MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

[Dirty_D_]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

For the most part, we will say a trade is unrealistic because everyone wants to upgrade their team without giving away anything valuable. I dont know how many Mets questions we have had with only wanting to deal Montero or Smith. People like to think about how much better they can make their team, but they don't look at it from the other side. I'd love to get someone like Gregory Polanco for example but why would the Pirates do that?

Stats are super helpful in determining value.

Yea coming from one of those guys trying to value Montero + Smith high. But thanks to the input most people would move past it. ( I did )

[GamecocksLaw17]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Yea coming from one of those guys trying to value Montero + Smith high. But thanks to the input most people would move past it. ( I did )

I should have mentioned that this was no shot at Mets fans, just the first team and example that came to mind. There are surely others

[Dirty_D_]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

I should have mentioned that this was no shot at Mets fans, just the first team and example that came to mind. There are surely others

lol .... No worries. Again thanks for what you do for the Community I know we all appreciate it on that note what you think about this .... reloaded my franchise to before the trade deadline........

Twins acquire

Matt Moore (10 starts)
W-L 5-3
IP 62.0
SO 70
ERA 4.35
WHIP 1.65

Jake Odorini (10 starts)
W-L 6-2
IP 68.0
SO 52
ERA 4.37
WHIP 1.49

Casey Gillespie (AAA - 40 games) (23yo high C - low B)
AB 163
HR 7
RBI 24
SB 0
AVG .287

Rays acquire

Miguel Sano (43 games)
AB 159
HR 21
RBI 41
AVG .346

**Full disclosure I know Sano is close to untouchable as it gets for a rebuilding club at the age of 22 with team control till 2021 but with no serious pitching prospects coming along besides Jose Berrios + Tyler Jay with an ETA of ending 2016 early 2017 but who knows…

[CBoller1331]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

lol .... No worries. Again thanks for what you do for the Community I know we all appreciate it on that note what you think about this .... reloaded my franchise to before the trade deadline........

Twins acquire

Matt Moore (10 starts)
W-L 5-3
IP 62.0
SO 70
ERA 4.35
WHIP 1.65

Jake Odorini (10 starts)
W-L 6-2
IP 68.0
SO 52
ERA 4.37
WHIP 1.49

Casey Gillespie (AAA - 40 games) (23yo high C - low B)
AB 163
HR 7
RBI 24
SB 0
AVG .287

Rays acquire

Miguel Sano (43 games)
AB 159
HR 21
RBI 41
AVG .346

**Full disclosure I know Sano is close to untouchable as it gets for a rebuilding club at the age of 22 with team control till 2021 but with no serious pitching prospects coming along besides Jose Berrios + Tyler Jay with an ETA of ending 2016 early 2017 but who knows…

Probably gonna need to switch out Moore for Blake Snell.

Since you know that Sano isn't going to get dealt, I won't lecture about it...but I think that means your going to have to give up an "untouchable" guy like Snell.

If you look at any trade for a guy who is not being actively shopped around, you aren't going to get away with trading just guys your looking to move. Your going to have to make some sort of sacrifice.

[Dirty_D_]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Probably gonna need to switch out Moore for Blake Snell.

Since you know that Sano isn't going to get dealt, I won't lecture about it...but I think that means your going to have to give up an "untouchable" guy like Snell.

If you look at any trade for a guy who is not being actively shopped around, you aren't going to get away with trading just guys your looking to move. Your going to have to make some sort of sacrifice.

So this should work Vaule wis, package built around Snell + Odorizzi + Gillespie

or I'm i at the point of just controlling the Twins and retire as Rays GM ?

[holden57]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Anyone have any ideas of any bench utility players that could be available? I'm assuming the value would be something like a high C prospect? Only player I can think of is Brock Holt, but I'm the Blue Jays so a trade is very unlikely.

Thanks!

[Nulap]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

I'm curious as to how much, if any, impact statements such as these would have on trade value of Padres players in general and James Shields in particular.

San Diego Padres exec calls his team 'miserable failures' http://teamstre.am/1sMNtCt

[Dirty_D_]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Anyone have any ideas of any bench utility players that could be available? I'm assuming the value would be something like a high C prospect? Only player I can think of is Brock Holt, but I'm the Blue Jays so a trade is very unlikely.

Thanks!

I see Brock as a mid B prospect but that's my 2 cent. What about guys like

Chris Coghlan - OAK
Kelly Johnson - ATL
Eric Campbell - NYM

Only guys I can think of not sitting in front of the game that fit your need

[holden57]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

I see Brock as a mid B prospect but that's my 2 cent. What about guys like

Chris Coghlan - OAK
Kelly Johnson - ATL
Eric Campbell - NYM

Only guys I can think of not sitting in front of the game that fit your need

Would love Coghlan but Oakland is still in the playoff race in my franchise so probably not realistic.

Twins are out of it though, would Eduardo Escobar or Danny Santana be available? If so any idea on their value?

[Dirty_D_]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

I'm curious as to how much, if any, impact statements such as these would have on trade value of Padres players in general and James Shields in particular.

San Diego Padres exec calls his team 'miserable failures' http://teamstre.am/1sMNtCt

That is quite a way to alienate yourself from the entire team. It should have a small hit of there players value but not buy much. It's a catch 22. He knows there trash, told everyone he thinks there trash but will give it the old spit shine when someone comes to look at them. lol

[Dirty_D_]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Would love Coghlan but Oakland is still in the playoff race in my franchise so probably not realistic.

Twins are out of it though, would Eduardo Escobar or Danny Santana be available? If so any idea on their value?

Escobar would be the more realistic target for what I believe your trying to give away. (your looking for a unity/bench player) which Santana is not, yea he may have hit his ceiling but at 25 with team control till 2020 you would have to give up a mid C + some kind of lottery ticket for him IMO.

[MindBeats]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

I see Brock as a mid B prospect but that's my 2 cent. What about guys like

Chris Coghlan - OAK
Kelly Johnson - ATL
Eric Campbell - NYM

Only guys I can think of not sitting in front of the game that fit your need

Brock is tearing it up for me in my franchise. Dunno why but I seem to hit very well with him.
That aside, idk what he's worth, but a mid B sounds decent

[ZoeK35]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

I'm looking to add a pitcher in the 3-5 range in my Cubs franchise. I had an offer on the table to the Padres for Cashner. I would give up Underwood, Almora and Corey Black or Oscar de la Cruz is the value about the same.

I would also like to move Rondon and Hammel what would be the expected return for those two. I was thinking a c level prospect for Hammel and maybe a low level B for Rondon.

Thanks for any info

[rovert22044]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Nearing the start of my Astros franchise. I want to make a move at the catcher position, but I think I will pass on Lucroy for now. So I have two questions:

1. What kind of value does Rockies C Tom Murphy have? Would love to deal for him.

2. What kind of value does Astros C Jason Castro have? If I deal for Murphy, I'd like to deal Castro. I know his return would be minimal, but just curious on other people's opinions.

All moves are made before the season starts, so no stats to provide.

Thanks!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[AC]

Re: MLB 16 Trade Discussion Thread

Most of the times that people post stats, others just ignore and say trade isn't realistic irl...

Those are unrelated