Top 10 QBs?

[SPTO]

Hm let's see

1. Brady
2. P. Manning
3. Big Ben
4. Palmer
5. Romo
6. Brees
7. Favre
8. Hasselbeck
9. McNabb
10. Gerrard

[wwharton]

Quote: Originally Posted by dirk360

i have to admit i'm not completely sold on romo yet.

I'm not either but I feel the same way about Gerrard and Big Ben (on that list). I think all 3 are top 10 in the systems their teams run, but I question all of them more than the others when they have to step outside of their comfort zone. I think Ben is the most likely to make that jump and Romo the less likely to have to as long as TO's in Dallas.

Question to tdawg3782... if it's based on 3 years how can you go with Gerrard and not Favre? They both fall short on that criteria. By the way, I feel you on Favre, especially at his age. I just think going into 08 based on the info we have over the past 3 years, both of these guys come with the same amount of question marks on whether they can repeat their 07 performances.

[Double Eights]

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Brett Favre
4. Donovan McNabb
5. Tony Romo
6. Ben Roethlisberger
7. Carson Palmer
8. Drew Brees
9. Matt Hasselbeck
10. Eli Manning

[dirk360]

Quote: Originally Posted by tdawg3782

Ya. He only played this one year but he had a pretty damn good one so he just squeezed into my Top 10.

yeah, he had a really good year but its too bad he didn't make the pro bowl. i'm not sure garrard will ever make the pro bowl considering he plays in the afc with brady,manning,palmer, and roth.

[bkrich83]

My list would look something like this for a Top 10

1. Tom Brady
1a. Peyton Manning
3. Carson Palmer
4. Brett Favre
5. Drew Brees
6. Tony Romo
7. Big Ben
8. Matt Hasselbeck
9. Donovan McNabb
10. Marc Bulger

[dirk360]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

My list would look something like this for a Top 10 1. Tom Brady 1a. Peyton Manning 3. Carson Palmer 4. Brett Favre 5. Drew Brees 6. Tony Romo 7. Big Ben 8. Matt Hasselbeck 9. Donovan McNabb 10. Marc Bulger

pretty good list.

[wwharton]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

My list would look something like this for a Top 10 1. Tom Brady 1a. Peyton Manning 3. Carson Palmer 4. Brett Favre 5. Drew Brees 6. Tony Romo 7. Big Ben 8. Matt Hasselbeck 9. Donovan McNabb 10. Marc Bulger

I think that mirrors mine, just in a different order. I wouldn't argue the order at all accept for Favre, who I think could end up deserving the 4 spot at the end of next year, but I agree with some of the others that it's not such a sure thing based on the few years before. But then again I have McNabb and Bulger ranked pretty high with just as much speculation around their future... especially McNabb who can't seem to stay healthy.

[dirk360]

Quote: Originally Posted by wwharton

I think that mirrors mine, just in a different order. I wouldn't argue the order at all accept for Favre, who I think could end up deserving the 4 spot at the end of next year, but I agree with some of the others that it's not such a sure thing based on the few years before. But then again I have McNabb and Bulger ranked pretty high with just as much speculation around their future... especially McNabb who can't seem to stay healthy.

mcnabb just really needs to stay HEALTHY for the entire season! i can't emphasize this enough!