Mike, I gotta say, I plugged your sliders in like always, and i'm getting great gameplay and stats. My biggest concern every year are tackle stats and how it should be relevant to positions like MLB and such. Well...
In my Bears Franchise, Trevathan, Jalen Smith, McPhee are absolute beasts! Linebackers are doing just that. Backing the line and running to get those tackles. Each game, i've had that trio rack up solo tackle stats like nobody's business. Jalen Smith had about 15 tackles in one game. I've been waiting years to see this in Madden. Thanks for posting these and please try not to make drastic changes. These are great especially if you play in Broadcast mode.
Mike, I gotta say, I plugged your sliders in like always, and i'm getting great gameplay and stats. My biggest concern every year are tackle stats and how it should be relevant to positions like MLB and such. Well...
In my Bears Franchise, Trevathan, Jalen Smith, McPhee are absolute beasts! Linebackers are doing just that. Backing the line and running to get those tackles. Each game, i've had that trio rack up solo tackle stats like nobody's business. Jalen Smith had about 15 tackles in one game. I've been waiting years to see this in Madden. Thanks for posting these and please try not to make drastic changes. These are great especially if you play in Broadcast mode.
I've been using various sliders on this forum for a while now, but I thought it was about time I started to pitch in. Here are the boxscores from my first two games on 17. I play Coach Mode almost exclusively (minus the occasional disruption on defence).
For the first game (as the Raiders against the Saints), please switch around the team stats:
Oakland Raiders at New Orleans Saints
Jan 1,
1ST
2ND
3RD
4TH
SCORE
Oakland Raiders (1-0)
0
17
10
3
30
New Orleans Saints (0-1)
3
3
7
0
13
Team Stats Comparison
OAK
NOR
Total Offense
511
261
Rushing Yards
244
78
Passing Yards
267
183
First Downs
28
17
Punt Return Yards
19
0
Kick Return Yards
80
107
Total Yards
610
368
Turnovers
3
4
3rd Down Converstion
12
5
4th Down Conversion
2
0
2-Point Conversion
0
0
Red Zone Touchdowns/Field Goals
2/2
1/0
Penalties
10
53
Posession Time
34:13
25:47
Oakland Raiders
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
D. Brees
28/41
211
0
3
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
M. Ingram
11
91
8.4
1
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
J. Hill
9
56
6.2
B. Hartline
6
48
8.0
M. Thomas
4
37
9.3
V. Brown
4
38
9.5
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
1
3
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
C. Barth
2/2
1/1
7
55
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
T. Morstead
3
168
56.0
1
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
W. Snead
3
80
26.7
0
C. Spiller
1
27
27.0
0
New Orleans Saints
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
D. Carr
29/39
275
2
3
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
L. Murray
42
213
5.1
1
T. Jones
1
28
28.0
0
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
M. Reece
7
64
9.1
0
A. Holmes
7
66
9.4
0
A. Cooper
5
52
10.7
0
M. Crabtree
4
43
10.8
2
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
4
3
0
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
S. Janikowski
3/3
3/3
12
44
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
M. King
0
0
0
0
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Jones
3
80
26.7
0
PUNT RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Jones
1
19
19.0
0
Atlanta Falcons at Oakland Raiders
Jan 1,
1ST
2ND
3RD
4TH
SCORE
Atlanta Falcons (0-2)
3
7
7
6
23
Oakland Raiders (2-0)
14
14
0
0
28
Team Stats Comparison
ATL
OAK
Total Offense
308
421
Rushing Yards
89
169
Passing Yards
219
252
First Downs
15
15
Punt Return Yards
19
29
Kick Return Yards
94
119
Total Yards
421
569
Turnovers
1
3
3rd Down Converstion
3-14
4-12
4th Down Conversion
0-1
0-2
2-Point Conversion
0-1
0-0
Red Zone Touchdowns/Field Goals
2/0
2/0
Penalties
2-10
0-0
Posession Time
36:05
23:55
Atlanta Falcons
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
M. Ryan
28/40
269
1
1
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
D. Freeman
24
86
3.5
1
T. Coleman
1
3
3.0
0
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
D. Freeman
5
54
10.8
0
J. Jones
4
72
18.0
0
J. Tamme
4
31
7.7
0
S. Chandler
4
23
5.7
0
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
0
0
1
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
M. Bryant
1/2
2/2
5
47
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
M. Bosher
8
457
57.1
1
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
E. Weems
3
71
23.6
0
D. Hester
1
23
23.0
0
PUNT RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
D. Hester
2
19
9.5
0
Oakland Raiders
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
D. Carr
24/33
252
2
1
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Jones
29
158
5.4
1
L. Murray
2
13
6.5
0
D. Carr
2
-2
-1.0
0
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
M. Reece
10
71
7.1
0
A. Holmes
6
78
13.0
0
A. Cooper
4
43
10.7
0
M. Crabtree
1
17
17.0
1
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
5
0
1
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
S. Janikowski
0/0
4/4
4
0
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
M. King
5
268
53.6
1
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Carrie
2
47
23.5
0
T. Jones
2
47
23.6
0
A. Cooper
1
25
25.0
0
PUNT RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Carrie
1
18
18.0
0
T. Jones
1
11
11.0
0
As you can see, my running game has probably had too much success, but I do love my running game... These were both based on your most recent update. Thanks for putting in all this work, it really makes my play time enjoyable.
Mike when you sim the season what are you doing to offset the fact that teams #1 wr's are lining up on the left side of the field. Is everyone just changing their team to have there best cb on the left side? I do this in game I'm wondering if moving revis to 2nd CB will hurt his confidence or his progression.
Also I have noticed that WR swap doesn't work in the sub formations this is getting very frustrating.
Mike when you sim the season what are you doing to offset the fact that teams #1 wr's are lining up on the left side of the field. Is everyone just changing their team to have there best cb on the left side? I do this in game I'm wondering if moving revis to 2nd CB will hurt his confidence or his progression.
Also I have noticed that WR swap doesn't work in the sub formations this is getting very frustrating.
I have not since this is likely being patched in the first (second) patch. By all means, it won't hurt anything, but to be fair, I'd also swap your CBs too
I've been using various sliders on this forum for a while now, but I thought it was about time I started to pitch in. Here are the boxscores from my first two games on 17. I play Coach Mode almost exclusively (minus the occasional disruption on defence).
For the first game (as the Raiders against the Saints), please switch around the team stats:
Oakland Raiders at New Orleans Saints
Jan 1,
1ST
2ND
3RD
4TH
SCORE
Oakland Raiders (1-0)
0
17
10
3
30
New Orleans Saints (0-1)
3
3
7
0
13
Team Stats Comparison
OAK
NOR
Total Offense
511
261
Rushing Yards
244
78
Passing Yards
267
183
First Downs
28
17
Punt Return Yards
19
0
Kick Return Yards
80
107
Total Yards
610
368
Turnovers
3
4
3rd Down Converstion
12
5
4th Down Conversion
2
0
2-Point Conversion
0
0
Red Zone Touchdowns/Field Goals
2/2
1/0
Penalties
10
53
Posession Time
34:13
25:47
Oakland Raiders
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
D. Brees
28/41
211
0
3
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
M. Ingram
11
91
8.4
1
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
J. Hill
9
56
6.2
B. Hartline
6
48
8.0
M. Thomas
4
37
9.3
V. Brown
4
38
9.5
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
1
3
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
C. Barth
2/2
1/1
7
55
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
T. Morstead
3
168
56.0
1
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
W. Snead
3
80
26.7
0
C. Spiller
1
27
27.0
0
New Orleans Saints
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
D. Carr
29/39
275
2
3
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
L. Murray
42
213
5.1
1
T. Jones
1
28
28.0
0
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
M. Reece
7
64
9.1
0
A. Holmes
7
66
9.4
0
A. Cooper
5
52
10.7
0
M. Crabtree
4
43
10.8
2
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
4
3
0
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
S. Janikowski
3/3
3/3
12
44
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
M. King
0
0
0
0
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Jones
3
80
26.7
0
PUNT RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Jones
1
19
19.0
0
Atlanta Falcons at Oakland Raiders
Jan 1,
1ST
2ND
3RD
4TH
SCORE
Atlanta Falcons (0-2)
3
7
7
6
23
Oakland Raiders (2-0)
14
14
0
0
28
Team Stats Comparison
ATL
OAK
Total Offense
308
421
Rushing Yards
89
169
Passing Yards
219
252
First Downs
15
15
Punt Return Yards
19
29
Kick Return Yards
94
119
Total Yards
421
569
Turnovers
1
3
3rd Down Converstion
3-14
4-12
4th Down Conversion
0-1
0-2
2-Point Conversion
0-1
0-0
Red Zone Touchdowns/Field Goals
2/0
2/0
Penalties
2-10
0-0
Posession Time
36:05
23:55
Atlanta Falcons
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
M. Ryan
28/40
269
1
1
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
D. Freeman
24
86
3.5
1
T. Coleman
1
3
3.0
0
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
D. Freeman
5
54
10.8
0
J. Jones
4
72
18.0
0
J. Tamme
4
31
7.7
0
S. Chandler
4
23
5.7
0
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
0
0
1
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
M. Bryant
1/2
2/2
5
47
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
M. Bosher
8
457
57.1
1
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
E. Weems
3
71
23.6
0
D. Hester
1
23
23.0
0
PUNT RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
D. Hester
2
19
9.5
0
Oakland Raiders
PASSING
C/A
YDS
TD
INT
D. Carr
24/33
252
2
1
RUSHING
ATT
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Jones
29
158
5.4
1
L. Murray
2
13
6.5
0
D. Carr
2
-2
-1.0
0
RECEIVING
REC
YDS
AVG
TD
M. Reece
10
71
7.1
0
A. Holmes
6
78
13.0
0
A. Cooper
4
43
10.7
0
M. Crabtree
1
17
17.0
1
DEFENSE
TACK
SACK
INT
TD
TEAM
5
0
1
KICKING
FG
XP
PTS
LONG
S. Janikowski
0/0
4/4
4
0
PUNTING
NO
YDS
AVG
IN20
M. King
5
268
53.6
1
KICK RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Carrie
2
47
23.5
0
T. Jones
2
47
23.6
0
A. Cooper
1
25
25.0
0
PUNT RETURN
RET
YDS
AVG
TD
T. Carrie
1
18
18.0
0
T. Jones
1
11
11.0
0
As you can see, my running game has probably had too much success, but I do love my running game... These were both based on your most recent update. Thanks for putting in all this work, it really makes my play time enjoyable.
Thanks so much for this. It's a tough balance limiting the TFL and still having a challenging run game. TFL is the biggest difference I'm seeing during PTM games and fully played games. Of course, more simmed plays are going to equal less TFL (and assisted tackles), so it's not surprising.
Hey, so I just completed my first game with these sliders, and I have to say, that was the most balanced and realistic felt game I have played in this years game. In the past, I would have problems with the CPU force feeding 1 RB the ball 25+ times a game & running it down my throat. This actually felt fair here. I was the Cowboys in this game. I read through this thread and made changes before playing a game. Was worth it! Thanks for these sliders.