***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Snigitty James
    Banned
    • Mar 2007
    • 615

    #4996
    Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

    Originally posted by WTF
    Eh... Timmy won't be suspended for that. No altercation involved. Not even the same circumstances as late in the game w/ Amare and Diaw. (waits to be crucified by Suns fans)
    Dude, you don't make sense. Your saying Duncan wasn't involved but Stoudemire and Diaw were? Umm.... what?

    Being on the floor at one point in the game is the same as being on the court at the end of the game. Doesn't matter, it's the principle.
    Last edited by Snigitty James; 05-15-2007, 05:37 PM.

    Comment

    • Scottdau
      Banned
      • Feb 2003
      • 32580

      #4997
      Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

      Originally posted by TheMatrix31
      I think some people have their definition of flopping warped.

      Nash got blindsided into the freakin' scorers table. What do you want him to do, fall down in a controlled manner? I swear, man.

      As for the suspensions. Horry deserves to be suspended. He tossed Nash into the scorer's table, THEN went and elbowed Raja. That wasn't a hard foul, that was frustration that could have very well led to a total brawl. Going and elbowing Raja shows the intent. Horry deserves two games.

      As for Amare and Diaw, we know the rule but they were stopped by the assistants. Plus, if Amare and Diaw get suspended then Duncan and Bowen better be also. Either way, I doubt anything will come out of this in terms of those four, because if Baron didnt get suspended for his dirty *** hit on Fisher, then these guys shouldnt, no matter what the rule says.

      CJ, the altercation was when Francisco Elson dunked, fell hard over James Jones. Duncan ran onto the floor and Bowen came too but tried to hold Duncan back.

      If they came on the floor then they should be suspended. That is the rule. Even though I don't agree with that rule, but it is still a rule. If Ducan came out to the court then he should be suspended too.

      Comment

      • Brandon13
        All Star
        • Oct 2005
        • 8915

        #4998
        Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

        I don't have any idea how the league can really justify not suspending Duncan if they do suspend Amare and Diaw. The circumstances were different but it's really the same principle. Duncan was came onto the court because he thought there may be an altercation. Amare and Diaw came onto the court because there was an alteraction. It is different but it's really the same in my eyes.

        Comment

        • WTF
          MVP
          • Aug 2002
          • 20274

          #4999
          Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

          Originally posted by Brandon13
          I don't have any idea how the league can really justify not suspending Duncan if they do suspend Amare and Diaw. The circumstances were different but it's really the same principle. Duncan was came onto the court because he thought there may be an altercation. Amare and Diaw came onto the court because there was an alteraction. It is different but it's really the same in my eyes.
          It is different... There was no altercation in Duncan's case. If there was an altercation, as w/ Nash and Horry, then yeah, he should be suspended. Those two had to be separated... Whoever was involved in the other foul wasn't. No confrontation between the two players. Completely different situation.

          But whatever you all see I guess... It doesn't matter to me one way or another. That's just how I see it.
          Twitter - WTF_OS
          #DropMeAFollow

          Comment

          • TheMatrix31
            RF
            • Jul 2002
            • 52927

            #5000
            Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

            Originally posted by WTF
            It is different... There was no altercation in Duncan's case. If there was an altercation, as w/ Nash and Horry, then yeah, he should be suspended. Those two had to be separated... Whoever was involved in the other foul wasn't. No confrontation between the two players. Completely different situation.

            But whatever you all see I guess... It doesn't matter to me one way or another. That's just how I see it.
            There was a confrontation, you just didn't see it cuz they cut to Ginobili. There was pushing and shoving and while Elson was still on the ground, Duncan was at the three point line basically.

            Add to the fact that Duncan was on the floor DURING THE GAME (which is against the rules as is), rather than a foul situation where Amare was up. Fact is, no one besides Horry should be suspended, but if Amare or Diaw do, then Duncan sure as hell better.

            Here are some nice pics of Duncan.


            Comment

            • Brandon13
              All Star
              • Oct 2005
              • 8915

              #5001
              Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

              Originally posted by WTF
              It is different... There was no altercation in Duncan's case. If there was an altercation, as w/ Nash and Horry, then yeah, he should be suspended. Those two had to be separated... Whoever was involved in the other foul wasn't. No confrontation between the two players. Completely different situation.

              But whatever you all see I guess... It doesn't matter to me one way or another. That's just how I see it.
              I see what you're saying. You're probably right and Duncan won't be suspended.

              Comment

              • WTF
                MVP
                • Aug 2002
                • 20274

                #5002
                Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                Well, if there was indeed a confrontation, then yeah, I'll agree that he needs to be suspended as well. But what I seen from the video, then there was nothing. Just Ginobli's big schnoz.

                But yeah, if there was pushing and shoving, indeed they need to be suspended as well.
                Twitter - WTF_OS
                #DropMeAFollow

                Comment

                • WTF
                  MVP
                  • Aug 2002
                  • 20274

                  #5003
                  Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                  Originally posted by Brandon13
                  I see what you're saying. You're probably right and Duncan won't be suspended.
                  Well, Matrix says that there was some pushing and shoving involved, so that puts them in the same category. If it was nothing but what we seen in the video, then he doesn't get anything in my opinion... but if there was an altercation, and some sort of physicality between the two players, and he went to "assist", then he deserves the same punishment.
                  Twitter - WTF_OS
                  #DropMeAFollow

                  Comment

                  • gallandro
                    Pro
                    • Jul 2003
                    • 526

                    #5004
                    Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                    And Timmy gets away with running onto the court... unreal...

                    Amare and Diaw suspended. Horry out two games... and Timmy gets away with one! Thanks David Stern!
                    "Echo from the buttes, Give 'Em Hell Devils!"

                    Comment

                    • Snigitty James
                      Banned
                      • Mar 2007
                      • 615

                      #5005
                      Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                      Suspensions:

                      Horry 2 games

                      Stoudemire and Diaw 1 game


                      Complete and utter Bull****. **** you David Stern and Stu Jackson!
                      Last edited by Snigitty James; 05-15-2007, 05:55 PM.

                      Comment

                      • TheMatrix31
                        RF
                        • Jul 2002
                        • 52927

                        #5006
                        Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                        I'm literally sick to my stomach.

                        Screw Robert Horry. If his punk *** didn't do anything, none of this would have occured.

                        This is ridiculous.

                        Stern is a moron. I don't care what the rules say, everything should be circumstantial.

                        Comment

                        • Brandon13
                          All Star
                          • Oct 2005
                          • 8915

                          #5007
                          Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                          That sucks, but it's what I expected.

                          Comment

                          • gallandro
                            Pro
                            • Jul 2003
                            • 526

                            #5008
                            Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                            Well Stern enjoy one of your lowest rated NBA finals in history as the Spurs and the Pistons bump and grind it out. Stern is a moron, at times he makes Bud Selig look like a frickin genius.

                            Yancy
                            "Echo from the buttes, Give 'Em Hell Devils!"

                            Comment

                            • WTF
                              MVP
                              • Aug 2002
                              • 20274

                              #5009
                              Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                              Told you, lol.
                              Twitter - WTF_OS
                              #DropMeAFollow

                              Comment

                              • Air23
                                Banned
                                • Feb 2003
                                • 2502

                                #5010
                                Re: ***Official 2007 NBA Playoffs Discussion Thread***

                                Well, it's what most of us expected.

                                **** Stern and his crew.

                                Comment

                                Working...