The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Pitfighter87]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Online Association


Cavs just offered me

K.Irving

Tristan Thompson

Antwan Jamison

for

Paul Millsap

Derrick Favors

Devin Harris

13 second round pick

Thoughts?

[MrPolo7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Online Association


Cavs just offered me

K.Irving

Tristan Thompson

Antwan Jamison

for

Paul Millsap

Derrick Favors

Devin Harris

13 second round pick

Thoughts?

I'd think of it this way....how much did the Jazz just give up for Favors?

[agreene7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Online Association


Cavs just offered me

K.Irving

Tristan Thompson

Antwan Jamison

for

Paul Millsap

Derrick Favors

Devin Harris

13 second round pick

Thoughts?

based on what you were looking for it seems like a great deal for you. You don't give up jefferson and you get a great pg. the bad part is that you lose millsap.

[kevinjcb]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thinking of starting an association with the Knicks, but I want to trade Melo as I'm not a fan of him and have just never got a hang of using him effectively in game.

I was thinking perhaps a 3-way trade that goes something like this:

NYK Receives:
Steph Curry
O.J. Mayo
Marreese Speights
Ekpe Udoh

GSW Receives:
Carmelo Anthony
Toney Douglas
Darrell Arthur
Josh Harrellson

MEM Receives:
Landry Fields
Andres Biedrins
Dorell Wright
GSW 1st Rd Pick

Might have to fiddle around a bit to get the salaries to match, but what are your guys' opinions on this deal?

[TDAWG89]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

My potential trade is Melo, Teague, 1st rd for Rondo and Danny Granger.. am I giving up too much?

My lineup in online assoc:
Teague
M.Brooks
Melo
Gasol
Kaman
---
Taj Gibson
Ish Smith
T.Allen
Redick
Budinger
Eddy Curry

[Pitfighter87]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'd think of it this way....how much did the Jazz just give up for Favors?

Yeah i feel ya.If i knew we where doin multiple seasons for sure then yeah im def keepin Favors because i know how much he progresses and so does Kanter.

But like agreene said its kinda what ive been lookin for and i still get to keep Big AL and get a nice PG and two Power Forwards.


I am so 50/50 right now its crazy.

[Pitfighter87]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

On a lighter note the Rockets offered

Jordan Hill
Chandler Parsons
Jonny Flynn

for

Enes Kanter
Gordon Hayward
Earl Watson

I kinda like it but wish i could some how get Courtney Lee in the deal.Any ideas on how to sweatin the pot or add/remove someone to get him? Im so desperate for perimeter offense.

[Pitfighter87]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Is this trade fair?

Boston Trades:

Rajon Rondo
Chris Wilcox


Sacramento Trades:

Marcus Thornton
Jimmer Fredette
12 1st round pick


I've seen people talking about a Rondo for Thornton and a 1st trade, and I'd like to open up more minutes for Juan Johnson and get a point in return. I could maybe throw in the celtics pick to make it more even. Thoughts?

Love it or Sac hate it for Boston.The reason Rondo is such a good fit for the Celtics is he knows he's surrounded by Paul Pierce,Ray Allen and KG which are scorers and he knows how to feed who and when.

You add Jimmer and Marcus Thorton,a guy thats never seen a shot he didnt like,and you have no one to distribute the ball just guys that are gonna take touches away from the the "Big Old Three".

Sac would love it.Move Tyreke to the two and have a guard that would know how to set up and offense that looks more lost then anyone in the NBA.

SUcks for Boston but Sacs sayin...

[Bolsen]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

How could I make it better for me (Boston)?

I would say try to add in Demarcus Cousins as he is a good young Center and the celtics could use a better, safer option at Center and it add some youth to the team. If they decline it then you could take Jimmer out of the trade as it takes away a shooter from you but you have Avery Bradley who I think is great in real life and in 2k and with a few training camps here and there he could develop a nice jumper.

[hawks223]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I would say try to add in Demarcus Cousins as he is a good young Center and the celtics could use a better, safer option at Center and it add some youth to the team. If they decline it then you could take Jimmer out of the trade as it takes away a shooter from you but you have Avery Bradley who I think is great in real life and in 2k and with a few training camps here and there he could develop a nice jumper.

No chance. That rapes the Kings, and gives the Celtics Sactowns leading scorer, and the top big man prospect in the nba thats already playing at a pretty elite level.

[jthomasx555]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I did an NBA fantasy draft and gave myself 1st overall pick in the fixed format just so I could sculpt my team to my playing style. After a trade to aquire Nate Robinson and a few free agent signings this is what my squad looks like this.

PG: Jeff Teague Nate Robinson J.J. Barea
SG: J.R. Smith Aaron Affallo DeAndre Leggins(I.R.)
SF: Kevin Durant James Johnson DeJaun Summers (D-League)
PF: Tyrus Thomas Maurice Speights Thiago Splitter Chris Wilcox
C: Joakim Noah Hasheem Thabeet (D-League)

I really wanna trade Joakim Noah for a good young center with some mid range game.
Any suggestions at who I should make a run at?

[Suntan Superman]

Thinking of starting an association with the Knicks, but I want to trade Melo as I'm not a fan of him and have just never got a hang of using him effectively in game.

I was thinking perhaps a 3-way trade that goes something like this:

NYK Receives:
Steph Curry
O.J. Mayo
Marreese Speights
Ekpe Udoh

GSW Receives:
Carmelo Anthony
Toney Douglas
Darrell Arthur
Josh Harrellson

MEM Receives:
Landry Fields
Andres Biedrins
Dorell Wright
GSW 1st Rd Pick

Might have to fiddle around a bit to get the salaries to match, but what are your guys' opinions on this deal?

That is one of the most lopsided deals I've ever seen smh

[xnickx5757]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

what do you guys think is a fair trade for kawhi leonard? i am playing as the cavs



the spurs were willing to accept:

Alonzo Gee
'13 2nd round pick


for him

does that seem fair?

[BobbyColtrane]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the Spurs:

SA receives: Corey Maggette and Tyrus Thomas

CHA receives: Richard Jefferson, Antonio McDyess (will retire with a cap hit of $2.6m), DeJuan Blair and 2012 1st rounder.

thoughts?

[packerfan28]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So in my NYK association on NBA 2k11 in my 2nd year I have pretty much the same lineup as the Knicks really do except I have Ron Artest who I traded for along with PG Chris Joseph from the Lakers in exchange for Baron Davis and Ronaldo Balkman. I then had to trade Tony Douglas to get J.R. Smith. I also cut bibby because he just sucks on defense. So right now my line up looks like this:

PG:Jeremy Lin
Iman Shumpert
Chris Joseph

SG: J.R. Smith
Landry Fields
Bill Walker
SF: Melo
Ron Artest

PF: Stat
Steve Novak
Jared Jeffries

C:
Tyson Chandler
Jared Jeffries

Now I've been on a role lately winning but all my games go over 100+ and that bothers me. The only reason I win games is because my offense is better then the teams defense I play. The games that I do lose are because my defense just sucks and my players are not shooting well. I was curious to see if I could make a trade that would improve my defense and so I was looking at Golden State who have trade rumors in real life and in the game they have players who are not happy and are requesting trades. So l send a trade offer to the Warriors and this is what it was. Let me know what you think and if it would help or make my team worse.

Knicks receive:
SG Monta Ellis
PF David Lee
C Yao Ming
SF Al Thorton

Warriors receive:
Carmelo Anthony
Amar'e Stoudemire
J.R. Smith

With that my lineup would look like this:

PG:Jeremy Lin
Iman Shumpert
Chris Joseph

SG: Monta Ellis
Iman Shumpert
Bill Walker

SF: Landry Fields
Ron Artest
Al Thorton

PF: David Lee
Steve Novak
Jared Jeffries

C:
Tyson Chandler
Yao Ming

So what do you think? Bad idea or definitly make it ago. Also note because its 2k11 Yao Ming is in the game but hes not happy and wants a trade so thats why I added him in and he would come off the bench as a sixth man.