The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Junaid14]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMachine?tradeId=7vlcuda

Boston get Millsap who is a young and interesting prospect. He would help boston post big 3. KG will move to center. Bell will slot into starting 2 guard.

Utah get Ray whos a killer from 3 and got a big expiring comtract. They get Bass who is a solid PF and a decent scorer. Also Stiesma as a throw in. This would mean Favors can start which would make him better and reach his full potential

At first i thought it was a bad trade but then i thought about it and i like it

[MrPolo7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Would it be reasonable to trade for Melo?

[Remixxxxxxx]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Wanting to aquire Deron Williams in my Blazers franchise, what do you guys think a fair trade is?

Oden, Matthews, Batum, 1st rounder

Williams, Shawne Williams

How does that look?

[ecaxcruise]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Hey guys , ive played MP for a long time.. and i just update to the new patch yesterday.. and i read this " Your team’s GM will now do a better job of acquiring one of your recommended players when he comes to you asking for potential trade targets. Be careful what you ask for! "

I wonder how do u ask for player trades in My player ?
thanks

[Suntan Superman]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMa...radeId=7vlcuda
Boston get Millsap who is a young and interesting prospect. He would help boston post big 3. KG will move to center. Bell will slot into starting 2 guard.

Utah get Ray whos a killer from 3 and got a big expiring comtract. They get Bass who is a solid PF and a decent scorer. Also Stiesma as a throw in. This would mean Favors can start which would make him better and reach his full potential

At first i thought it was a bad trade but then i thought about it and i like it

Yeah that's not a good trade for Utah at all, Millsap's contract isn't hindering them so Allen's contract expiring doesn't help them, Bass is an obvious downgrade, Stiemsma will the third C on the team behind Jefferson and Kanter, Allen moves in to block Burks playing time. All in all, the Jazz give up a pretty good player and get absolutely nothing in return, You'd have to thrown in Avery Bradley, or a pick or something with some actual value to the franchise to get this to work.

[Cruzader]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am Knicks using vtcrb's roster (with my own edits for J. Lin).

I suck with B-Diddy's shot (which I hear is common). I don't really plan on playing douglas or bibby or walker.

Suggestions for who to target with a package deal? (Davis, Douglas, Bibby, Walker or 1st rdr). I am looking for a pass-first PG to replace Davis and/or a defensive big. Controlling all 30 teams so I'm trying to keep it realistic. So Davis for Tyler Hansbrough would not fly.

Maybe I should just keep Douglas for defense but my plan was to not play the guys who aren't playing IRL.


edit: ok nm i made a trade and signed agent zero (rated 71 in this roster I think)

Current Roster

Lin/Arenas/Shumpert
Smith/Shumpert/Fields
Melo/Fields/Novak
Amare/Biyombo/Jeffries
Chandler/Jeffries/Jorts

Walker/Jordan (D-League)

[MrPolo7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Started a sixers assoc, what do you guys think about a trade involving Iggy and Melo?

[Captive.]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

You guys think this trade is fair?

Hawks Receive;
Marshon Brooks
Mehmet Okur
1st Rd Pick

Nets Receive;
Josh Smith
some 2nd round draft pick

[killstory]

You guys think this trade is fair?

Hawks Receive;
Marshon Brooks
Mehmet Okur
1st Rd Pick

Nets Receive;
Josh Smith
some 2nd round draft pick

I think its fair. Nets get Josh Smith who could mesh well with DWill.

[Suntan Superman]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I don't see why the Hawks would do it, the first round pick is nice, but Marshon Brooks would sit behind Joe Johnson, unless you're gonna start Johnson at the 3, which IRL would be a defensive nightmare. You get Okur who while serviceable is on a one year deal, that frees up cap space you don't really need since you have JJ's massive contract, Okur could start at the five and have Al go down to his more natural four which is nice, but it definitely doesn't improve the Hawks who are clearly in a more win-now mode than a systematic rebuild where guys like Brooks and a 1st would help.

[fluent2332]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

You guys think this trade is fair?

Hawks Receive;
Marshon Brooks
Mehmet Okur
1st Rd Pick

Nets Receive;
Josh Smith
some 2nd round draft pick

No way would the Nets give up that much for Josh Smith. They're giving up a very promising prospect in Brooks, a huge expiring contract which they can use, and probably a lottery pick, maybe even a top 5 pick. No way they would do that.

Marshon Brooks is probably untouchable at this point. Maybe Okur + 1st round pick for Josh Smith would be more realistic. But I just don't see the Nets trying to make a push for Josh Smith who's going to be old soon. He has a lot of mileage on those legs. So I doubt the Nets would even give up a 1st round pick for him. Especially if it's a lottery pick. So I say, don't do it.

[nowitsourtime]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Made this trade in my online association

Bobcats (me) get:
Marcin Gortat
Josh Childress
Hakim Warrick

Suns (them) get:
Anderson varejao (involved in earlier trade I had no part in)
Daniel Gibson (see above)
Boris Diaw
2nd round draft pick

Thoughts?

[Cossolotto32]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

This one is interesting, the Warriors finally decide to deal Monta...


Warriros Trade:
Monta Ellis

Grizzlies Trade:
OJ Mayo
Tony Allen
1st Round Pick (2012)

I think it works out in both teams favor. Warriors get a bigger man in the backcourt who can put up big numbers, also fits into their offense. Tony Allen helps out with the MUCH NEEDED defense end of the court and the draft pick will get them some decent talent. For the Grizz it gives them yet another scoring option but then has no backup for Monta. Still pretty good though.
Thoughts?

[Pitfighter87]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im the Jazz in my online league and am lookin to trade D.Harris.Bobcats offered me DJ Augustine straight up.Should i take it or wait it out for somethin else?

[ROABS]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im the Jazz in my online league and am lookin to trade D.Harris.Bobcats offered me DJ Augustine straight up.Should i take it or wait it out for somethin else?

depends on what your looking for ? i would wait a bit as harris is pretty decent in the game to use.