2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • CalmLikeABomb
    Rookie
    • Mar 2009
    • 134

    #91
    Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

    I have to be honest, and this is the FIRST time I have ever done this. I am picking up the version for both systems. I already have the XBOX one and going to get the ps4. I have a friend from work who just bought and XBOX ONE for this game. lol. If I had to choose one, I would go PS4 if it came down to it. I have friends on PSN and LIVE so hopefully they fix netcode.

    Comment

    • sbauer318
      MVP
      • Mar 2004
      • 2511

      #92
      Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

      I have both systems and just picked it up for the Xbox one. I want to try out the face scanning feature but don't want to spend money on a ps4 camera that I'll never use. Small Graphical differences don't bother me, Just as long as the gameplay is the same.
      PSN/XBL: sbauer318
      Steam: sbauer
      MLB: Baltimore Orioles
      NFL: Baltimore Ravens

      Comment

      • Nomah5
        Pro
        • Mar 2003
        • 845

        #93
        Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

        There's also something fun about the Xbox one and the friends tab, showing all the notifications a achievements and the clips. Well now I can justify keeping my ps4 even if I'm not going to game on it at this point. The NHL GameCenter app is far better on the PlayStation then it is on the Xbox.

        Comment

        • thedream2k13
          MVP
          • Jan 2013
          • 1507

          #94
          Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

          Biggest difference between the two versions:

          Online, player indicators are present on ps4 but NOT on xb1. What's 2k answer for this?
          #SIMNATION

          fighting for truth, justice and SIMULATION gameplay

          Comment

          • aylmer1981
            Rookie
            • Oct 2005
            • 221

            #95
            Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

            Hey everyone I just traded in my Xbox copy for a ps4 to see the difference and to try out the ffaces can difference. I will let y'all know later on tonight.

            Comment

            • USNAggie44
              Pro
              • Nov 2011
              • 698

              #96
              Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

              For the people that said the PS4 is brighter and more saturated, would changing the TV settings help make the One look better?
              Gig'em Aggies!

              Comment

              • AndyTheGiant
                Rookie
                • May 2009
                • 65

                #97
                Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                I'm really happy we have a group of educated, smart dudes on here.

                I have a proposal - how about we keep this thread going over the next couple of days so that we can continue to give insights on which is the best?

                It looks like xbox one is beginning to regain some momentum. I'm still on the fence myself.

                Are we absolutely sure PS4 has better graphics, or are we dealing with output settings that can be adjusted?

                And yes, the friend feed on Xbox One is superior. I feel like logging onto PS4 can be an empty experience sometimes in comparison.

                Comment

                • Nomah5
                  Pro
                  • Mar 2003
                  • 845

                  #98
                  Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                  Yes the ps4 is just so boring now that I'm used to the friends feed. I love watching clips.

                  Comment

                  • Nomah5
                    Pro
                    • Mar 2003
                    • 845

                    #99
                    Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                    Oh yea... i returned the ps4 version to the red box and kept the one version for another night to see if I just have to have it.

                    Comment

                    • aylmer1981
                      Rookie
                      • Oct 2005
                      • 221

                      #100
                      Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                      Breakdown after my experience of both ps4 and Xbox one

                      Graphics:
                      PS4 has more solid colors.
                      PS4 Colours are richer
                      Players have a more realistic gloss to them

                      Winner: PS4 edge by maybe 8%

                      Gameplay:
                      PS4 faster player movement/gameplay

                      Winner: Xbox One. PS4 seems 7-8% too fast.

                      Facescan:
                      Xbox's scan gave me 1600 ref points tops. Came out way off giving me too dark of a face.

                      PS4 seemed to stay longer on the white detection screen providing me with an avg of over 2000 points with no green square problems. Complexion is not the most accurate, but I think can be fixed with better lighting.

                      Winner: PS4

                      Controls:
                      Everyone has their own preference. I like Xbox ones controller personally. Never been a fan of playstation controllers.

                      Server:

                      Xbox one servers were up and running ps4 servers were down for me.

                      Winner: Xbox One (as of now - since Sony has acknowledged their server issues.

                      Conclusion:

                      Both systems are great. If you are into having a great face scan that resembles you and gets you excited to play my player then PS4 is the one to get. As mentioned on previous posts. If you like xbox ones features I would go with the xbox one. Seems balanced out depending on what you like more of is the one you should go with.

                      Since, I don't think there is any excuses for xbox one's unstable facescan and the slight superiority over graphics I prefer the PS4 version slightly. If I were to give a rating, and the Xbox One was a 9, I would give the PS4 version a 9.2/10.
                      Last edited by aylmer1981; 10-09-2014, 12:37 AM.

                      Comment

                      • CalmLikeABomb
                        Rookie
                        • Mar 2009
                        • 134

                        #101
                        Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                        Originally posted by aylmer1981
                        Breakdown after my experience of both ps4 and Xbox one

                        Graphics:
                        PS4 has more solid colors.
                        PS4 Colours are richer
                        Players have a more realistic gloss to them

                        Winner: PS4 edge by maybe 8%

                        Gameplay:
                        PS4 faster player movement/gameplay

                        Winner: Xbox One. PS4 seems 7-8% too fast.

                        Facescan:
                        Xbox's scan gave me 1600 ref points tops. Came out way off giving me too dark of a face.

                        PS4 seemed to stay longer on the white detection screen providing me with an avg of over 2000 points with no green square problems. Complexion is not the most accurate, but I think can be fixed with better lighting.

                        Winner: PS4

                        Controls:
                        Everyone has their own preference. I like Xbox ones controller personally. Never been a fan of playstation controllers.

                        Server:

                        Xbox one servers were up and running ps4 servers were down for me.

                        Winner: Xbox One (as of now - since Sony has acknowledged their server issues.

                        Conclusion:

                        Both systems are great. If you are into having a great face scan that resembles you and gets you excited to play my player then PS4 is the one to get. As mentioned on previous posts. If you like xbox ones features I would go with the xbox one. Seems balanced out depending on what you like more of is the one you should go with.

                        Since, I don't think there is any excuses for xbox one's unstable facescan and the slight superiority over graphics I prefer the PS4 version slightly. If I were to give a rating, and the Xbox One was a 9, I would give the PS4 version a 9.2/10.
                        I would say this is 100% spot on. I wish that I could use the X1 controller on the PS4 and there was a way to control game speed. It feels a bit fast on the PS4, X1 seems to be just right where you can really control the pacing of the game. It just "feels" better. I haven't tried it online yet, I still have both the redbox games. I am about to jump in and play them again.* Wait a second I just found game speed in XBOX one setting, about to test out on PS4.
                        Last edited by CalmLikeABomb; 10-09-2014, 01:10 AM. Reason: more info

                        Comment

                        • CalmLikeABomb
                          Rookie
                          • Mar 2009
                          • 134

                          #102
                          Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                          Okay I found the game speed slider and turned it down to 40 on PS4 from 50 and plays much better IMO. So for me at least, that issue is resolved as I agree the PS4 was more enjoyable at a slightly slower pace on the X1. I will say at this point, people should get the PS4 version without a doubt IF the servers hold up for a good online experience. The only think I am missing is the "xbox record that" lol. BTW is there a way to share game play on ps4 when you hit the share button other than facebook? I am really enjoying the game. I saw a review that this is just an "add on" to 2k14. I couldn't disagree more. This is a graphic upgrade, and so many small things done much better.

                          Comment

                          • AndyTheGiant
                            Rookie
                            • May 2009
                            • 65

                            #103
                            Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                            Originally posted by aylmer1981
                            Breakdown after my experience of both ps4 and Xbox one

                            Graphics:
                            PS4 has more solid colors.
                            PS4 Colours are richer
                            Players have a more realistic gloss to them

                            Winner: PS4 edge by maybe 8%

                            Gameplay:
                            PS4 faster player movement/gameplay

                            Winner: Xbox One. PS4 seems 7-8% too fast.

                            Facescan:
                            Xbox's scan gave me 1600 ref points tops. Came out way off giving me too dark of a face.

                            PS4 seemed to stay longer on the white detection screen providing me with an avg of over 2000 points with no green square problems. Complexion is not the most accurate, but I think can be fixed with better lighting.

                            Winner: PS4

                            Controls:
                            Everyone has their own preference. I like Xbox ones controller personally. Never been a fan of playstation controllers.

                            Server:

                            Xbox one servers were up and running ps4 servers were down for me.

                            Winner: Xbox One (as of now - since Sony has acknowledged their server issues.

                            Conclusion:

                            Both systems are great. If you are into having a great face scan that resembles you and gets you excited to play my player then PS4 is the one to get. As mentioned on previous posts. If you like xbox ones features I would go with the xbox one. Seems balanced out depending on what you like more of is the one you should go with.

                            Since, I don't think there is any excuses for xbox one's unstable facescan and the slight superiority over graphics I prefer the PS4 version slightly. If I were to give a rating, and the Xbox One was a 9, I would give the PS4 version a 9.2/10.
                            So day 2 (or 3?) of this boys. Let's keep it coming. And what a great writeup here. Now I am back on that fence.

                            Can we also talk about how annoying it is to charge the PS4 controllers? I didn't have that in a Con because that wasn't specific to 2k15, but with rumble in the game now, the juice on these things will go down quickly. Nothing more frustrating than wanting to hop in and play only to have to charge...

                            Comment

                            • Vni
                              Hall Of Fame
                              • Sep 2011
                              • 14833

                              #104
                              Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                              Originally posted by Art1bk
                              Both versions are 1080p 60fps


                              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                              2K15 clearly doesn't run at 60fps on my PS4.

                              Comment

                              • Nomah5
                                Pro
                                • Mar 2003
                                • 845

                                #105
                                Re: 2K15 on Xbox One vs. PS4 - Pros and Cons

                                The charging controllers drives me nuts. I'm back on the fence again thanks to that awesome post. I have NEVER cared about the slight graphical difference in a game so I'm still leaning towards xbox. I also have no desire to scan my face and how my player. I'm typically just a franchise guy.

                                Comment

                                Working...