The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[GamingJones]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Blockbuster here:

Johan Petro and second round pick for Donte Green.

[Rocboyz101]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Hornets are in win now mode, IRL. If they weren't they most certainly would have traded CP3.

There team looks so bad though, was almost certain they were rebuilding. You're right though, guess they're in the same situation my Suns are in.

[OCC2USC]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Traded Joe Johnson & a 1st rounder to Portland for Brand Roy (Year 1 of association)

Great trade IMO.

Joe Johnson contract was going to kill me and he's also 5 years older than Brandon Roy who is a Star.

Roy fits my Hawks better anyways. Here's my starting 5

Brandon Roy
Jamal Crawford
Mo Evans
Josh Smith
Al Horford

[Lightning Flik]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Started up my association and decided on being the Raptors. Was looking for another big man to go along with Barn, and decided for the heck of it to take a crack at Minnesota's Kevin Love. The guy has 90+ rebounding and since I don't really know much about basketball (its not high on my list of favorite sports), I figured I could use a guy like him.

So I told Minnesota that's who I wanted. Waited for a response and figured that for sure they'd probably want my created self (point guard, 73). They did the opposite of that and asked for Jose Calderon and Jarrett Jack. I didn't even think twice about accepting the trade, since I wanted Calderon off my books and this worked out just beautifully.

Trade To Minnesota
PG - Jose Calderon
PG - Jarrett Jack

Trade to Toronto
PF - Kevin Love

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

What do you guys think of this trade the computer gm made in my My Player (Bucks)

Jazz Get:
ERSAN ILYASOVA
2011 First round pick

Bucks get:
Gordon Hayward (who was sent to D league after like 2 games)

In the game, this is probably a good trade because since Hayward was a 1st round pick, he'll probably develop pretty decent, but in real life, I'd kill myself if Milwaukee did this. Ilyasova is so underrated. He plays his heart out, shoots the ball well, and can play the 3 or 4 pretty well. AND we lose our 1st round pick? No thanks.

[xHostile818x]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

(Me) Sacramento Kings
Omri Casspi
Future 1st Round

(CPU) New Jersey Nets
Terrence Williams

[chezzie11]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the Thunder

Thunder get:
Andres Nocioni
Jason Kapono
Jodie Meeks
76'ers 1st Rounder 2011

76'ers get:
Thabo Sefolosha
Nick Collison
some scrub I can't remember
Thunder 1st 2011

I did this before the season started.

I wanted to shed some cap, and improve my 3 point shooting. I also improved my draft selection. After this trade, I'm now 5th in the NBA in 3pt shooting.

[willIam9387]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

How about this trade, look realistic to you guys?

I trade:

DeMar Derozan (high potential and athleticism, decent defender)
Ed Davis (high potential and good rebounding)
Marcus Banks (decent outside shot, above average defender)
Erick Dampier (good defense and rebounding)


I get (from Pistons):

Ben Gordon (bad contract, but I want another good scoring option and a good defender)
Ben Wallace (old but good defense)
Will Bynum (decent defender and outside shooter)
Jason Maxiel (good rebounder)

Or I can just do this if it sounds better:

I trade:

DeMar Derozan (high potential and athleticism, decent defender)
Ed Davis (high potential and good rebounding)
Marcus Banks (decent outside shot, above average defender)

I get (from Pistons):

Ben Gordon (bad contract, but I want another good scoring option and a good defender)
Ben Wallace (old but good defense)

What do ya guys think?

I don't see this as being a good trade for the raptors because they are def in rebuilding mode and both Derozan and Davis are pieces to build around for the future. Plus Gordon, the main player your getting in return isn't that great of a scorer to command both Davis and Derozan. Add his bad contract, which will hinder you from possibly signing the right free agents to surround derozan barnagni and Davis. I could trading a high potential prospect if your the Lakers or another playoff contending team that needs a second scorer, or a rebounder like Maxiell or Wallace. But as the raptors, I'd try to build around both Derozan and Davis who would be a nice complement to Bargnani because if you pair Gordon and Bargnani together, I don't think that tandem will be as potent as the Derozan, Davis, Bargnani trio would be down the road.

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I don't see this as being a good trade for the raptors because they are def in rebuilding mode and both Derozan and Davis are pieces to build around for the future. Plus Gordon, the main player your getting in return isn't that great of a scorer to command both Davis and Derozan. Add his bad contract, which will hinder you from possibly signing the right free agents to surround derozan barnagni and Davis. I could trading a high potential prospect if your the Lakers or another playoff contending team that needs a second scorer, or a rebounder like Maxiell or Wallace. But as the raptors, I'd try to build around both Derozan and Davis who would be a nice complement to Bargnani because if you pair Gordon and Bargnani together, I don't think that tandem will be as potent as the Derozan, Davis, Bargnani trio would be down the road.

Thanks buddy, all I was looking for. I didn't do it after all.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nuggets trade: Carmelo Anthony and Al Harrington
Pacers trade: Danny Granger, TJ Ford (expiring), and 2 1st round picks

[redsoxallday]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nuggets trade: Carmelo Anthony and Al Harrington
Pacers trade: Danny Granger, TJ Ford (expiring), and 2 1st round picks

...............

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

...............

What exactly does this mean?

In the game, Anthony is significantly better than Granger, and they get Al Harrington to play the PF position too (as compared to Hansbrough and McRoberts). I'm just trying to rebuild the Nuggets. I figure Granger can be my #2 if I get this team to be good again (until then, he's kinda forced to be the #1 the way he was in Indy), and meanwhile the Pacers are suddenly a very solid team with Collison at the point, Melo on the wing, Harrington stretching the floor, and Hibbert inside. And I couldn't get the Knicks or Nets to trade for him and even the Pacers it took awhile to work the trade out but I think it works.

Update on the trade: Melo was 4th in the NBA in scoring and led the Pacers to #4 seed in the Eastern Conference. Nuggets were tied for the 8th spot in the west with the Jazz but lost to the Jazz in the final game of the season to miss the playoffs.

[NDIrish98]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

just started an association w/ the Bulls a couple days ago, and even before i play my first game the Pacers offer me Granger and Hansborough for Boozer and a 1st rd pick. i sat on this one for a little while to think about it, being that the bulls are my fav, and pacers being a close second, i ended up rejecting it though because i was anxious to use Boozer for Chicago. yeah, i know, technically it isn't a trade, but thought it was an interesting, and very tempting offer, nonetheless.

[NDAlum]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Could this ever go down?

Knicks trade:

SF Danilo Gallinari (72)
C Ronny Turiaf (66)
'12 1st Round Pick

Grizzlies trade:

SG Xavier Henry (68)
C Hamed Haddadi (54)
C Hasheem Thabeet (58)

*~*~*~*~*~*~~*~*~*~*~*

I'm simming year 1 of the Knicks and my goal is to free up some cap space for signing Melo. I hate getting rid of Galo but Henry is a solid player in 2K. Man looking at it one more time I think they got the better deal! Well hopefully the pick is late in the 1st round. Basically Galo for Henry. If they get rid of Mayo they can move Gay to the 2 and have Galo start at the 3.

[krulmichael]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I need a spark at point guard from the perimeter, so I got counter-offered into this deal and I was thinking bout taking it. What do you guys think?

Pistons (Me) Receive

SG (although I'm gonna try him at PG) Alonzo Gee (68 ovr, B- POT)
2012 Spurs 1st Round Pick

Spurs Receive

SF Jonas Jerebko (66 ovr, C+ POT)
2011 Pistons 1st Round Pick