2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[Dienerbird55]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Keep A-Rod, he always retires. Cano= Two A's and a very High B, at least. Sabathia is the same. Granderson is two B's and an A. Soriano is three mid B's. Kuroda is two B's. Tex is an A and two B's.

Here's my proposed trades. Going off of ACMilan's suggestions, did I trade fair for the most part, or was it just some pipe dream trading?
TRADE:
NYY receives: O.Infante 2B(B), N.Perio 2B(B)
MIA receives: A.Rodriguez 3B
TRADE:
NYY receives: Z.Lee SP (A), D.Gordon SS (A), J.Lindblom RP (B)
LAD receives: R.Cano 2B
TRADE:
NYY receives: D.Smyly SP (A), J.Turner SP (A), D.Fields CF (B)
DET receives: C.Sabathia SP, M.Mesa CF
TRADE:
NYY receives: A.Craig RF (A), K.Wong 2B (B), R.Jackson SS (B), E.Sanchez RP (B), A.Serrano SP (B)
StL receives: M.Teixeira 1B, R.Soriano CP, R.Mustelier 2B
Makes StL Bullpen stronger in the 8th and 9th with Soriano/Motte
TRADE:
NYY receives: M.Saunders CF (B), F. Martinez 3B (B)
SEA receives: H.Kuroda SP
TRADE:
NYY receives: M.Moreland 1B (B), T.Scheppers RP (B)
TEX receives: C.Granderson CF, D.Phelps SP ( C)
Josh Hamilton moves back to LF, Granderson takes over CF.
TRADE:
NYY receives: R.Doumit C
MIN receives: R.Martin C
I liked hitting with Doumit in exhibition games. I can’t hit with Martin worth anything. Plus, Doumit is a switch hitter.

[AC]

Here's my proposed trades. Going off of ACMilan's suggestions, did I trade fair for the most part, or was it just some pipe dream trading?
TRADE:
NYY receives: O.Infante 2B(B), N.Perio 2B(B)
MIA receives: A.Rodriguez 3B
TRADE:
NYY receives: Z.Lee SP (A), D.Gordon SS (A), J.Lindblom RP (B)
LAD receives: R.Cano 2B
TRADE:
NYY receives: D.Smyly SP (A), J.Turner SP (A), D.Fields CF (B)
DET receives: C.Sabathia SP, M.Mesa CF
TRADE:
NYY receives: A.Craig RF (A), K.Wong 2B (B), R.Jackson SS (B), E.Sanchez RP (B), A.Serrano SP (B)
StL receives: M.Teixeira 1B, R.Soriano CP, R.Mustelier 2B
Makes StL Bullpen stronger in the 8th and 9th with Soriano/Motte
TRADE:
NYY receives: M.Saunders CF (B), F. Martinez 3B (B)
SEA receives: H.Kuroda SP
TRADE:
NYY receives: M.Moreland 1B (B), T.Scheppers RP (B)
TEX receives: C.Granderson CF, D.Phelps SP ( C)
Josh Hamilton moves back to LF, Granderson takes over CF.
TRADE:
NYY receives: R.Doumit C
MIN receives: R.Martin C
I liked hitting with Doumit in exhibition games. I can’t hit with Martin worth anything. Plus, Doumit is a switch hitter.

These teams would never make these trades. For a quick example, rebuilding Seattle doesn't need Kuroda.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[Dienerbird55]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

These teams would never make these trades. For a quick example, rebuilding Seattle doesn't need Kuroda.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

Whoops, I never even put that into consideration. I was trying to find a West coast team to ship him to. Well...back to the drawing board I guess.

[AC]

Whoops, I never even put that into consideration. I was trying to find a West coast team to ship him to. Well...back to the drawing board I guess.

Lol just take needs and state of their organization into account and you'll be good.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[D0GGERT D0G]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I got Josh Hamilton for Tim Lincecum and Brett Pill in my SF Giants franch

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Whoops, I never even put that into consideration. I was trying to find a West coast team to ship him to. Well...back to the drawing board I guess.

I'll put s trades together for you and let me know what you think

Sabathia- Dodgers
For- Lee, Reed, Evoladi

Cano- Cardinals
Martinez/Miller, Taveras, Wong

Texeira- Blue Jays
For- Gose, Hutchison, Syndrgard

Granderson- Texas
For- Perez, Ramirez

Kuroda- Pirates (if theyre in the race)
For- Cain, Dodson

Rodriguez- D Backs
For-Meo and Owings

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'll put s trades together for you and let me know what you think

Sabathia- Dodgers
For- Lee, Reed, Evoladi

Cano- Cardinals
Martinez/Miller, Taveras, Wong

Texeira- Blue Jays
For- Gose, Hutchison, Syndrgard

Granderson- Texas
For- Perez, Ramirez

Kuroda- Pirates (if theyre in the race)
For- Cain, Dodson

Rodriguez- D Backs
For-Meo and Owings

I got Josh Hamilton for Tim Lincecum and Brett Pill in my SF Giants franch

I like them all except for the Jays one. It's completely fair, but the Jays wouldn't trade top prospects within their division, and I doubt the Yanks would trade Tex inter-division. How about;

Tex- Milwuakee
For- Peralta, Thornburg, Jungmann

Tex-Washington
For- Rendon, Goodwin, Myer

Also, are you sure they'd deal Grandy to their rival in Texas?

Granderson-San Fran
For- Hembree, Joseph, Panik

Granderson- Atlanta (Convert him to LF before you make this trade)
For- Simmonds, Vizcaino

[fran33s]

I am the Royals. I played 15 games then simmed to current day, and
Played 3 games. Moustakas and Perez are lighting it up batting .330 each with some power(combined 16 home runs). Kole Kalhoun who came over with Vernon Wells in the Joakim Soria trade is batting .370 with 4 home runs in 16 games(off bench).


Billy butler is my problem. I love the guy in real life, but in the game he is a double play machine for me and is only hitting .220 with 6 homers... I don't know what I should do... Maybe trade him? Or keep And hope to break out of it? My pitching is fine, and I'm throwing well and I have a ton of prospects. I just can't hit with him/he's having a subpar season. He does have a lot of value too.. And it would allow me to have Kalhoun play DH more often since he is having phenomenal season off the bench. I don't know yet...

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I like them all except for the Jays one. It's completely fair, but the Jays wouldn't trade top prospects within their division, and I doubt the Yanks would trade Tex inter-division. How about;

Tex- Milwuakee
For- Peralta, Thornburg, Jungmann

Tex-Washington
For- Rendon, Goodwin, Myer

Also, are you sure they'd deal Grandy to their rival in Texas?

Granderson-San Fran
For- Hembree, Joseph, Panik

Granderson- Atlanta (Convert him to LF before you make this trade)
For- Simmonds, Vizcaino

I knew you were gonna have a problem with the Jays one like you always do, these are not realistic at all obviously all these are just fair and fit needs and I think this would really help the Jays so I think it would work

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I like them all except for the Jays one. It's completely fair, but the Jays wouldn't trade top prospects within their division, and I doubt the Yanks would trade Tex inter-division. How about;

Tex- Milwuakee
For- Peralta, Thornburg, Jungmann

Tex-Washington
For- Rendon, Goodwin, Myer

Also, are you sure they'd deal Grandy to their rival in Texas?

Granderson-San Fran
For- Hembree, Joseph, Panik

Granderson- Atlanta (Convert him to LF before you make this trade)
For- Simmonds, Vizcaino

Again there rivals aren't even Texas different divisions and just cause they're both really good doesn't mean the trade can't happen. They have the money to take him on and it fits a need.

[Dienerbird55]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'll put s trades together for you and let me know what you think

Sabathia- Dodgers
For- Lee, Reed, Evoladi

Cano- Cardinals
Martinez/Miller, Taveras, Wong

Texeira- Blue Jays
For- Gose, Hutchison, Syndrgard

Granderson- Texas
For- Perez, Ramirez

Kuroda- Pirates (if theyre in the race)
For- Cain, Dodson

Rodriguez- D Backs
For-Meo and Owings

I like them all except for the Jays one. It's completely fair, but the Jays wouldn't trade top prospects within their division, and I doubt the Yanks would trade Tex inter-division. How about;

Tex- Milwuakee
For- Peralta, Thornburg, Jungmann

Tex-Washington
For- Rendon, Goodwin, Myer

Also, are you sure they'd deal Grandy to their rival in Texas?

Granderson-San Fran
For- Hembree, Joseph, Panik

Granderson- Atlanta (Convert him to LF before you make this trade)
For- Simmonds, Vizcaino

I like the ideas behind some of these trades! I'm trying to find out which of these deals are going to help me best fill in the positions i'm losing by trading these guys before I pull the trigger.(I can't find some of the guys mentioned though, ex. Dodson, Pirates) Thanks for the suggestions!

[s0xfan09]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Well looks like my Youkilis trade was just a TAD off lol.

As for Royals guy, what AL teams are in the playoff race? Are you in it? Butler is a solid hitter but hes pretty much just a DH who doesn't have a ton of power which cuts down his value. What are you looking for in return?

[survo202]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

2 mid B's would be fine

What about Buehrle for Lewis? I'm aware that the Marlin's wouldn't trade him but I'm a big fan of his.

Also what is feliz's value? I may trade him but I'm not sure yet.

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What about Buehrle for Lewis? I'm aware that the Marlin's wouldn't trade him but I'm a big fan of his.

Also what is feliz's value? I may trade him but I'm not sure yet.

Buehrle is better than Lewis but He's also pretty old so I'd say maybe add a high C and then it'd be fine. Feliz probably 2 High B's .... not worth an A yet because we haven't seen enough of him as a starter and I'm never gonna give up an A for a reliever

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Buehrle is better than Lewis but He's also pretty old so I'd say maybe add a high C and then it'd be fine. Feliz probably 2 High B's .... not worth an A yet because we haven't seen enough of him as a starter and I'm never gonna give up an A for a reliever

Not even for Johnny Venters, Craig Kimbrel, David Hernandez, etc.?