If the Super Bowl was tomorrow what current QB would you have on your team?

[Buckeyes_Doc]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

I would pick Brady how could you not? But why isnt Who Dat DREW BREEEEES a choice?

I only posted QB's who have won super bowls recently, I know Brees is having a great year and is a top 5 QB, sorry lol. Thats why I put other.

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

I would pick Brady how could you not? But why isnt Who Dat DREW BREEEEES a choice?

He's won 1 Playoff game, has played in just 3 total.

[Kriech23]

I'll take Roethlisberger, he has 2 rings, 16 fourth quarter comeback wins in a relatively short amount of time. He is clutch when he needs to be. Their defense obviously helps them out, but that drive at the end of the super bowl last year was enough for me to take him. (I'd be fine with Brady though)

[bkrich83]

If the SB was tomorrow?

Manning, outside of Drew Brees, I don't think anyone is playing anywhere near the level he is right now.

[TheWatcher]

Well, Manning worries me in the playoffs. He didn't play very well at all in the Wild Card or the Divisional playoff of his Super Bowl season. Both Roethlisberger and Brady have been big reasons why their teams have gotten there, rather than in spite of.

Eli had one helluva 2007 postseason. But...

You gotta go wth Brady. His record speaks for itself and he was one legendary defensive meltdown from a 4th Super Bowl win.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

I went with Big Ben, almost solely because of the way he led them to their victory a year ago. That was one hell of a drive, and from the games I've seen so far this year, it doesn't appear that it was a fluke. For whatever reason, when the Steelers need points, he seems to step up the vast majority of the time, and he can make it happen even with a bad O-Line with his ability to avoid sacks (whereas Brady would be in trouble). Also, if a play breaks down, he's enough of a threat that he can run for a good chunk of yards and get out of bounds, which Brady also struggles with. Obviously, you can't really go wrong with either one, but I'll take Big Ben.

[Sandman42]

Peyton.

[Pacman83]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheWatcher

Well, Manning worries me in the playoffs. He didn't play very well at all in the Wild Card or the Divisional playoff of his Super Bowl season. Both Roethlisberger and Brady have been big reasons why their teams have gotten there, rather than in spite of. Eli had one helluva 2007 postseason. But... You gotta go wth Brady. His record speaks for itself and he was one legendary defensive meltdown from a 4th Super Bowl win.

Not picking on you, but they didnt score...plain and simple the offense got shut down.

NE way, i believe Brady is a product of the system. Peyton is the system...Brady has playmakers, Peyton makes playmakers...imho. Not big on either overall, both would get it done....but ima go with Peyton, think hes a better overall QB.