The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Suntan Superman]

I think its fine. They lose the younger more talented players.

[lavy23]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Alright, I need input on this trade. I feel it is too powerful for the 76ers, what do you guys think?

Magic trade: Jameer Nelson, J.J. Redick, Quienton Richardson, '12 1st round pick
76ers trade: Louis Williams, Thaddeus Young

Thats a good trade for the magic, trading away 3 terrible players and a pick and getting back 2 young guys who are pretty solid

[2ks_finest]

Thats a good trade for the magic, trading away 3 terrible players and a pick and getting back 2 young guys who are pretty solid

Nelson isn't terrible, Reddick can shoot, Richardson is just a tad bit old. AND Orlando is going to give up a pick? Im not sure if all of that is worth just Williams and Young. But then again, Williams is about to win 6th man of the year if Harden doesn't.

[ross6655]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thank's for the feedback, I did it because I was simming a season just for fun. Both teams did pretty good, so I guess it helped them.

[brett the jet favre]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I want to get younger at SG, so Kevin Martin, and Jonny Flynn to the Kings, for Tyreke Evans?

[2ks_finest]

I want to get younger at SG, so Kevin Martin, and Jonny Flynn to the Kings, for Tyreke Evans?

That is a pretty good trade, however Kevin Martin is very talented and underrated in my opinion. As you said you do want to get younger so Tyreke Evans would be a perfect fit.

[brett the jet favre]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

That is a pretty good trade, however Kevin Martin is very talented and underrated in my opinion. As you said you do want to get younger so Tyreke Evans would be a perfect fit.

I definitely agree he is underrated, but i just want to get a young foundation, and alright, just wanted to make sure its a pretty even trade.

[2ks_finest]

I definitely agree he is underrated, but i just want to get a young foundation, and alright, just wanted to make sure its a pretty even trade.

Yeah I believe it is fair. The direction you are going in, Evans will fit in.

[brett the jet favre]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Yeah I believe it is fair. The direction you are going in, Evans will fit in.

Alright, thanks man.

[NoSkillz50]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Using SIM-WORLD association file. Warriors are 19-18 and Bucks are projected to finish in the bottom 8. Stephen Jackson is rated -8 and demanding a trade.

Warriors give up: Brandon Rush, Kwame Brown, '13 1st round

Bucks give up: Stephen Jackson, '12 1st round

Rush and Kwame have expring contracts.

[HolyStroke3]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Any opinions on this trade?

Warriors get: Dwight Howard
Magic get: Andrew Bynum, David Lee, Wizards '13 1st round pick (via GS), Warriors '13 1st round pick
Lakers get: Stephen Curry, Hedo Turkoglu

[fluent2332]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Using SIM-WORLD association file. Warriors are 19-18 and Bucks are projected to finish in the bottom 8. Stephen Jackson is rated -8 and demanding a trade.

Warriors give up: Brandon Rush, Kwame Brown, '13 1st round

Bucks give up: Stephen Jackson, '12 1st round

Rush and Kwame have expring contracts.

Nice move. Not sure I would involve draft picks though. If the Bucks are going to finish in the bottom 8, they'd be giving up a lottery pick for what will probably turn into a mid-first round pick if GS makes the playoffs next season (which they would have a solid chance of doing if they get Jackson). So I'd just leave the draft picks out. But I like the deal for both teams.

The Tyreke Evans for Kevin Martin deal is fair. I don't like the Magic/Sixers trade though. Sixers would never give up their 2 best bench players who could be starters for other teams, for JJ Redick or Jameer Nelson. The Magic have nothing on their roster that would get one of those guys, let alone both of them. It would just never happen.

[miz468]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

After my first year with the Wizards, I had the #1 and #4 overall picks in the NBA Draft. Cleveland offered me their '12 1st round pick and Christian Eyenga for my '13 1st round pick and Jan Vesely during the regular season. I accepted.

In the off-season, I did this trade:

Timberwolves receive:
#1 Overall Pick 2012
Andray Blatche
Javale McGee
Trevor Booker

Wizards receive:
Kevin Love
#9 Overall Pick 2012

I don't know if the T'Wolves would trade Love like that, but I think both teams benefit.

The T'Wolves' starting lineup is now:
PG- Ricky Rubio
SG- Wesley Johnson
SF- Derrick Williams
PF- Andray Blatche
C- Nikola Pekovic

They have Harrison Barnes (#1 pick), McGee, Booker, Randolph, etc. coming off the bench.

My lineup is now:
PG- John Wall
SG- Nick Young
SF- Michael Kidd-Gilchrist (#4 pick)
PF- Kevin Love
C- Andre Drummond (#9 pick)

I have Alonzo Gee (FA), Jordan Crawford, Tristan Thompson (Rashard Lewis trade), Shelvin Mack, Ronny Turiaf, Chris Singleton, and Christian Eyenga coming off the bench.

Thoughts?

[packerfan28]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So I decided to start a new 30 team association in NBA 2k11. Because its NBA 2k11 I choose to start with the most updated rosters from the 2010-2011 season instead of the current season rosters. I simmed the first season making sure that the correct teams made the playoffs, the correct teams made it to the conference finals, and that Dallas won the championship. I also made sure the five worst teams were correct as well. I'm currently going through the offseason process, using online sources to make the correct resigning and draft the correct players. I'm gonna be taking over the Orlando Magic and I was originally just going to trade Howard and start a complete rebuilding process in Orlando, but I am starting to rethink that idea and maybe try to find away to compete and convince Howard to stay. I thought of a trade Idea and wanted to know what everyone thought. So here it is:

Magic receive:
Monta Ellis(from Warriors)
Steve Nash (from Suns)

Warriors receive:
Marcin Gortat (Suns)
1st round pick (Magic)
Jason Richardson (Magic)

Suns receive:
Future 2nd round pick (Magic)
Jameer Nelson (Magic)
Hedo Turkoglu or Justin Harper (Magic)


Also financially I have no idea if this would work, this was just off my head.

[skives]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm playing as the Detroit Pistons. I'm thinking i need to get rid of ben gordon and charlie v. What should i get for them any idea's?