The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[LookItsOP]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

hey guys I'm running with the 76ers and trying to find a star that I can add to my team I'm willing to give up anyone and even a little extra in order to get a younger star to build around can you think of a trade that I could get a younger guy that can carry a team? I'd like to keep it somewhat realistic but as long as the trade makes sense i'm willing to do it....obviously not getting a Durant but maybe Westbrook or someone along those lines

Dunno how you're going to get Westbrook, he's one of those "untouchables", IMO.

As for my trade, it's working great so far. I played a few preseason games and I'm dominating. And the difference between me and the Heat is that after Howard and Deng eventually retire, I'll still have a superstar in Gordon, and Avery Bradley turns into a superstar as well at around 24-25.

[HoneyBadger48]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

By young star I'd like someone around 25 26 so I guess that would be more prime too I just don't want a guy whose right around 30 and can only give a couple years I'd like somebody to build a team around....I don't see the Cavs giving up Kyrie either....who would you guys suggest

[LookItsOP]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Well, you already have Evan Turner, but if you don't mind bringing him off the bench, I'd suggest Eric Gordon. NOH are desperate to trade him because he's already said IRL he wants to go elsewhere, iirc.

[NoSkillz50]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Any input on this trade: using Sim-World file

Monta Ellis for Al Jefferson + 1st round pick

Are the Warriors getting too much? Any other possible deals involving Monta?

[HoneyBadger48]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Idk what Jefferson is rated in that roster but I know in mine he's like the 3rd or 4th best center in the game if thats the case I think thats way too much with the 1st rounder...I can see it happening if its a year or 2 into your association and Kanter's progressed though

[Suntan Superman]

What about this:

Boston gets:

Loul Deng
Jimmy Butler
#26 pick

Chicago gets:

#1 pick
Paul Pierce

I'm the Celtics. Should I throw in another 1st for me, or is that good?

So they trade an all-star in his prime, and a young bench guy for the curiously acquired #1 pick and a declining player who doesn't improve their title chances?

If you're chicago are you really trading your second best player for essentially nothing?

[LookItsOP]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So they trade an all-star in his prime, and a young bench guy for the curiously acquired #1 pick and a declining player who doesn't improve their title chances?

If you're chicago are you really trading your second best player for essentially nothing?

Are you serious? While Deng IS better than Pierce, Pierce can still help a team win a title, and they got a very solid Harrison Barnes with the #1 pick.

[Suntan Superman]

Deng is better than Pierce right now. Deng is one of the best and most underrated defenders in the league, and has a good relationship in Chicago, why on earth would they trade them for guys who are not going to put them over the top. If they wont trade him for Howard, why would they trade him for Pierce and potential? Doesn't make any sense for Chicago.

[2ks_finest]

Any input on this trade: using Sim-World file

Monta Ellis for Al Jefferson + 1st round pick

Are the Warriors getting too much? Any other possible deals involving Monta?

I think that's a bad trade. And what's the "sim world file"

[NoSkillz50]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Idk what Jefferson is rated in that roster but I know in mine he's like the 3rd or 4th best center in the game if thats the case I think thats way too much with the 1st rounder...I can see it happening if its a year or 2 into your association and Kanter's progressed though

Monta is 84 and Jefferson is 78. Monta is 1 year older and I believe potentials are very close between the two players. I may wait until the first offseason to make the trade. I was hoping to somehow acquire a mid 1st round draft pick but I am willing to give up more than just Monta. I want to draft someone like Rivers or Beal to replace Monta.

[Suntan Superman]

The difference is positional value. 1/2s are a lot easier to find than 4/5s.

[joeSDL]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

In my MP

Suns:
Steve Nash
Pacers:
George Hill, 1st 2013

imo Suns got a little bit screwed, what you think?

[2ks_finest]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I just started an association with the Bulls. My goal is to get a good shooting SG and trade Bogans in this process. Any ideas?

I was thinking about trading Bogans and Korver to somewhere and getting a SG in return.

[holyshep]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

In my MP

Suns:
Steve Nash
Pacers:
George Hill, 1st 2013

imo Suns got a little bit screwed, what you think?

Hill is a young talent, but not a future franchise cornerstone or anything. And the Pacers' 1st round is no longer a lottery pick since they're a solid playoff team. I'd say the Pacers won that.

[ATLMIATEX]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

In my online Cavaliers association, I am at the trade deadline(Kyrie: 20.5pts 3.5rebs 5.6asts 48%FG 41%3PT 87%FT), I'm 1 game below .500 and I wanna upgrade at PF. I was looking at Josh Smith, and I noticed Pau Gasol was on the trade rumors, so this is what I offered.

Cavs trade:Ramon Sessions(LAL) 12' 1st Round Pick(ATL) 13' 1st Round Pick(LAL) Alonzo Gee(ATL)

Lakers trade:Pau Gasol(ATL) Matt Barnes(CLE)

Hawks trade:Josh Smith(CLE) Marvin Williams(LAL) 12' 2nd Round Pick(CLE)

Cavs Line-up
PG-K.Irving 38min
SG-Matt Barnes 32min
SF-Omri Casspi 39min
PF-Josh Smith 35min
C- Anderson Varejao 32min
6th-Daniel Gibson 32min

Lakers Line-up
PG-Ramon Sessions 36min
SG-Kobe Bryant 37min
SF-Marvin Williams 28min
PF-Metta World Peace 31min
C-Andrew Bynum 36min

Hawks Line-up
PG-Jeff Teague 34min
SG-Joe Johnson 34min
SF-Tracy McGrady 28min
PF-Pau gasol 37min
C-Al Horford 36min
6th-Alonzo Gee 28min