2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[Pete_Dogg_18]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sup fellas,

I'm at the end of May in my Boston franchise and I was wondering what would it take to get either Tulo or CarGo from the Rockies? Thanks in advance.

Barnes + Webster/Owens + Brentz for CarGo

Bradley Jr + De La Rosa + Webster/Owens + maybe another high C for Tulo

Im not always great at this though, maybe someone could check these first...

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I don't feel like quoting all the feedback, but I do appreciate all the responses.

I am very high on Michael Wacha, Joe Kelly, and Kolten Wong. I understand the hesitation to include Rosenthal but mind you I am before the season when the Cards bullpen wasn't appearing to be a weakness.

In regards to Adams, I like the kid but I plan to move Rosario to first (quote of why a couple pages back) so a first baseman wouldn't be ideal although I certainly will take as much as I can get.

Also I really like Martinez, but not in Coors, he has incredible stuff but i worry about whether his small stature will lead to injury/homerun problems so I don't particularly want him in any deal.

I understand this is a difficult package to put together but I appreciate all the help.

Is Rosenthal just a pipe dream?

Note: I love Miller but I don't think the Cards would part with him along with Wacha, Kelly, and Wong. It seems silly but I am trying to get the most bang for my buck.

Also does anyone have any feedback for a potential CarGo trade, I really like the idea of the Red Sox, and my prime target is Jackie Bradley Jr. What else could I potentially get in this deal? I really need a long term catcher since the Bethancourt idea was taken so well by you guys haha

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Bradley Jr + De La Rosa + Webster/Owens + maybe another high C for Tulo

Not enough for Tulo IMO.

[cardinal511]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I like Rosenthal a lot more than the other two, the kid's just my kind of pitcher lol. I'm not much of a scout.

Rosenthal + Wong + Adams + Jenkins + that OF you mentioned earlier?

That'd work with me. I take it you like hard throwers?

[Pete_Dogg_18]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Not enough for Tulo IMO.

What could he add??? Maybe Barnes instead of De La Rosa and another B instead of the C???

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I like Rosenthal a lot more than the other two, the kid's just my kind of pitcher lol. I'm not much of a scout.

Rosenthal + Wong + Adams + Jenkins + that OF you mentioned earlier?

Is there anyone I could throw into this deal that would allow me to get Rosenthal, Wong, Rosenthal, and Kelly?

[cardinal511]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I don't feel like quoting all the feedback, but I do appreciate all the responses.

I am very high on Michael Wacha, Joe Kelly, and Kolten Wong. I understand the hesitation to include Rosenthal but mind you I am before the season when the Cards bullpen wasn't appearing to be a weakness.

In regards to Adams, I like the kid but I plan to move Rosario to first (quote of why a couple pages back) so a first baseman wouldn't be ideal although I certainly will take as much as I can get.

Also I really like Martinez, but not in Coors, he has incredible stuff but i worry about whether his small stature will lead to injury/homerun problems so I don't particularly want him in any deal.

I understand this is a difficult package to put together but I appreciate all the help.

Is Rosenthal just a pipe dream?

Note: I love Miller but I don't think the Cards would part with him along with Wacha, Kelly, and Wong. It seems silly but I am trying to get the most bang for my buck.

Also does anyone have any feedback for a potential CarGo trade, I really like the idea of the Red Sox, and my prime target is Jackie Bradley Jr. What else could I potentially get in this deal? I really need a long term catcher since the Bethancourt idea was taken so well by you guys haha

Wacha or Rosenthal not both I don't think. If you're higher on Wacha then take him and leave Rosenthal for some glimmer of hope in our bullpen.

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Wacha or Rosenthal not both I don't think. If you're higher on Wacha then take him and leave Rosenthal for some glimmer of hope in our bullpen.

I am very high on Wacha. I loke Rosey a lot but he is not an absolute necessity.

So Wacha, Kelly, Wong + who else because that doesn't seem like enough?

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Is there anyone I could throw into this deal that would allow me to get Rosenthal, Wong, Rosenthal, and Kelly?

Whoops, Meant Wacha not Rosenthal twice

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What could he add??? Maybe Barnes instead of De La Rosa and another B instead of the C???

Barnes + JBJ + Webster + Iglesias/Marrero

Is there anyone I could throw into this deal that would allow me to get Rosenthal, Wong, Wacha, and Kelly?

From COL's side? Throw in Brothers and Swanner or a good prospect.

[cardinal511]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I am very high on Wacha. I loke Rosey a lot but he is not an absolute necessity.

So Wacha, Kelly, Wong + who else because that doesn't seem like enough?

Still think Adams would be a great fit. If not him, Jenkins name has been tossed in, he's a B. If you think you want more value out of it you could always gamble a little on Martinez. In my view he's the most expendable out of Wacha, Rosey, and him. He's also the farthest away, which could be why. I read a report saying Wacha was close to ready now, and might be the first to the majors from last years class.

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Still think Adams would be a great fit. If not him, Jenkins name has been tossed in, he's a B. If you think you want more value out of it you could always gamble a little on Martinez. In my view he's the most expendable out of Wacha, Rosey, and him. He's also the farthest away, which could be why. I read a report saying Wacha was close to ready now, and might be the first to the majors from last years class.

Exactly why i like Wacha so much. how does this sound

Tulo and Betancourt for Rosey, Wacha, Wong, Kelly, Adams?

[mgcst5]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Barnes + JBJ + Webster + Iglesias/Marrero



From COL's side? Throw in Brothers and Swanner or a good prospect.

How about Cargo for Barnes, Webster, Ranaudo/Owens, JBJ?

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

How about Cargo for Barnes, Webster, Ranaudo/Owens, JBJ?

Ehh, too much.

Barnes+Webster+JBJ's probably the most you'd get from those guys. Maybe Barnes + Webster + Owens + Ranaudo.

[cardinal511]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Exactly why i like Wacha so much. how does this sound

Tulo and Betancourt for Rosey, Wacha, Wong, Kelly, Adams?

Betancourt the old reliever or someone else? I think we'd want Brothers instead of him and probably someone else an I don't know if you really have anyone else that would benefit us for Rosey. What about adding Anthony Garcia onto the previous trade? He's a B Outfielder with good power potential.