2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Nah, it's OK. Humans need sleep. Go to bed if you're getting sleepy.

just throw the 2 trades out there lol

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

just throw the 2 trades out there lol

Justin Nicolino, Jacob Anderson, Dwight Smith, Jr. (Three mid B's)
FOR
Garza

Travis D’Arnaud, Sergio Santos, Anthony Gose (Two A's and a set up guy to replace Eric O, and his crappy potential)
FOR
Jason Heyward

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Justin Nicolino, Jacob Anderson, Dwight Smith, Jr. (Three mid B's)
FOR
Garza

Travis D’Arnaud, Sergio Santos, Anthony Gose (Two A's and a set up guy to replace Eric O, and his crappy potential)
FOR
Jason Heyward

even tho i dont view Garza as a true ace, i think he's worth an A so i'd go with an A+B for him....i'd probably take one of the B's in your first trade and throw him into the second instead of Santos

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

even tho i dont view Garza as a true ace, i think he's worth an A so i'd go with an A+B for him....i'd probably take one of the B's in your first trade and throw him into the second instead of Santos

Why does everyone think Garza's worth an A? He had an ERA over 4 in his division last year, one of the weakest in the league. And Santos is a better fit, because of O'Flaherty (SP?) having B OVR, but C POT. McCann has that, too, A OVR, but B POT. Stupid, but he IS getting D'Arnaud.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Why does everyone think Garza's worth an A? He had an ERA over 4 in his division last year, one of the weakest in the league. And Santos is a better fit, because of O'Flaherty (SP?) having B OVR, but C POT. McCann has that, too, A OVR, but B POT. Stupid, but he IS getting D'Arnaud.

i dont always agree with the OSFM rating so he's a B POT in my book.....plus i dont think ur supposed to care where D'Arnaud plays once u trade him although that did cross my mind....as far as Garza goes, he had a mid 3 ERA in almost 200 IP's averaging a K per inning...so u think he's worth 3 mid B's?

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

i dont always agree with the OSFM rating so he's a B POT in my book.....plus i dont think ur supposed to care where D'Arnaud plays once u trade him although that did cross my mind....as far as Garza goes, he had a mid 3 ERA in almost 200 IP's averaging a K per inning...so u think he's worth 3 B's?

Actually, yes, for these B's. Especially Justin Nicolino. He's a top prospect with #2 potential IRL.

Side note; Do you sleep?

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Actually, yes, for these B's. Especially Justin Nicolino. He's a top prospect with #2 potential IRL.

Side note; Do you sleep?

i just think you're selling Garza just a bit short but we're not far off on opinions....and yes i do sleep

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

i just think you're selling Garza just a bit short but we're not far off on opinions....and yes i do sleep

That's surprising... it's 5 'o clock!

I think I am, but only because I'm seen him live, at his worst, and it isn't pretty. Back on the Rays I've seen him get mauled...

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

That's surprising... it's 5 'o clock!

I think I am, but only because I'm seen him live, at his worst, and it isn't pretty. Back on the Rays I've seen him get mauled...

im about to head to bed actually lol....yes i know what ur referrin to....would u be opposed to giving up just a low-A as opposed to 3 mid- B's?

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

im about to head to bed actually lol....yes i know what ur referrin to....would u be opposed to giving up just a low-A as opposed to 3 mid- B's?

Good, sleep is nice. I miss it.

As the Jays, my low-As are Rasmus and Arencibia. Colby's a beast for my everytime and I would only give him up for a superstar, and J.P.A. would leave me without an actual catcher.

No, Jeff Mathis doesn't count. Hahaha!

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Good, sleep is nice. I miss it.

As the Jays, my low-As are Rasmus and Arencibia. Colby's a beast for my everytime and I would only give him up for a superstar, and J.P.A. would leave me without an actual catcher.

No, Jeff Mathis doesn't count. Hahaha!

u should go get some sleep as well man....well at least try....and Rasmus was acquired for Jackson whose not on Garza's level if that means anything....im not expectin u to give up JP if ur trading D'Arnaud...cant afford to really trade Rasmus if ur giving up Gose and Marisinick....maybe 3 B's+ a useful player?

[hawks223]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

That's surprising... it's 5 'o clock!

I think I am, but only because I'm seen him live, at his worst, and it isn't pretty. Back on the Rays I've seen him get mauled...

Garza won well over 30 games for the Rays in 3 years between the ages of 24-26, never had a era over 4, and threw over 200 innings twice. Seriously? He's also one of the better strikeout pitchers in baseball.

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

u should go get some sleep as well man....well at least try....and Rasmus was acquired for Jackson whose not on Garza's level if that means anything....im not expectin u to give up JP if ur trading D'Arnaud...cant afford to really trade Rasmus if ur giving up Gose and Marisinick....maybe 3 B's+ a useful player?

OH! I forgot to mention! I'm taking on Soriano and Amezega! Should've mentioned. So that should even it out, taking on those two.

Rasmus was acquired while he was slumping, during a feud with La Russa, and had asked for a trade. So obviously, the price was down. However, I can just go OFF with Colby. I average 3-5 with him, I'd guess. Usually hit at LEAST a double, love his speed and glove. What a bomb he hit today, too. Into the second deck!

And yeah, after lying in bed from 10:30 to 2:30, I gave up lol.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

OH! I forgot to mention! I'm taking on Soriano and Amezega! Should've mentioned. So that should even it out, taking on those two.

Rasmus was acquired while he was slumping, during a feud with La Russa, and had asked for a trade. So obviously, the price is down. However, I can just go OFF with Colby. I average 3-5 with him, I'd guess. Usually hit at LEAST a double, love his speed and glove. What a bomb he hit today, too. Into the second deck!

And yeah, after lying in bed from 10:30 to 2:30, I gave up lol.

Amezaga is irrelevant in any trade and idk if Soriano has his real-life contract in the game...if not, u might wanna throw in a Cecil or somebody useful since u don't wanna give up an A.....but yeah taking back Soriano's contract would definetly have some effect....i like Colby a lot as well...was thinkin of tradin for him in my franchise lol

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Amezaga is irrelevant in any trade and idk if Soriano has his real-life contract in the game...if not, u might wanna throw in a Cecil or somebody useful since u don't wanna give up an A.....but yeah taking back Soriano's contract would definetly have some effect....i like Colby a lot as well...was thinkin of tradin for him in my franchise lol

You wanna head to the Arb thread? I wouldn't make the trade in my chise, but I'll make a deal anyways. If you have a lot righties in your division and you like hitting with lefties, and since I know you play every game, you could probably hit 35+ HRs with around .290.

Soriano does have his contract, I'm using Scott's rosters. And I'd LOVE to throw in Cecil. I'll drive him to the airport! Calling him 'useful' is a stretch.