2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

LOL I edited the post but I guess it didn't save so yeah that was a pretty lopsided deal

Is Corey Hart for Kirkman, Moreland, and Grimm/Jackson to much value for Hart?

Grimm + Ramirez.

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I know Price to the Rangers has been heavily discussed but I can't seem to find an answer in the thread as too a deal that has Olt, Profar, Arfalo, and Perez going to the Rays. Would this be fair? or would the Rangers have to throw in something else?

[rpagz3]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I already did this trade.. and your opinion wouldn't make me change my transaction, but just wanted some thoughts on it.

Mets give: Flores & Montero

Rays give: Jeremy Hellickson

.. I'm the Mets.

[HozAndMoose]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I need some good hitting prospects. Im playing as the Astros. Anyone is available to be traded(OSFM).

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I already did this trade.. and your opinion wouldn't make me change my transaction, but just wanted some thoughts on it.

Mets give: Flores & Montero

Rays give: Jeremy Hellickson

.. I'm the Mets.

That's fine

I need some good hitting prospects. Im playing as the Astros. Anyone is available to be traded(OSFM).

Altuve available too?

[HozAndMoose]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

That's fine



Altuve available too?

yes he is.

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

yes he is.

Altuve to TOR for Anthony Gose and Jacob Anderson?

Altuve to LAD for Corey Seager and Joc Pederson?

Altuve to KC for Mondesi and Dwyer?

Altuve to the O's for Jon Schoop and Nick Delmonico?

[WaitTilNextYear]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I know Price to the Rangers has been heavily discussed but I can't seem to find an answer in the thread as too a deal that has Olt, Profar, Arfalo, and Perez going to the Rays. Would this be fair? or would the Rangers have to throw in something else?

I think there's something in the last 4-5 pages on a similar offer.

Consensus is that Profar + Olt + Alfaro + Grimm is about right.

I did this trade in my 'chise:

Price + McGee + Peralta for Profar + Gallo + Buckel + Alfaro + Grimm

I already did this trade.. and your opinion wouldn't make me change my transaction, but just wanted some thoughts on it.

Mets give: Flores & Montero

Rays give: Jeremy Hellickson

.. I'm the Mets.

If our opinion doesn't matter, why post it here? But it's not bad at all. Good job.

I need some good hitting prospects. Im playing as the Astros. Anyone is available to be traded(OSFM).

Bud Norris + Justin Maxwell + Jason Castro to TEX for Mike Olt + Rougned Odor

Lucas Harrell to CLE for Tyler Naquin + Giovanny Urshela

J.D. Martinez + Jason Castro to Mets for Wilmer Flores + Brandon Nimmo + Kevin Plawecki

Jose Veras to MIL for Khris Davis

Jose Altuve to STL for Kolten Wong + Matt Adams

Chris Carter + Wesley Wright to SFG for Gary Brown + Andrew Susac

Carlos Pena (if doing well) to OAK for Jefry Marte

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Bud Norris + Justin Maxwell + Jason Castro to TEX for Mike Olt + Rougned Odor

Lucas Harrell to CLE for Tyler Naquin + Giovanny Urshela

Da heck no, those are big rips.

[Coper3000]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Could anyone see some-sort of realistic trade involving Bud Norris + possibly DeShields Jr (or a young player) for Parra of the Diamondbacks? The Dbacks could use a rotation starter since they have two SPs on the 60 day DL (nearing the trade deadline).

Bud has a sub 4.00 ERA and Parra is hitting .280 or so, while Deshields is about .260 in AA. I know the Astros are in re-building mode, but I've been the Astros the past few years and I just cannot hit with DeShields - plus I plan on locking Altuve up at 2B, and Parra would immediately fill CF where DeShields could possibly be used (Springer in AAA has been atrocious).

I assume 'story wise' I would be selling the fans some story about how we have lots of potential in the minors, but we wanted something to show for it now without giving up the farm for an all-around player, haha. Would then lock Parra up a few years. Too much? Too little? Not realistic? Just wondering because I would enjoy locking someone like him or Matt Adams up while my prospects get ready (would also enjoy any comments on who would be fair for him). Long read, so thanks in advance, haha.

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I don't enjoy the idea of Norris on the D-Backs, but how about...

Martinez + Deshields

FOR

Kubel + Parra + Davidson

[Coper3000]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I don't enjoy the idea of Norris on the D-Backs, but how about...

Martinez + Deshields

FOR

Kubel + Parra + Davidson

Cahill and Miley are the ones out for an extended time, and McCarthy is on the 15 day DL. Still might be pushing it because of the depth they have accumulated.

I'm giving stats a little thought and Kubel is absolutely killing it this season in my franchise (something crazy like 2nd in HRs and 3rd in RBIs), so they probably wouldn't trade him. Davidson would be great depth, but Dominguez is actually playing really good, and his glove is amazing. I really want Parra, but maybe I should scrap the trade involving Parra and focus on Matt Adams. I could possibly get over my dislike of DeShields if I knew he would be a decent fit in CF in a couple of years.

However, looking over STL roster and minors I'm not even sure who they could use? My closer in Veras and set-up man Wright have both been lights out all season, but I'm not sure one of them (plus other?) would be fair? Thanks for the reply.

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Cahill and Miley are the ones out for an extended time, and McCarthy is on the 15 day DL. Still might be pushing it because of the depth they have accumulated.

Oh, then your Norris trade is completely fine.

However, looking over STL roster and minors I'm not even sure who they could use? My closer in Veras and set-up man Wright have both been lights out all season, but I'm not sure one of them (plus other?) would be fair? Thanks for the reply.

Veras really isn't that much of an upgrade.

[DoTheLongo]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

It looks like waittilnextyear still has a huge problem with Olt.

[WaitTilNextYear]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

It looks like waittilnextyear still has a huge problem with Olt.

Really necessary for a comment like that? I'm pretty sure that debate is over and I also think people would rather not restart that in here since it distracts from analyzing trade offers.

But if you must know, I actually have Olt in my franchise as the Astros and love having him. I just wouldn't trade the world to get him.