The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Ninja Tactic

I hate when people say things are unrealistic. I'm pretty sure last year if u would've said u had lebron wade and bosh on one team someone would've said its unrealistic. But buddy it happened. If its for the betterment of ur team, then do Wat u have to do

Are you referring to me? The guy asked which trade scenario would be most realistic and I answered.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by rocketsfan81

I am the Rockets and I did this trade: Chuck Hayes For The Cavs 1st round pick(2011)

Kinda defies the improved AI logic since the Cavs are rebuilding and the Rockets are the playoff team but I still say that's a robbery for you.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Uncle Way

Finally said **** it and shipped off Arenas.. Wizards Get:: (C) Tyson Chandler (SG) John Salmons (PG) J.J. Barea '11 1st Rd Pick(from Mavs) Bucks Get:: (PG)Kirk Hinrich (PF) Hilton Armstong Mavs Get:: Gilbert Arenas Love the new trade engine...

I don't really get the deal from the Bucks perspective, but pretty good deal for the Mavs and Wizards

[goh]

Quote: Originally Posted by Freak123

Well yeah but I only got Gibson and Moon for him...and he's averaging over 21 PPG, over 3 APG, and over 3 RPG while shooting over 50% from the field and over 44% from behind the arc, so he's helping their team significantly. Anywho, would still like opinions on my trade if possible, also another PG went on the block and I'm considering this as well as anything is better than Chalmers... Heat get: Mike Bibby 2nd round pick Hawks get: Daniel Gibson Timefey Mosgov 1st round pick (via the Celtics)

No one in that division would help out the Heat like that. Cavs and Raptors wouldn't either. Doubt anyone in conference would. Try the Clippers or T'Wolves. Hmm lesse...you can trade Chalmers and MaGloire for Ridnour. That's better,at least in sim terms.

[richyung62]

Sup guys,

Bulls Assoc. I need another valuable player who can create off the dribble instead of D.Rose, it gets kind of boring runnin aroun with him until someone gets open or cut to the basket. With that said, I'm looking to Move Deng, Gibson, Brewer and of course Keith Bogan an Jerome James, someone advised me to Trade Deng, James and Gibson for Danny Granger, not bad but do any of you guys have any better ideas, I want someone who can create their own shot.

I was thinking about Deng for Hedo, idk about this one bcuz PHX did send Deng's draft rights to the Bulls.

Gibson and Bogans for McGrady and Summers (no brainer?)

From what I know Melo is impossible to get with the Bulls but any other trade ideas are appreciated, thanks

[canes21]

Pistons Trade:
Ben Wallace 74 OVR (C) 36 Yrs Old
Tracy McGrady 73 OVR (SG) 31 Yrs Old
Chris Wilcox 62 OVR (C) 28 Yrs Old D Potential
2011 1st Round Pick

Celtics Trade:
Shaquille O'Neal 77 OVR (C) 38 Yrs Old
Glen Davis 67 OVR (PF) 24 Yrs Old B- Potential
Avery Bradly 65 OVR (SG) 19 Yrs Old A Potential
Von Wafer 61 OVR (PG) 25 Yrs Old B- Potential

Started out 0-3 with no post game,. I wanted change and wanted to bring in some youth with potential too. I am the Pistons. After this trade, I played the Celtics ironically. I didn't know that was my next game. I lost 86-83 because of one mistake late late in the game. I could have won that game, so I think the trade helped me out a lot.

[RColemanVT]

Quote: Originally Posted by canes21

Pistons Trade: Ben Wallace 74 OVR (C) 36 Yrs Old Tracy McGrady 73 OVR (SG) 31 Yrs Old Chris Wilcox 62 OVR (C) 28 Yrs Old D Potential 2011 1st Round Pick Celtics Trade: Shaquille O'Neal 77 OVR (C) 38 Yrs Old Glen Davis 67 OVR (PF) 24 Yrs Old B- Potential Avery Bradly 65 OVR (SG) 19 Yrs Old A Potential Von Wafer 61 OVR (PG) 25 Yrs Old B- Potential Started out 0-3 with no post game,. I wanted change and wanted to bring in some youth with potential too. I am the Pistons. After this trade, I played the Celtics ironically. I didn't know that was my next game. I lost 86-83 because of one mistake late late in the game. I could have won that game, so I think the trade helped me out a lot.

That actually seems like a pretty good trade. Wallace is a great defensive center and rebounder which the C's love, and you took Avery Bradley out of a pretty bad situation to one where he has the chance to develop and get some PT

[Ninja Tactic]

@ Yeah that guy
No not referring to u lol i posted that because someone annoyed me earlier today about unrealistic trades ex. I traded KG and a 1st for favors, Williams and someone or something else. And he was like oh that's unrealistic. I know it is but it helped my team