M17 XP Slider Discussion

[Smallville102001]

Quote: Originally Posted by tdawg3782

1st sim is in the books. I forgot how long it takes recordering the data lol. Anyways here we go: Rules: 75 Man Preseason Roster/XP Sliders all at 100%/Progress set to Every 4 Weeks How to read chart: Base is how many players were rated in each group and +10 Years is how many after simming 10 seasons. The % is just the % of players rated in each group to give you a visual that way. Total is the total amount of players rated 80+. QB:100% Spoiler QB Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 3 4 11.54% 11.11% 90-94 3 3 11.54% 8.33% 85-89 7 7 26.92% 19.44% 80-84 13 22 50.00% 61.11% Total 26 36 100.00% 100.00% So we had 10 more players above 80 then the original rosters. Kind of deep on talent but then again the top end players matched up perfect. If we drop the % then I would imagine they would drop to. However if you want a little less talent at the QB position then that would be perfect. For me I will try 90% next. HB:100% Spoiler HB Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 90-94 4 2 12.90% 8.70% 85-89 5 6 16.13% 26.09% 80-84 22 15 70.97% 65.22% Total 31 23 100.00% 100.00% This was one of the only positions to drop the total from the base. This isn't bad really. Personally I'd like a little more out of the position. I like how the base was set. I'm going to try 120% next. FB:100% Spoiler FB Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 90-94 1 0 8.33% 0.00% 85-89 4 3 33.33% 23.08% 80-84 7 10 58.33% 76.92% Total 12 13 100.00% 100.00% FB isn't a strong position in Madden to start with. The position is fading out in the league for the most part. These numbers look consistent so I'm going to keep it at 100%. FYI the lone 90+ guy in the base roster was Marcell Reese who isn't really even a FB. WR:100% Spoiler WR Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 2 0 3.92% 0.00% 90-94 13 2 25.49% 3.17% 85-89 14 12 27.45% 19.05% 80-84 22 49 43.14% 77.78% Total 51 63 100.00% 100.00% Here is were things get tough. 12 more players rated over 80 this time. Not crazy but a decent amount. But they are clumped mostly between 80-84. If we raise it we will probably see a few more top end players but may still have a clump at the bottom resulting in 80+ give or take WRs over 80. Catch-22 (no pun intended lol). I think I'll try 110% to see what happens. TE:100% Spoiler TE Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 1 2 4.00% 6.45% 90-94 3 3 12.00% 9.68% 85-89 4 12 16.00% 38.71% 80-84 17 14 68.00% 45.16% Total 25 31 100.00% 100.00% This isn't bad. 7 more players rated over 80 then base. Lot more 85-89 guys but this wouldn't be a bad spot to keep it. I'm hesitant to lower things when I see the top end (90+) right where I like it but I think I'm going for 90% nest sim. T:100% Spoiler T Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 3 0 6.98% 0.00% 90-94 4 4 9.30% 9.09% 85-89 12 10 27.91% 22.73% 80-84 24 30 55.81% 68.18% Total 43 44 100.00% 100.00% Pretty good we are just missing those couple beast tackles. This is honestly a really good result though. I'm going to do 110% next just to see what happens. G:100% Spoiler G Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 1 0 3.45% 0.00% 90-94 3 0 10.34% 0.00% 85-89 9 3 31.03% 13.64% 80-84 16 19 55.17% 86.36% Total 29 22 100.00% 100.00% The guard position was pretty weak to start with and now they are even worse. This position needs help in my opinion. Think I'll go up to 130% for next sim. C:100% Spoiler C Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 90-94 1 0 6.25% 0.00% 85-89 6 1 37.50% 7.14% 80-84 9 13 56.25% 92.86% Total 16 14 100.00% 100.00% Another kind of weak position to start with that got worse. Going to go with 130% for next sim like guard. DE:100% Spoiler DE Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 1 3 3.23% 6.98% 90-94 9 3 29.03% 6.98% 85-89 15 15 48.39% 34.88% 80-84 6 22 19.35% 51.16% Total 31 43 100.00% 100.00% This was an odd position to start with. Lots of good talent with 48% of the players coming in the 85-89 range and 29% in the 90-94 range which was more the the 80-84 range. After the 10 year sim it balanced out a bit which is what I like to see. A few with 90+, some with 85-89, and the bulk 80-84. We have 12 more players above 80 then base but this seems good to me. Will leave at 100% DT:100% Spoiler DT Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 1 0 4.17% 0.00% 90-94 5 3 20.83% 8.82% 85-89 4 5 16.67% 14.71% 80-84 14 26 58.33% 76.47% Total 24 34 100.00% 100.00% 10 more players above 80 then base. This is where I get scared. I'd like to see at least 1 at 95+ but then we will start seeing a problem with depth being too good. If we raise the % we could have another 10 guys above 80 which seems excessive. Then again I don't know how touchy the XP sliders will be so who knows. Gonna leave at 100% for now. OLB:100% Spoiler OLB Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 3 2 6.67% 3.39% 90-94 8 9 17.78% 15.25% 85-89 11 14 24.44% 23.73% 80-84 23 34 51.11% 57.63% Total 45 59 100.00% 100.00% OLB seemed like an over powered position compared to other positions at base. 11 guys 90+. This stayed pretty consistent. 14 more players 80+ then base but 85+ looks about the same. Depends on what you want. I will drop it to 90% because I'd like to see a little less talent overall. MLB:100% Spoiler MLB Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 1 0 5.88% 0.00% 90-94 1 3 5.88% 11.54% 85-89 6 11 35.29% 42.31% 80-84 9 12 52.94% 46.15% Total 17 26 100.00% 100.00% I thought MLB was a little weak to start but it balanced out pretty good. 9 more players 80+ and no 95+ guy but I like this result. Keeping at 100% CB:100% Spoiler CB Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 1 1 3.13% 3.57% 90-94 7 0 21.88% 0.00% 85-89 13 11 40.63% 39.29% 80-84 11 16 34.38% 57.14% Total 32 28 100.00% 100.00% Was surprised this one dropped. Think it needs some help for sure. Only 1 player 90+ isn't going to cut it especially since I want to up WR XP. Going to go with 120% next sim. FS:100% Spoiler FS Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 2 0 7.41% 0.00% 90-94 5 0 18.52% 0.00% 85-89 5 17 18.52% 51.52% 80-84 15 16 55.56% 48.48% Total 27 33 100.00% 100.00% This was a really strange one. This position was loaded on the base roster. After sim we have 6 more players 80+ but none 90+. I think we have to up it but I'm just afraid of, like the DT situation, that depth will be a problem. I mean 33 players 80+ is enough for every team to start a 80+ FS. But I don't like having 0 elite guys. Will go with 110% next sim. SS:100% Spoiler SS Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 90-94 2 4 12.50% 10.53% 85-89 6 16 37.50% 42.11% 80-84 8 18 50.00% 47.37% Total 16 38 100.00% 100.00% This one was crazy. Not much talent to start and then it blew up after the sim. 22 more players 80+ the base. That's insane. That's 6 more players then we originally had to start with. Anyways I think I have to drop this. Will go down to 90% for next sim. K:100% Spoiler K Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 90-94 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 85-89 0 1 0.00% 11.11% 80-84 7 8 100.00% 88.89% Total 7 9 100.00% 100.00% Not sure why Ks are rated so low this year but there must be a reason. This matched up almost perfect and I see no reason to change it. Leaving at 100% P:100% Spoiler P Base +10 Years Base % +10 Years % 95-99 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 90-94 0 0 0.00% 0.00% 85-89 0 2 0.00% 16.67% 80-84 5 10 100.00% 83.33% Total 5 12 100.00% 100.00% Same as Ks, Ps are rated pretty low this year. 7 more players 80+ then base but I don't have a problem with this number. Leaving at 100% So there you have it guys. Sim 1 in the books and I think we got some good data. My suggestions are what I'm looking for in this game and the may not coincide with yours so you don't have to agree at all lol. Just take the info and do what you want with it. But my goal is to hopefully find a really good base where we can start so all my fellow franchise guys who like to go years into theirs can have an enjoyable experience. And if all else fails at least we can edit everything (Thanks for that EA).

Interesting results would be interesting to see reslults at 0% and 200% to see just how big the difference is.

[queenie.paula]

anyone have a good realistic xp slider set?

[zackebarsch10]

Quote: Originally Posted by queenie.paula

anyone have a good realistic xp slider set?

TDawg's Madden 17 XP Sliders

https://r.tapatalk.com/shareLink?url...3&share_type=t


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

[queenie.paula]

Quote: Originally Posted by zackebarsch10

TDawg's Madden 17 XP Sliders https://r.tapatalk.com/shareLink?url...3&share_type=t Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

I was gonna use those, but wasn't sure