of April or end of May?

What have I posted that is flat out wrong?

Show me the posts, I’ll wait

Oh, this is easy, I'll field this one if I may.
Tess - ''Statement A.''
Country Boy - "I disagree with Statement A."

That's flat-out wrong!

[tessl]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

What have I posted that is flat out wrong?

Show me the posts, I’ll wait


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Pitcher stamina has nothing to do with when a manager pulls the starting pitcher.

Do I need to explain it again? I haven't figured out whether people are being obtuse or if it's a larger issue. I feel like I'm trying to teach math to Jethro Bodine.

[countryboy]

MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Pitcher stamina has nothing to do with when a manager pulls the starting pitcher.

Do I need to explain it again? I haven't figured out whether people are being obtuse or if it's a larger issue. I feel like I'm trying to teach math to Jethro Bodine.

Not once did I ever say that. Find the post and share it.

Again I’ll wait.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MiracleMet718]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Pitcher stamina has nothing to do with when a manager pulls the starting pitcher.

Do I need to explain it again? I haven't figured out whether people are being obtuse or if it's a larger issue. I feel like I'm trying to teach math to Jethro Bodine.

You do need to explain it again. We are all idiots here and need your incredible genius to teach since you are so all-knowing. Please teach us and share your knowledge!

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

You do need to explain it again. We are all idiots here and need your incredible genius to teach since you are so all-knowing. Please teach us and share your knowledge!

Piss on that. I'd rather be an idiot.

[Armor and Sword]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Jesus that was exhausting to deal with….finally.

Can we get this thread back on the topic of how SDS is looking to improve franchise mode and the order of operations to get us there?

Lol…..lord. Talk about utter nonsense. It took too long to finally silence the BS.

But at least it’s now done. Thank you.

Back to our regularly scheduled programming.

[CBoller1331]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Jesus that was exhausting to deal with….finally.

Can we get this thread back on the topic of how SDS is looking to improve franchise mode and the order of operations to get us there?

Lol…..lord. Talk about utter nonsense. It took too long to finally silence the BS.

But at least it’s now done. Thank you.

Back to our regularly scheduled programming.

Order #1 - expand rosters to include full (playable would be preferred) single A rosters (I think just 1 level is okay for me personally) - still with 15 extra players in Rookie ball/low-A. I'd also like each minor league level to carry ~30 players (still only 26 active) to allow for slightly more realistic # of injuries at each level without completely devastating your whole organization.

I really feel like this has to the first step for a deeper mode. I could see the developer team wanting to get 1 or 2 more logic things tuned up before that (trade logic or roster construction) - but it seems like adding in a new level would require updating that type of thing anyways

[Armor and Sword]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Order #1 - expand rosters to include full (playable would be preferred) single A rosters (I think just 1 level is okay for me personally) - still with 15 extra players in Rookie ball/low-A. I'd also like each minor league level to carry ~30 players (still only 26 active) to allow for slightly more realistic # of injuries at each level without completely devastating your whole organization.

I really feel like this has to the first step for a deeper mode. I could see the developer team wanting to get 1 or 2 more logic things tuned up before that (trade logic or roster construction) - but it seems like adding in a new level would require updating that type of thing anyways

I agree 100% and I do think the concensous here at OS is expand the rosters to full single A and 15 additional slots for rookie ball, and at the same time expand the amateur draft to 20 rounds and add IMO at least an additional 5 scouts for a total of 8 (preferably 10) so we
Can scout a much larger prospect pool.

Once that’s in place we can see a revamped trade deadline, wear and tear injury system, expanded trade slots, three team trades and cash options added.

And of course full customization of your franchise mode including but not limited to adding or subtracting amount of teams, realignment of divisions, playoff teams, retro rules, ability to add new rules (CBA options) expansion mode.

Things start to get a lot more interesting once the rosters, draft and logic is all worked out first.

[MiracleMet718]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Order #1 - expand rosters to include full (playable would be preferred) single A rosters (I think just 1 level is okay for me personally) - still with 15 extra players in Rookie ball/low-A. I'd also like each minor league level to carry ~30 players (still only 26 active) to allow for slightly more realistic # of injuries at each level without completely devastating your whole organization.

I really feel like this has to the first step for a deeper mode. I could see the developer team wanting to get 1 or 2 more logic things tuned up before that (trade logic or roster construction) - but it seems like adding in a new level would require updating that type of thing anyways

Im curious if this is next, only because this is the first year that I can remember that they showed the High-A logo for the Single A team in the roster screen. I doubt they’d give us both High and Low-A, but simply adding High-A with a handful of players being in the Low-A “team” would go a long way in helping with what you are talking about.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

I bet Spindler be like ''Oh no, more minor leaguers to create.'' But two full Single A levels would take the minor league development experience to dizzying heights.
I do feel bad for Ridin but I'm practically salivating thinking about 125 man rosters.

[CBoller1331]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Im curious if this is next, only because this is the first year that I can remember that they showed the High-A logo for the Single A team in the roster screen. I doubt they’d give us both High and Low-A, but simply adding High-A with a handful of players being in the Low-A “team” would go a long way in helping with what you are talking about.

Yeah I had a hunch it was coming in '24 because in 2023 it seemed like they were cycling through different minor league players each roster update. I thought maybe the roster team was gearing up to create enough guys to fill another level. Obviously it didn't happen, but maybe that was the case about creating players, but they felt like the logic wasn't up to snuff to handle that yet, or maybe I was just reading into a small detail too much.

But yeah the fact that Single-A team logos are in feels like they are setting up the "infrastructure" to expand to another minor league level

[Cod]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

Order #1 - expand rosters to include full (playable would be preferred) single A rosters (I think just 1 level is okay for me personally) - still with 15 extra players in Rookie ball/low-A. I'd also like each minor league level to carry ~30 players (still only 26 active) to allow for slightly more realistic # of injuries at each level without completely devastating your whole organization.

I really feel like this has to the first step for a deeper mode. I could see the developer team wanting to get 1 or 2 more logic things tuned up before that (trade logic or roster construction) - but it seems like adding in a new level would require updating that type of thing anyways

I like this idea. In my ideal world, the game would expand to single A (high-A and playable) and an international complex (non-playable). The international piece of amateur and FA signings is one of the major areas missing from franchise mode.

[countryboy]

Re: MLB The Show Survey....Serious Things Being Discussed

I think there are a few more things that need to be addressed before we see the expansion of rosters the biggest being a new progression/regression system. I think this needs to be put into place before you look into expanding out rosters and subsequently the draft/scouting.

I also think that trade metrics (although really good post patch 7 imo) and free agency/roster building logic need to be tuned prior to an expansion.

And I'd be curious if they look to add the international signing period before expanding out rosters. I don't know the complexities of such a task and if it is easier to do before roster expansion, after roster expansion, or if it doesn't matter. Personally I'd like to see this done first, so that they can iron out "issues" with it (CPU logic) before tasking the CPU with handling this with an expanded roster.

And finally I'd like to see them implement the in season contract extensions being utilized by CPU teams. This is a personal top priority as I dislike features that are only accessible to the player controlled teams that provide an "advantage".